AU
CA
CN
HK
JP
NZ
SG
Select a jurisdiction
Australia
Australia
Canada
Canada
China
China
Hong Kong
Hong Kong
Japan
Japan
New Zealand
New Zealand
Singapore
Singapore
Back to home
Australia
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Mortgage. At times, we will also refer to a ‘General Security Deed’ or a ‘Featherweight Security Deed’.
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
There are generally four types of security interests over land. Each security interest is outlined as follows:
Mortgage – a mortgage involves the transfer of title to the land (or other type of property) from the mortgagor (as owner of the land) to the mortgagee (typically, a lender or security trustee depending upon the nature of the loan structure) by way of security for particular obligations. The lender or security trustee would not usually take possession of the mortgaged asset, and the borrower/mortgagor would continue to use and occupy the land. A mortgage can be legal or equitable. A legal mortgage transfers legal title to an asset whereas an equitable mortgage transfers the beneficial interest in an asset. A legal mortgage will be signed as a deed and registered on title whereas an equitable mortgage is typically not signed in this manner, or registered on title.
Charge – a charge over land does not transfer title to the land or convey an existing interest in the land, but provides the lender (as chargee) with the right to sell the land to discharge the debt or secured obligation. As with a mortgage, a charge may also be legal or equitable. A legal charge is one that is registered on the title of the land, whereas an equitable charge is not directly registerable on title. It is uncommon to use an equitable charge over land as a form of security interest in financing transactions. However, if it is used or requested, in Australia we would typically lodge a caveat to protect the lender’s equitable security interest.
Pledge – a pledge arises when personal property or title documents are deposited with the beneficiary of the pledge, with the intention of creating security for the payment of a debt. In relation to land, the pledge of title deeds will create an equitable mortgage over the land. This form of security is also known as a mortgage by deposit of title deeds.
Lien – unlike other forms of security, a lien over land arises at law (either statute or common law). In relation to land, it typically arises automatically in equity and does not require the agreement of the parties to the creation of the quasi security interest. An example of a specific circumstance which would give rise to a lien over real property would be where a vendor who has not been paid the full purchase price for land obtains the benefit of an unpaid vendor’s lien to secure payment of the outstanding purchase price. The lien arises on exchange of the contract for the sale of land. An equitable lien is enforceable by a court order for the sale of the property. A caveat could be lodged to protect the equitable interest in the land created by the lien.
In Australia, and specifically within each jurisdiction, it is common practice in real estate financing transactions to lodge a mortgage (rather than any of the other additional security interests listed above). For the remainder of this survey, our responses will be tailored to mortgages only.
In a typical real estate transaction, the borrower (or mortgagor) will generally also be required by the lender or the security trustee to provide a form of General Security Deed or Featherweight Security Deed. The purpose of these security documents is to provide the lender or security trustee with security over all or substantially all of the borrower’s (or mortgagor’s) assets. This type of security is beneficial as it decreases administration risk if an administrator (in an insolvency scenario) is appointed to the company and the security becomes subject to a moratorium under the Corporations Act (Cth). The administration risk associated (and suffered by the lender or security trustee) is lowered if the financier has security over all or substantially all of the company’s assets.
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Fixed ranking
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
N/A
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
Mortgages
The two particular formalities to be observed when the mortgage is executed are as follows:
Execution protocol; and
Verification of Identity.
Execution Protocol
The execution protocol will differ per jurisdiction (and each titles office is amending its position upon execution due to the introduction of the National Mortgage Form and the response to COVID-19). To assist, we will provide the common form execution protocol used in NSW, Queensland and VIC.
1. New South Wales:
a. The National Mortgage Form must be executed by both parties – counterpart execution is not permitted;
b. If an annexure is included which outlines additional terms and conditions, the first and last page of the annexure must be signed by the mortgagor (or, at the very least, initialled); and
c. Any additional terms and conditions are to be structured as a deed.
2. Queensland:
a. The National Mortgage Form must be executed by both parties – counterpart execution can be permitted in certain circumstances, although no recommended;
b. If an annexure is included which outlines additional terms and conditions, this is usually annexed by way of a Form 20 (QLD specific form) and does not need to be signed by either party.
3. VIC
a. The National Mortgage Form must be signed by the mortgagor – the mortgagee does not execute the same form in VIC.
b. If additional terms and conditions are to be registered with the mortgage, the terms must first be registered as a ‘Memorandum of Common Provisions’ which is not signed by either party. The dealing number associated with the registered MCP will be included on the National Mortgage Form.
Verification of Identity
Prior to, or simultaneously with, execution of the mortgage, the identity of the mortgagee and the mortgagor must be identified by each counsel to ensure that the correct parties are signing and there is no fraudulent activity. In Australia, verification of identity requirements are based off a “VOI Standard” which means that an individual must take reasonable steps to verify the identity of the signor. The VOI Standard incorporates a cascading list of identification documentation to be reviewed and certified copies obtained. For example, we would typically expect each signor to provide:
confirmation that they are empowered to sign i.e. a copy of a registered Power of Attorney, or confirmation that they are a company director or secretary; and
a copy of their driver’s licence and Australian or foreign passport.
VOI procedures must occur before a mortgage can be registered.
Other forms of security
If any other forms of security are being granted i.e. general security deeds, specific security deeds or featherweight security deeds, it is prudent that:
the relevant registrations on the Personal Properties Security Register are made which correlate to, and protect the lender in relation to, the security deed; and
f any original personal property is to be provided (i.e. share or unit certificates), that it is obtained prior to or on settlement.
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
The filing and registration requirements for a mortgage in each Australian jurisdiction differ slightly based upon the introduction of electronic conveyancing on a national scale which encompasses:
the conversion of physical title deeds to electronic title deeds;
the introduction of the National Mortgage Form; and
the introduction of the online conveyancing platform, PEXA which is an Electronic Lodgement Network Operator.
