AT
BE
CH
DE
ES
FR
GB
IE
IT
LU
NL
PO
TR
Select a jurisdiction
Austria
Austria
Belgium
Belgium
France
France
Germany
Germany
Ireland
Ireland
Italy
Italy
Luxembourg
Luxembourg
Netherlands
Netherlands
Poland
Poland
Spain
Spain
Switzerland
Switzerland
Turkey
Turkey
United Kingdom
United Kingdom
Back to home
Austria
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Mortgage (Grundpfand – Hypothek)
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
Under Austrian law, mortgages (which are pledges) are the only security interests available in regard to real estate.
Under certain circumstances, such as, for example, when the term for repayment of the loan is less than one year or the borrower has an exceptional credit rating, lenders may consider to only apply for a preservation order which is valid for one year.
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Fixed ranking
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
N/A
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
When executing the pledge agreement, it is necessary that the authenticity of the signatures is certified by a notary public or a court of law offering such services. Without such certification the mortgage cannot be registered in the Land Register (Grundbuch) and the mortgage will not be validly created. Furthermore, the pledge agreement must describe the concerned real estate in detail and contain the express declaration of the person whose right is to be restricted, encumbered, cancelled or transferred to another person that he or she consents to the registration.
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
Depending on the respective transaction, the filing process will usually be administered by one of the attorneys involved or the notary public who certified the signatures. The registration only requires an application to that effect which can be submitted electronically. The documents on which the application is based must either be produced as an original or made available through the electronic documents archive of Austrian attorneys or Austrian notaries. The competent court then grants registration by an order (Beschluss) to that effect. Upon registration of the mortgage a court fee of 1.2 % of the secured obligations will be due which is typically borne by the borrower.
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
Yes
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
When a borrower requires a draw down under the loan prior to the mortgage’s registration in the Land Register, the lender should secure the rank of its future mortgage prior to any payments. This can be done by requiring the borrower to file an application for the preservation of the rank for a pledge with the competent court (Anmerkung der Rangordnung). If the application is granted, the court will issue an order (Rangordnungsbeschluss) to that effect and make the respective entry in the Land Register. The borrower will be required to submit the original of this court order to the lender, since any person holding the original order may then – within the period of one year – have a mortgage registered in the reserved rank. Upon registration of the rank preservation a court fee of 0.6 % of the secured obligations will be due (which is typically borne by the borrower). The subsequent registration of the mortgage will trigger another court fee of 0.6 % of the secured obligations.
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
This depends on the way the security interest is created.
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
In general, the enforcement of a mortgage requires a final court judgment which may take several years to acquire. In the enforcement proceedings the pledged real estate will then be sold at a public auction.
To avoid such lengthy proceedings, immediate out-of-court enforceability is often agreed upon by lenders and borrowers. In such cases the borrower authorises the lender to sell or otherwise realise the pledged real estate (or other real right) and issues a power of attorney to that effect. However, it should be noted that Austrian courts typically will not accept such agreements if they allow the lender to sell the real estate at its discretion or at a value agreed in advance. Any such agreement therefore should, among other things, contain a clause that an authorised real estate appraiser must determine the current value of the real estate prior to an out-of-court sale.
Other than that, immediate enforcement could be achieved by executing the loan agreement in the form of an enforceable notarial deed (vollstreckbarer Notariatsakt) which is secured through a mortgage. However, this would be rather uncommon and it seems unlikely that any borrower would agree to submit itself to such immediate enforceability.
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
Austrian statutory law generally does not grant a lender the right to enforce security over real estate directly without an application to court. Therefore, security documents often contain contractual rights to enforce without the need for court approval. Usually, the debtor will be given written notice of the default and a certain amount of time in which to remedy it. Failure to comply will then typically trigger the enforcement provisions in the security document, entitling the creditor to realise the pledge without any other legal court action, either by public auction or by private sale. The net proceeds will then be applied against the secured debt.
However, it should be noted that the out-of-court enforcement of a pledge over real estate has not yet been tested in the higher courts, therefore enforcement through judicial proceedings is still the more common approach. In this case, the lender's claim must be established in so-called title proceedings. If successful, the lender can then enforce the pledge via separate enforcement proceedings. This usually entails a public auction in which the real estate will be sold to the highest bidder. The auction proceeds are used to pay the secured debt, with any excess being transferred to the debtor.
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
Austrian corporate law provides for a rigorous system of capital maintenance rules that, among other things, prohibit the return of equity from a company to its shareholders or their affiliates. The Austrian courts have interpreted this mandatory principle broadly and held that the prohibition of the return of equity prohibits the granting of security by a company for a loan advanced to its shareholders, or any other group company other than such company’s subsidiaries. So up-stream or cross-stream guarantees, or pledges of assets are prohibited. However, what can be drawn from the Supreme Court’s past decisions is that the granting of security by a company for a loan made to its shareholders is permissible if:
it is at arm’s length, with adequate consideration being received in return by the company; and where, after due investigation by the company, it is reasonable to conclude that the shareholder or affiliate to whom the loan is extended will remain solvent and able to meet the secured debt repayment without recourse to the group company providing the guarantee or security; or
the granting of security is for the guarantor’s operational benefit.