Physical titles vs electronic titles
The use of physical and electronic titles differs per jurisdiction. The current position is as follows:
NSW – NSW is edging towards electronic titles. Currently, titles will be electronic if an ADI (“Authorised Deposit-Taking Institution”) is registered as the mortgage on title. However, if the title is unencumbered or the mortgagee is not an ADI, a physical title will be printed.
QLD – all titles are electronic in Queensland.
IC – VIC is in a similar position to NSW, it is currently moving towards electronic titles unless the title is unencumbered or the mortgagee registered on title is not an ADI.
Western Australia – Western Australia is moving towards electronic titles only. There are still paper titles in circulation however, they are being reduced each time a new registration occurs.
South Australia – Paper titles are no longer accepted in South Australia and duplicates of titles are no longer printed.
Tasmania – Tasmania has not mandated a timeline for the introduction of electronic titles or to subscribe to any form of electronic conveyancing.
Northern Territory – Paper titles are no longer accepted in the Northern Territory and duplicates of titles are no longer printed.
Australian Capital Territory - ACT is moving towards electronic titles only. There are still paper titles in circulation however, they are being reduced each time a new registration occurs.
Introduction of the National Mortgage Form
The National Mortgage Form must be used in all Australian jurisdictions other than the Australian Capital Territory. The previous dealing form for a mortgage will no longer be accepted.
The National Mortgage Form provides two different avenues for ‘additional terms and conditions’ to be registered with a mortgage. Such forms differ on a jurisdictional basis, for example in NSW additional terms and conditions can be registered as an annexure to the mortgage whereas in VIC any form of terms and conditions must be registered as a ‘Memorandum of Common Provisions’ and a dealing number to be included on the National Mortgage Form.
PEXA (Electronic Lodgement Network Operator)
Online conveyancing is optional per jurisdiction and varies among the Australian jurisdictions. Currently, it is only mandated in the following jurisdictions:
New South Wales;
Victoria;
Western Australia; and
South Australia.
It is not used in Tasmania, but is optional in other jurisdictions such as Queensland and the Northern Territory.
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
Yes
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
The settlement process in Australia and the draw down under loans secured by real property differs as to whether settlement is occurring via (1) PEXA (as identified above) or (2) in paper with a physical settlement occurring.
PEXA
If the settlement is to occur via PEXA, the documentation and the funds being provided (as requested at settlement) occurs simultaneously. One cannot occur without the other – as mandated by the electronic system. In practice, the lender (or relevant finance party) will provide the funds into the PEXA workspace however, they will not be withdrawn from the lender’s account and delivered to the borrower’s nominated account(s) until all parties agree that settlement is to occur and the documentation is sent for lodgement.
PAPER
If the settlement is to occur via paper, it is common that the funds will be drawn down prior to settlement to ensure that bank cheques are made available. In practice, the lender will provide the relevant bank cheques at settlement in exchange for the documentation to be registered. Once settlement has been effected (and the funds provided), the lender will attend to the registration of the documentation.
In addition to the actual registration requirements for a mortgage, another consideration for a mortgagee when attempting to register a mortgage is whether a consent regime is applicable and required. Consent to the mortgage may be required in some circumstances, including:
If the land is subject to any development agreement, the consent of development partners may be required.
If the mortgage will be second ranking, the consent of the prior mortgagee will most likely be required to avoid the mortgagor breaching a negative pledge in the first-ranking security. This will apply even if the second mortgage will not be registered. If the second mortgage will be registered on title, the first registered mortgagee will need to provide its consent to the registration.
If there is a caveat registered on title that prevents the registration of a mortgage, the consent of the caveator will be needed to register the mortgage. The parties should investigate any caveat to determine if mortgages are restricted.
Typically, the additional requirements we could impose in these cases are (1) undertakings, and (2) priority notices.
Undertakings
On an ad hoc basis, we request an ‘undertaking’ from the borrower’s counsel (or other parties’ counsel involved in the transaction) to the effect that, if the documentation registered is requisitioned, they must attend to and resolve the requisition within a specified time-frame.
In addition to the above, prior to settlement occurring (whether in paper or PEXA), it is prudent to review all documentation that is intended on being registered to ensure it is in registerable form with no amendments being required.
Priority Notices
To ensure lodgement occurs in the sequential order as required at or after settlement and to ensure that no other documents are lodged in priority, various jurisdictions have the option to lodge a Priority Notice. These jurisdictions include New South Wales, Queensland and Victoria.
A Priority Notice is a notice which is lodged against a title to reserve priority for a pending transaction that will affect that title. When recorded on title, a Priority Notice has a twofold effect:
Reserve priority for the transaction set out in the Priority Notice, and
Notify parties searching the title that a transaction to be lodged against title is imminent.
While a Priority Notice is in effect, any dealing, except those excluded in section 74W(2) of the Real Property Act 1990 NSW or Transfer of Land Act 1958 - Sect 91F Victoria, will lodge and be visible as an unregistered dealing. However, the dealing will only become registered once the following occurs:
The dealing(s) identified in the Priority Notice are lodged and registered on title, or;
The Priority Notice is withdrawn, or;
The Priority Notice expires which generally occurs after 60 days unless it is extended by a period of 30 days (which is optional).
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
N/A
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
N/A
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
N/A
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
N/A
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
N/A
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
Yes
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
N/A
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
No
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
Other risks
What other insurances are usually required?
The typical insurance policies which we would require in a real estate financing transaction are:
insurance over all property which is of an insurable nature for its full insurable value on a reinstatement and replacement basis;
other insurance appropriate to a mortgagor’s business, assets and operations (including worker's compensation, public risk, product liability, business interruption, loss of rent or other insurance reasonably required).
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
We would typically request a valuation:
Prior to funding (to be approved by the lender and the security trustee)
at least once in every 12 month period; and
if the lender, or relevant finance party, suspects that a default (generally defined within the loan agreement) has occurred.
The conditions attached to a valuation in a transaction of this nature include:
it must be prepared on instructions acceptable to the lender (or relevant finance party) and be in form and substance satisfactory to the lender (or relevant finance party);
it must be prepared by a licensed independent property valuer acceptable to, and appointed on terms approved by, the lender (or relevant finance party);
it should be addressed to and capable of being relied on by the lender (or relevant finance party) (with a confirmation that each of those parties has the benefit of the valuer’s professional indemnity insurance policies); and
it must not be dated earlier than 1 month before it is provided to the lender (or relevant finance party).
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
As mentioned above, lenders would typically request a General Security Deed or a Featherweight Security Deed to circumvent any administration risk. Additionally, the other forms of security which could be provided are in the form of ‘Specific Security Deed’ which secures any personal property of the lender.
Examples of personal property include:
company shares;
bank accounts;
receivables or debts owing to the borrower;
motor vehicles, aircrafts, machinery etc; and
financial instruments.
Contacts
Nino Di Bartolomeo
[email protected]
+61 2 9330 8234
Fiona Evans
[email protected]
+61 2 9330 8563
Canada
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Charge/Mortgage
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
A Charge/Mortgage is the market standard security interest for real estate financing transactions in Ontario. The Charge/Mortgage is an instrument registered with the Land Titles Office for the region where the subject property is located. Upon granting and registration of a Charge/Mortgage, the Chargee/Mortgagee obtains a security interest by way of charge with respect to the property. The Mortgages Act, Land Titles Act and Land Registration Reform Act of Ontario prescribe by statute certain rights and terms governing Charges/Mortgages and remedies available to Chargees/Mortgagees; additional terms are often incorporated into the Charge/Mortgage, directly or by reference.
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Fixed ranking (when registered)
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
An unregistered mortgage would have no fixed rank. The creation of this kind of security interest is possible but not customary.
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
An authorised signatory for the registered owner of the interest being charged is required to sign an Acknowledgement & Direction, which is an instrument authorising the applicable solicitor to register of the Charge/Mortgage. Registration is then effected by the solicitor. In other words, there are no formalities required for the creation of the security interest beyond standard execution (signature).
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
Ontario offers a remote, electronic registration system for land titles documentation, which includes Charges/Mortgages. The electronic registration system is known as Teraview.
When registering a Charge/Mortgage electronically, there are various fields that must be completed (some of which are pre-populated) such as the legal description of the property, the name of the chargor and chargee, principal amount of the charge, the other terms of the charge and “law statements” in certain circumstances. Law statements are statements made within the registered instrument to address specific issues which might otherwise prevent registration. Law statements generally replace the need to provide supporting evidence in order for the charge to be accepted for registration; they can only be made by a person entitled to practice law in Ontario. The terms of the charge include the principal, calculation period, balance due date, interest rate, payments, interest adjustment date, payment date, first payment date, last payment date, reference number of standard charge terms, insurance amount and guarantor. Please note that each of these terms need not be completed in order to register the Charge/Mortgage. Standard charge terms set out the terms and conditions of the charge, including, without limitation, the remedies available to the chargee in the event of chargor default. There are various types of standard charge terms – they are filed with the land registrars and are assigned a number such that they can been incorporated by reference into the Charge/Mortgage by use of that number. Sometimes secured parties will supplement the standard charge terms with additional provisions that get attached, along with the standard charge terms, to the charge and registered with the charge.
Once the Charge/Mortgage is registered, it receives an instrument number that immediately appears on the title to the secured property along with the date and time at which the Charge/Mortgage was registered. Following registration, land registrars review the registration and, provided there is no missing information that is required or any other issues, the registration of the Charge/Mortgage will be certified.
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
No
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
N/A
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
Further actions are required for enforcement.
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
The prerequisites vary depending on the enforcement remedy that the secured party intends to exercise and there is a variety of remedies available. Governing legislation such as the Land Registration Reform Act and Mortgages Act statutorily prescribe cure periods available to the debtor within which they can remedy the default before the secured party can enforce and may also provide obligations on the part of the secured party to notify the debtor of the default before it can exercise its remedies and other prerequisites. Similarly, the terms of the mortgage may themselves provide for cure periods or certain prerequisites to be taken before enforcing the security interest. For example, under the Mortgages Act, a secured party that wishes to exercise its power of sale remedy in the event of debtor default must first provide notice to the debtor of its intention to sell the property within a specific number of days during which time the debtor can attempt to cure its default.
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
See note below on prerequisites
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
In Ontario, it is typical for an affiliate of the borrower to enter into guarantees and grant a mortgage as security for the borrower’s loan obligations. The enforcement of the real property real estate security would be subject to the same requirements as outlined herein.
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
See below.
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
It is customary to issue or obtain an enforceability opinion on the Charge/Mortgage (but it is not customary to issue or obtain a security interest opinion in respect thereof). Opinions are customarily given by the borrower’s solicitor.
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
It is customary to obtain a lender’s title insurance policy to protect the lender against a range of risks related to the state of title and the legal compliance of the property.
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
N/A
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
"All-risk" including fire, pipe water, storm and hail
Building and property owner liability insurance
Loss of rent insurance
Other risks
What other insurances are usually required?
The coverage required is extensive and often the previously listed cover is required at minimum; however, typically lenders will conduct their own insurance consultant review.
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
In Ontario, an appraisal is obtained prior to making a loan, however, it is not customary or standard practice to include any ongoing “monitoring” or updated valuations/appraisals.
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
Other types of security that lenders generally ask for may include:
General assignment of leases and rents;
Specific assignment of lease(s);
Assignment of insurance;
Assignment of material contracts;
Personal guarantees or indemnities;
Environmental indemnity;
Share pledges;
Postponements of shareholder loans;
General security agreement over existing and after-acquired personal property including, without limitation, machinery, equipment, inventory, accounts receivable and intellectual property;
Subordination and Standstill or Inter-creditor Agreement(s) with other lenders having registered interests;
Personal Property Security Act registration(s) for personal property used in connection with, related to or located at the subject property, and no-interest letters from other lenders having such registrations;
Notice of security interest; and
Assignment of construction and project management contracts (if a construction facility).
Contacts
China
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Mortgage (Di Ya)
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
A mortgage is a type of security interest that can be created by either a debtor or a third party over a property (including a real estate property) for the benefit of a creditor for the purpose of securing the performance of the underlying debt (without transferring the possession of the mortgaged property) so that when the debtor fails to pay when the debt falls due or upon the occurrence of any trigger event as agreed by the parties, the creditor enjoys a superior claim over unsecured creditors against the value of the mortgaged property (please also read this in conjunction with our answer to question 12).
It is worth mentioning that it is often not so straightforward for an offshore creditor to take a mortgage over a real estate property in China. Not only will this be subject to additional administrative requirement which creates an enforceability issue if not properly handled (please read our answer to question 8), but also it is not so easy for an offshore creditor to enforce security over real estate property within China. In order to address this issue, it is a common practice for an offshore creditor to consider setting up an onshore-offshore linked financing structure. In such a structure, there is going to be an offshore syndicate lending to an offshore borrower, and at the same time, an onshore loan will be made by an onshore syndicate (which usually comprises of the same lenders (through their PRC branches) within the offshore syndicate) to an onshore borrower and the property mortgage will be established securing the liabilities of the onshore loan. This structure would give offshore creditors comfort to a certain extent. In addition, to make the whole structure workable, and link the onshore loan and the offshore loan, there will need to be an intercreditor agreement, as well as cross-default arrangements between the onshore and offshore syndicates. Normally, the onshore facility agreement will mirror the offshore facility agreement in many aspects. The onshore-offshore structure is very popular in the real-estate financing market in China, but it has some inherent risks, especially for offshore creditors as the mortgage over the onshore real estate does not secure the offshore loan. PRC legal advice should be sought on a case-by-case basis.
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
No
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Fixed ranking. Nevertheless, certain creditors’ rights might rank ahead of secured creditors’ rights due to specific legal provisions. For instance, regarding real estate under construction, the contractor's right to receive payment for construction project fees will have priority over the creditors’ rights secured by mortgage.
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
N/A
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
An agreement to create a mortgage over real estate must be executed in the form of a written contract (subject to further registration with the relevant immovable property administration authority and upon which the mortgage is legally established). The contract must specify the type and amount of the secured underlying obligation, the mortgage term, particulars of the mortgaged property, and the scope of the secured liabilities covered by the mortgage. There is no specific witnessing or notarisation requirement in China.
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
The mortgage should be registered with the local immovable property registration authority where the mortgaged property is located. Upon successful registration, a registration certificate in respect of the property will be issued to the mortgagee evidencing the registration of the mortgage.
Generally, there is no restriction in terms of the identity of the mortgagee. However, the practice may vary from region to region, especially for foreign mortgagees, for example, some local authorities may impose certain restrictions or require more onerous documentation in connection with the incorporation of and authorisation by the mortgagee.
Depending on the structure of the underlying financing transaction and mortgage arrangement, a mortgage may also need to be registered with the State Administration of Foreign Exchange (SAFE) (if it constitutes a certain kind of cross-border security under the relevant PRC laws) or otherwise, the enforcement of such mortgage (in particular, the remittance of the enforcement proceeds) would encounter difficulties.
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
Yes
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
In some cases, registration of a mortgage will be treated as a condition precedent to the initial utilisation so that the loan can only be drawn after the registration has been completed, while in some cases, parties may agree to have it as a condition subsequent. For the latter scenario, usually, the lender side would require a security perfection guarantee granted by the sponsor as a condition precedent to the initial utilisation and it will be released upon the perfection of the mortgage (and other security if any).
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
Further actions required for enforcement
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
Mortgages can be enforced (i) when the mortgagor fails to pay when the secured debt becomes due, or (ii) upon any other trigger event that the parties agree that upon the occurrence of such event, the mortgage can be enforced.
If this occurs, the mortgagor and the mortgagee may reach an agreement for the enforcement of the security through auction, sale or conversion of the collateral into moneys; in which case the security enforcement may be carried out by the parties themselves, rather than being carried out under the domination of the relevant PRC court.
If no agreement is reached, the mortgagee may bring litigation for enforcement of the mortgage and concurrently apply to the court for seal-up, attachment or freezing of the collateral.
In PRC, generally it takes at most two instance trials to reach a final judgment. The first instance trial usually takes six months from the date of filing, and three months for the second instance trial from the date of filing, but this could be longer in certain circumstances. In addition, the courts may in very limited circumstances following an initial review, order that a case be re-trialled, which process is likely to take three months from the date of filing.
According to past practice, the enforcement procedure may take as long as one to two years, or even longer, after the creditor obtains a valid enforcement court order.
Under the court enforcement procedures, (i) the property will first be sold by way of an auction; (ii) if the auction has been aborted for three times for whatever reason, the court will order a sale of the property; and (iii) if no one offers to buy the property during the court ordered sale procedure, the mortgagee may choose to take ownership of the property to off-set the sale price from the mortgaged debt, which normally is valued at the floor price of the last auction (Off-set Price). If the amount of proceeds obtained through auction or court ordered sale, or the Off-set Price, cannot fully discharge the mortgaged debt, the mortgagee is entitled to claim any shortfall against the debtor.
If the mortgage is registrable with the SAFE but it has not been registered with SAFE, the enforceability of the mortgage (in particular, the remittance of the enforcement proceeds) may be hampered.
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
It is not easy to enforce a mortgage under PRC law.
In most cases, the secured lender must first obtain an effective judgment/award through arbitration or litigation to recognise the existence/validity of the mortgage. Alternatively, if there is no substantial dispute in the enforcement, the lender may choose to initiate a specific mortgage-enforcement procedure. This would take approximately 2-3 months, which is a more time-efficient method to obtain such order compared to litigation or arbitration, which would be at least 6-9 months.
The lender can then apply to the local court to enforce the judgment/award/order. The court would appoint an agent to appraise the property before appointing a sales agent. The property would be disposed through sale or auction. The proceeds would be held by the court to discharge the secured debt. The entire enforcement process would take around 6-9 months, or perhaps longer.
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
There is no such restriction under PRC law.
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
If the property has been seized by a court before any legal proceeding (litigation or arbitration) commenced by the secured lender, the court that first ordered the seizure will handle the disposal of the property and such disposal will only take place after the disputes before that court have been settled.
Moreover, in the case that the court that first ordered the seizure is slack in the disposal of the property, to take initiative, the lender would need to apply to the court that ordered the seizure in order to transfer the jurisdiction to the court of enforcement. This application process may take several months.
If the borrower enters into judicial bankruptcy restructuring during the course of the mortgage enforcement process, the disposal of the property may be suspended by the court-appointed bankruptcy administrator. If so, the lender would need to file a separate objection procedure to resume the disposal process, provided that the collateral is at risk of damage or significant decrease in value and is not essential to the restructuring.
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
Yes
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
N/A
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
No
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
"All-risk" including fire, pipe water, storm and hail
Other risks
What other insurances are usually required?
Third party liability insurances
(in respect of the real estate property under construction) Construction related insurance
(where the property has been put into operation) Business interruption insurance
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
As a matter of practice, an initial valuation will usually be carried out prior to the initial utilisation. It is very common that a satisfactory property valuation report will be included as a condition precedent item in the facility agreement. The intervals for any subsequent valuation are largely up to the parties’ agreement, but an annual or semi-annual valuation arrangement is frequently seen. In addition, the lender will usually have a right to demand an extra valuation if the lender reasonably believes that there has been a material reduction in the value of the property resulting in the relevant LTV ratio exceeding the agreed standard, but this may vary from case to case.
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
In addition to the mortgage over the property being financed, it is also common for lenders to take:
(where the property has been put into operation) a pledge over the account receivables derived from the operation of the property, for example, lease income.
an assignment of rights and interest under the material contracts in relation to the property, for example the main construction contracts, building management contracts, lease agreements and insurance policies.
a pledge over the shares of the project company that owns the property.
Contacts
Shanghai Pacific Legal
Joy Gao
[email protected]
+86 21 6086 0101
Sophia Zhang
[email protected]
+86 21 6086 0106
Rujie Wen
[email protected]
+86 21 6086 0107
Hong Kong
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Legal charge
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
The market standard form of security interest over land under Hong Kong law is a mortgage by way of legal charge. This is a form of mortgage required by statute and provides the only means by which a legal mortgage of land in Hong Kong can be created. The mortgagee is given a statutory interest in the land which is effectively equivalent to a legal mortgage. It doesn’t transfer title to the mortgagee, but it will give the mortgagee a proprietary interest in the land.
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Fixed ranking
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
N/A
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
As a legal interest, a legal charge must be created by deed. If these requirements are not fulfilled, the intention of the parties is not totally frustrated; the mortgage may instead take effect as an equitable mortgage or charge.
While witnessing is not a legal requirement under Hong Kong law, witnessing/attestation of conveyancing documents is a long established practice in Hong Kong. The Hong Kong Law Society advised that such practice should be followed in order to achieve uniformity and avoid unnecessary misunderstanding and argument among solicitors. Accordingly, while the Hong Kong Law Society has not made such practice mandatory, it strongly recommends that the signatures of parties to a conveyancing document, including a legal charge, be attested or verified by a solicitor acting for such parties. Solicitors and their clerks whose signatures appear on a document whether as witnesses, interpreters, identifiers, verifiers or certifiers should have their names and firm names or company names indicated in legible form in full immediately below their signatures unless their names and firm names or company names appear elsewhere in the same document.
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
A legal charge should be registered at the Hong Kong Land Registry. Non-registration at the Hong Kong Land Registry will render the legal charge null and void against any subsequent bona fide purchaser or mortgagee for valuable consideration. The legal charge should be registered within one month after its execution in order to preserve its priority.
If a legal charge is created by a company incorporated in Hong Kong or a non-Hong Kong company registered under Part 16 of the Companies Ordinance (Cap 622 of the laws of Hong Kong), the legal charge will also need to be registered with the Hong Kong Companies Registry within one month of the date of the creation of the charge. Failure to register the legal charge at the Companies Registry will render it void against a liquidator and any creditor of the company.
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
Yes
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
Land searches will be updated both on the drawdown date and the date of the mortgage to ensure there is no encumbrance registered prior to the mortgage. The title deeds and documents are retained by the mortgagee from or before the date of drawdown.
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
Immediately enforceable
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
N/A
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
Under Hong Kong law, subject to the terms of the credit document, a lender may enforce security directly without an application to court if the security document sets out the enforcement rights of the secured lender.
The security documents may give the secured lender express powers to take possession, sell the secured assets and apply the net proceeds against the secured debt.
There are also statutory powers to do this unless a contrary intention is expressed.
A legal charge over land executed as a deed in accordance with section 44 of the Conveyancing and Property (CPO) (Cap. 219 of the Laws of Hong Kong) will, on the occurrence of an event of default, confer on the lender mortgagee certain powers, including the power to take possession, power of sale, power to do all things necessary or desirable to realise the mortgaged land as prescribed under the Fourth Schedule of the CPO.
The most common approach is to appoint a receiver who will take control of the secured assets and either apply any income, such as rental payments, to discharge the secured debt, or sell the assets. After costs of sale, the net proceeds are used to discharge the secured debt.
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
No, provided the directors of the guarantor company are satisfied there is a commercial benefit to the guarantor company in facilitating the lending arrangement for the borrower, there is no issue with cross or upstream guarantees. The guarantee document would usually contractually postpone the guarantor’s rights of indemnity from the debtor and subrogation of the secured creditor’s rights until the secured creditors have been fully repaid.
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
As noted above, a range of powers of mortgagees and receivers, including a statutory power of sale, is conferred by the CPO in relation to a legal charge or equitable mortgage over land in Hong Kong. There are restrictions on when those statutory powers are exercisable. The statutory powers are not exercisable until one of the following has occurred:
Notice requiring payment of the mortgage money has been served on the mortgagor, or on one of the several mortgagors and the mortgage money, or part of it, has not been paid within one month after service of the notice to pay.
Interest under the mortgage is in arrears remaining unpaid for one month after becoming due for payment.
There has been a breach of a provision, either express or under the Conveyancing and Property Ordinance (Cap. 219), of the mortgage other than a covenant for payment of the mortgage money and interest.
Nevertheless, the above statutory powers of mortgagees and receivers can be varied by express terms in the document.
Other than the above, there is generally no restriction that prohibits lenders from commencing proceedings against a company in Hong Kong, or from enforcing security rights in Hong Kong. A lender is generally able to enforce a security interest in accordance with the terms of the security document. The exception is the foreclosure power (to take ownership extinguishing the mortgagor’s rights to the property), which may also be included in a security document as an enforcement power. This is, in the Hong Kong context, rarely used as a remedy for enforcement.
If the debtor is subject to an insolvency rescue process, such as a contractual standstill by agreement with creditors, then the rights to enforce security may be postponed for a period. Commercial secured lenders are usually part of the discussions before such a process is started, as their agreement will often be key to a successful outcome.
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
Yes
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
N/A
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
No
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
"All-risk" including fire, pipe water, storm and hail
Natural disasters
What other insurances are usually required?
N/A
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
Valuation is usually conducted before drawdown of the loan and thereafter, updated on an annual basis.
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
If the property is subject to tenancy, a rental assignment may be required. For a development financing there will be an assignment of sale proceeds and an assignment of building contracts and any performance bond. An assignment of insurances is also customary. The mortgagee may also ask for a personal guarantee.
Contacts
David Milligan
[email protected]
+44 207 444 2675
Daniel Ng
[email protected]
+852 3405 2321
Victor Sim
[email protected]
+852 3405 2378
Alvin Wong
[email protected]
+852 3405 2518
Kristina Thielemann
[email protected]
+49 69 505096 271
Japan
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Mortgage (Teito-ken)
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
A mortgage (teito-ken) and revolving mortgage (ne-teito-ken) are commonly used for taking a security interest over real estate. A mortgage is a security interest granting a secured creditor a preferential right to receive payment for its specific secured claim from the value of mortgaged property, before other non-secured or subsequent secured creditors receiving payments for their claims.
A revolving mortgage is a kind of mortgage, which secures the secured creditor’s claims up to an agreed maximum amount. The secured claims are not specified at the time of creating the revolving mortgage but agreed as a scope (e.g., claims arising out of certain transactions), and then fixed upon certain events (e.g., a request by the mortgagee). If the maximum secured amount is increased, the change will require the consent of the beneficiaries of lower ranking mortgages.
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Fixed ranking
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
N/A
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
No particular formality is required when a mortgage agreement is executed. Even a written document is not required to make an effective mortgage. However, when creating a revolving mortgage agreement, it must include (i) the scope or type of claims to identify the secured claims and (ii) the maximum amount to be secured.
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
A mortgage needs to be filed and registered at the relevant legal affairs bureau for the location of the subject property. A mortgage is perfected (i.e., the mortgagee has a preferential right over other subsequent registered mortgagees) and becomes immediately enforceable by being registered. A registration tax is payable.
A provisional registration of mortgage is sometimes used to save paying the registration tax at the time of registration (the registration tax for a provisional registration of a mortgage is only 1,000 JPY for each parcel of real estate over which the mortgage was created). A provisional registration fixes the date of priority for preferential status and enforcement for the mortgagee, but the mortgage is only enforceable when it is formally registered (and so the tax paid).
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
Yes
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
Lenders sometimes permit draw down before completing registration of a security interest, given that the registration process takes 1 to 2 weeks after filing at the competent legal affairs bureau. In such cases, lenders would still require evidence of the filing of the registration documents before draw down.
Before a draw down, lenders or their legal counsel usually review the latest registration of property to confirm that there is no prior-ranking mortgage over the property, and require the borrower’s representations and negative pledge covenants.
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
This depends on the way the security interest is created.
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
A mortgage with formal registration is immediately enforceable.
If the mortgage is registered as a provisional mortgage to save initial costs when created, it needs to be registered again as a formal registration before enforcement. To obtain the formal registration, the mortgagee must submit certain required documents to the legal affairs bureau for the location of the property, some of which need to be prepared by the mortgagor. If the mortgagor refuses to deliver the required documents to the mortgagee, the mortgagee will need to bring court proceedings to force it to do so. It is therefore important for the mortgagee to control how and when it effects formal registration before enforcement. One approach is monitoring the mortgagor’s financial condition and requiring the necessary documents on or before certain events (such as financial covenants) are triggered.
Enforcement of mortgaged property is made through a public auction process conducted by a court. However, the sale price in a public auction is usually substantially lower than market value in most cases. In order to sell mortgaged property at a price closer to market valuation, it is common for a lender to include in a mortgage agreement its right to sell the property outside the court process, and voluntarily sell the property in the real estate market when enforcing the mortgage.
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
Under Japanese law, a mortgage can be formally or provisionally registered.
A mortgage with formal registration is immediately enforceable.
If the mortgage is registered as a provisional mortgage, it will take longer to enforce as it firstneeds to be re-registered as a formal registration before enforcement.
In order to sell mortgaged property at a price close to market valuation, it is common for a lender to include in a mortgage agreement a contractual right for the mortgagee to sell the property outside the court process (i.e. in the real estate market) when enforcing the mortgage (a “Contractual Right”).
There is no definite time period specified under the law to realise the proceeds of the enforced security. However, the realisation of the mortgage through the court process takes much longer (up to a year) than selling the property under a Contractual Right; the timing of a sale under a Contractual Right would largely depend on market conditions, as with any other sale of real estate.
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
No; as long as there is a commercial benefit to the guarantor company in facilitating the lending arrangement for the borrower, an affiliate of the borrower may provide guarantees and/or real estate security. Enforcement of those guarantees and third party real estate security does not usually affect the enforcement process since the guarantee document would usually contractually postpone the guarantor’s rights of indemnity from the debtor and subrogation of the secured creditor’s rights until the secured creditors have been fully repaid.
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
If the debtor is subject to bankruptcy proceedings and real estate in the insolvency estate is subject to a Contractual Right, the trustee in bankruptcy proceedings (hasan-tetuzuki) may request the court to set a period during which the mortgagee must exercise its Contractual Right and the mortgagee may not exercise the Contractual Right after expiry of that period.
If the debtor is subject to bankruptcy proceedings or civil rehabilitation proceedings, the trustee in the proceeding may request the court to extinguish security interests (including mortgages, even if subject to a Contractual Right).
Moreover, if the debtor is subject to corporate reorganisation proceedings (kaisha-kosei-tetuzuki) (restructuring-type insolvency proceedings), the mortgagee may not exercise a Contractual Right and payment will only be made subject to the corporate reorganisation procedure.
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
Yes
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
N/A
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
No
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
"All-risk" including fire, pipe water, storm and hail
Natural disasters
Building and property owner liability insurance
Loss of rent insurance
What other insurances are usually required?
N/A
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
It depends on the size of transaction and each lender’s policy. Banks are generally encouraged by the financial authorities to review the valuation of property every half-year for borrowers categorised as “in danger of bankruptcy”, “de facto bankrupt” or “bankrupt”, once a year for borrowers categorised as “needs attention”, and on an “as necessary” basis for properties above a certain threshold value.
It is common in real estate finance documents that a borrower is required to provide lenders with an independent appraisal report once a year.
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
Security over a claim to receive a refund of the deposit against the bank, security over rental income claims, security over insurance claims, security over receivables from sale and purchase agreements, security over the shares in the borrower (in particular where the Borrower is an SPV), security over claims arising from an asset management agreement, subordination of any shareholder debt, pledge of hedging receivables in the case of floating rate interest loans which require interest rate hedging.
Contacts
Atsumi & Sakai
Daniel Hounslow
[email protected]
+44 75 2149 3501
Naoki Kanehisa
[email protected]
+44 203 696 6540
New Zealand
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Mortgage
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Non-accessory / abstract
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
A registered mortgage is the most common type of security to be granted over land in New Zealand, and is the market standard interest adopted in real estate financing transactions. Other types of security interests include a registered encumbrance, and various statutory land charges and charging orders.
A mortgage is a charge which secures the payment of money and may also secure the performance of other obligations. An encumbrance is an instrument that typically secures the performance of non-monetary obligations (but may include a payment obligation). Statutory land charges secure certain obligations arising under statute (for example, to pay rates if the local authority has agreed to defer payment), whereas charging orders are court orders sought by a party to secure payment of a debt.
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Fixed ranking
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
N/A
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
A mortgage is registered electronically against the (public) record of title to a property. To effect electronic registration, the mortgagee and mortgagor must each sign an “Authority and Instruction” (“A&I”) form, following strict witnessing requirements: typically the form must be signed by an authorised signatory, witnessed by a solicitor, and the witnessing solicitor must check the signatory’s photo identification. For some institutional mortgagees, this process can be simplified be executing a letter of instructions in lieu of an A&I form.
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
The instructed solicitor(s) will rely on the A&I forms (and/or, if relevant, letter of instructions) to effect electronic registration of the mortgage through New Zealand’s LandOnline conveyancing software.
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
No
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
N/A
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
Immediately enforceable
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
N/A
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
Under New Zealand law, a lender can enforce a mortgage directly without an application to court.
Mortgages in New Zealand generally contain a personal covenant and mortgagees have statutory rights against mortgaged land. Therefore, the mortgage will be personally enforceable against the mortgagor and the mortgagee will have remedies against the mortgaged land such as the right to take possession of and/or sell the mortgaged property.
There is a statutory process which must be followed prior to enforcement of mortgage security which in summary follows a notice and remedy period approach.
Where a lender has security over land only, the usual approach is for the mortgagee to carry out a mortgagee sale to realise the proceeds of the enforced security. Where a lender also has security over the personal property of a borrower, it is more usual to appoint a receiver who will take control of the secured assets and either apply any income, such as rental payments, or sell the assets. In either case, after costs of sale, the proceeds are used to discharge the secured debt.
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
No, provided the directors of the guarantor company are satisfied that the guarantee is given for a proper purpose and is in the best interests of the guarantor company or, if expressly permitted by the guarantor company’s constitution, for the benefit of the debtor as its holding company, then there is no issue with cross or upstream guarantees. The guarantee document would usually contractually postpone the guarantor’s rights of indemnity from the debtor and subrogation of the guarantor’s rights until the mortgagee has been fully repaid.
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
If the debtor is subject to voluntary administration, the rights to enforce may be postponed during the moratorium period. Other insolvency processes either do not delay the lender’s right to enforce or will most likely require the agreement of the lender.
Other subsequent charges such as caveats and charging orders may also cause delays in enforcement. However, a mortgage is superior to these charges and they will be able to be removed by a mortgagor.
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
No
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
New Zealand land law provides for “indefeasibility of title”, which means that a registered owner of an estate or interest in property (as evidenced on the (public) record of title to the property) has an enforceable interest which is protected against claims by third parties that do not hold a registered estate or interest. The key exception to indefeasibility of title is if the registered owner of an estate or interest gained that estate or interest by fraud.
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
N/A
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
"All-risk" including fire, pipe water, storm and hail
Terrorism
Natural disasters
Building and property owner liability insurance
Loss of rent insurance
What other insurances are usually required?
N/A
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
Typically, the borrower will be required to obtain a valuation annually, or upon key milestone dates (for development financing), and upon the request of the lender.
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
A first-ranking general security deed over all of the borrower’s present and after-acquired property, including an assignment by way of security over any material contracts; a guarantee from shareholders and/or related-party guarantors.
Contacts
Minter Ellison Rudd Watts
Chris O'Brien
Chris.O'[email protected]
+64 4 498 5133
Holly Hill
[email protected]
+64 4 498 5173
Singapore
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Mortgage
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
If title to the property is not issued (e.g. in the case of a property comprised within a development under construction), it is common to have a Mortgage in-escrow (pending the issuance of title and the perfection of the mortgage) together with a signed Deed of Assignment in respect of the Building Agreement or Sale and Purchase Agreement as security for the financing.
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes, as long as the Mortgage is registered against the title to the property.
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Fixed ranking – interests appearing in the land register have priority according to the order of their registration or notification, irrespective of the dates of the instruments by which those interests were created or evidenced.
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
N/A
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
The Mortgage must be in the form approved by the land registrar for registration with the Singapore Land Authority.
A certificate of correctness must be signed in the Mortgage, which implies representations that to the best of the signatory’s knowledge and belief and in so far as he has any reasonable means of ascertaining:
the instrument is made in good faith;
the matters set forth therein are substantially correct; and
in the case of:
a person acquiring title, the person acquiring title thereunder accepts proprietorship and (unless otherwise expressed in the instrument) is of full age and legal capacity; or
a person divesting title, the person divesting title thereunder is the party entitled to divest the interest under the instrument and is of full age and legal capacity.
Where:
a solicitor has been employed by a party to the instrument, the certificate referred to above must be signed by the solicitor; or
a solicitor has not been employed by a party to the instrument, the party himself must sign the certificate and if the party is a corporation or limited liability partnership, the certificate must be signed by a responsible officer of the corporation or limited liability partnership, as the case may be.
Where any instrument is executed by an attorney for a party to the instrument, the certificate by the attorney implies representations that, to the best of the belief of the attorney or (as the case may be) the solicitor employed, the attorney has the authority to act as the agent for and on behalf of the party in respect of that instrument.
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
A Mortgage must be lodged in such electronic form as may be approved by the Registrar.
Where an instrument is lodged in electronic form:
it is the duty of the person who certifies the correctness of the instrument to ensure that all particulars entered therein are complete and accurate; and
the Registrar need not be concerned to inquire into the completeness or accuracy of the particulars as entered in the instrument and must, on acceptance of the instrument so lodged, register the instrument in accordance with those particulars.
A hard copy of the signed Mortgage must also be registered in the land registry, and upon registration of any mortgage, the Registrar must enter a statement on the mortgage to the effect that it has been registered and, where such instrument is accompanied by a certificate of title, or lease the Registrar must:
in the case of a manual folio or lease, endorse a memorial of the date of registration of the mortgage on the certificate of title or lease, and deliver the duplicate certificate of title or duplicate lease to the person entitled to the custody thereof; and
in the case of a computer folio, issue a new edition of the certificate of title showing the relevant entry of the memorial of registration of the mortgage and deliver a print-out of the certificate of title with such entry to the person entitled to the custody thereof.
In the absence of any express agreement to the contrary, the mortgagee is entitled to the custody of the certificate of title or duplicate lease.
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
Yes
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
Typically a notification of interest by way of a caveat is registered against the title to the mortgaged property, pending registration of the Mortgage.
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
Immediately enforceable upon registration of the Mortgage.
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
N/A
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
If a default is made in payment of the principal, interest or other money secured by a mortgage, the lender is entitled to enter into possession of the mortgaged property and to receive rents and profits provided this power is exercised after one month’s notice has been given to the mortgagor.
The lender may also make an application to the court for an order for foreclosure, and upon registration of the order of court in the land registry, the mortgaged property will vest in the lender absolutely and beneficially and the mortgagor’s equity of redemption is extinguished.
The most common approach is for the lender to appoint a receiver who will take control of the secured assets and either apply any income, such as rental payments, or sell the assets. After costs of sale, the proceeds are used to discharge the secured debt. The appointment of a receiver must be in writing, and there is no need for a court order.
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
No, provided the directors of the guarantor company are satisfied there is a commercial benefit to the guarantor company in facilitating the lending arrangement for the borrower, there is no issue with cross or upstream guarantees. Usually, the guarantee document would contractually postpone the guarantor’s rights of indemnity from the debtor and subrogation of the secured creditor’s rights until the secured creditors have been fully repaid.
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
If the debtor is subject to an insolvency rescue process, such as administration, or a moratorium, or a contractual standstill by agreement with creditors, then the rights to enforce may be postponed for a period. Commercial secured lenders are usually part of the discussions before such a process begins, as their agreement will often be key to a successful outcome.
Where the mortgaged property is being occupied by a tenant of the mortgagor, the remedies available to a lender would depend on whether the tenancy is binding on the lender. The tenancy will be binding where:
the tenancy is expressly or impliedly authorised, whether by the terms of the mortgage or by law;
the lender has consented to the tenancy; or
the tenancy was granted before the mortgage was created and the lease is for seven years or less (including any optional renewal period).
If the lender is bound by an existing tenancy, and thus unable to obtain vacant or physical possession of the mortgaged property, the lender may still obtain constructive possession by directing the tenant to pay all future rentals to the lender. If the tenancy is not binding on the lender, the lender may choose to recognise the tenancy and to receive rental payable by the tenant, or require the tenant to quit and deliver up possession of the premises to the lender. An application to court for an order of possession may have to be obtained where such tenant does not give possession.
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
Yes
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
N/A
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
No
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
Other risks
What other insurances are usually required?
Fire and reinstatement insurance.
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
Valuation is usually conducted at the commencement of loan tenure, at loan re-pricing, or as may otherwise be stipulated by the lender (this may include a requirement for an annual desktop valuation, with a full valuation once every 3 years).
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
Depending on the nature of the loan, this could include security over bank accounts, rental income, sale proceeds, insurance claims, debentures, corporate guarantees, etc.
Contacts
Yu-En Ong
[email protected]
+65 6309 5328