It is important that the Austrian group company granting the guarantee or security considers carefully whether one of the exceptions to the prohibition applies, in the context of the of the particular circumstances of the case.
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
There are several potential material legal issues which may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate.
For example, the company granting security may contest the lender’s allegation that an event of default has occurred unless that has been established by a court which may result in their obtaining a preliminary injunction preventing the sale or auction of the property.
In the course of judicial enforcement proceedings, the company granting security can also raise certain objections, although these are limited in scope and usually concern issues such as a dispute that the secured debt is payable.
Insolvency proceedings do not usually create material issues that delay enforcing the security. However, the insolvency administrator may contest the security’s validity on the basis of the “claw-back” provisions contained in the Austrian Insolvency Code (e.g. where the pledge was granted within a period of sixty days prior to the commencement of the insolvency proceedings, or where the creditor was aware, or culpably unaware, of the fact that the debtor was over-indebted or unable to pay its debts at the time of granting the security, or on the basis of an alleged violation of the capital maintenance rules.
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
Yes
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
N/A
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
Yes
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
"All-risk" including:
Fire, pipe water, storm and hail
Terrorism
Natural disasters
Building and property owner liability insurance
Loss of rent insurance
What other insurances are usually required?
N/A
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
Apart from an initial valuation of the real estate over which a security interest is granted it is common to conduct subsequent valuations to assess whether the security remains adequate. The intervals for such subsequent valuations vary from one transaction to another but, typically, range between two to three years. In certain instances, valuations may also be conducted on request of the lender. Usually, this would be the case when the borrower is in default, fails to remedy such and lenders seek to enforce their claims against the security. The costs for subsequent valuations (whether recurring or ad-hoc) are usually governed by the cost provisions in either the loan or the pledge agreement and will be borne by the borrower.
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
If required by lenders, typical security interests (other than mortgages) in real estate financing transactions would be pledges over existing and future insurance claims, pledges over present and future claims (e.g. rental income; receivables from sale and purchase agreements; etc.) or pledges over present and future claims in relation to bank accounts. Further, pledges over shares in the borrower, its parent company or its subsidiaries are also common. Typically, lenders also require shareholders to subordinate existing claims against the borrower. A security assignment of claims is also a possibility. However, since there is often a risk of triggering stamp duties in the amount of 0.8 % when the secured obligations comprise more than just repayment of the loan, pledges are usually preferred.
Note that special attention must be paid when subsidiaries provide any form of security for loans granted to their parent or other group companies as it might be in contravention of capital maintenance requirements and thus null and void.
Contacts
BLS Rechtsanwälte GmbH
Thomas Boller
[email protected]
+43 1 512 14 27-14
Belgium
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Mortgage mandate (Hypothecair mandaat)
Mortgage (Hypotheek)
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
Mortgage: A mortgage is a security right over real property, such as land, buildings, long leaseholds or other real rights on property located in Belgium. A mortgage entitles the mortgagee to a preference right upon the proceeds of the sale on foreclosure. The costs of taking a mortgage can be estimated at 1.5% of the secured amount of the mortgage. The secured amount is to be agreed between the parties but generally reflects the actual value of the real property, increased with 10%.
In order to limit the costs in taking a mortgage, it has become market practice (also in real estate financing transactions) to combine a so called mini-mortgage, i.e. a mortgage registered for a limited secured amount (e.g. between €100,000 and €1 million), with the remainder of the secured amount covered under a mortgage mandate. The mini-mortgage also keeps the mortgagee informed about any (probably non-permitted) disposals by the mortgagor.
Mortgage mandate: The mortgage mandate does not create a security interest as such, but establishes a contractual obligation for the company to allow the creation of a mortgage (i.e. a conversion of the mandate into an actual registered mortgage) if and when the mortgagee wishes to do so (e.g. when financial covenants are not met, in case of a potential event of default, etc.). A mortgage mandate has to be enacted in a notarial deed and only incurs a limited (notary and registration) cost.
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Mortgage mandate (Hypothecair mandaat)
No fixed ranking
Mortgage (Hypotheek)
Fixed ranking
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
Mortgage mandate (Hypothecair mandaat)
Please note that the mortgage mandate does not create a security as such, but establishes a contractual obligation. Only upon the conversion of the mortgage mandate into an actual registered mortgage, will the converted mortgage will receive fixed ranking.
Negative undertakings: contractual negative pledge clause(s) will be included in the finance documents in order to prevent the security provider from encumbering the underlying real property (right) with (other) security rights.
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
Mortgage mandate (Hypothecair mandaat)
A mortgage mandate has to be enacted in a notarial deed executed before a Belgian notary public.
Mortgage (Hypotheek)
A mortgage is created by way of a formal deed executed before a Belgian notary public.
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
Mortgage mandate (Hypothecair mandaat)
The executed notarial deed must be registered with the Register Office – a €50 duty will become payable. The notary public is responsible for registration.
Mortgage (Hypotheek)
The mortgage has to be registered with the Register Office and the competent Mortgage Register in order to be enforceable against third parties – this is a straightforward process and will be taken care of by the instructed notary public. The registration process can take up to 2 months but the mortgage takes ranking according to the date of it being filed for registration.
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
Yes
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
Mortgage mandate (Hypothecair mandaat)
Loans are in general made available on the date that the mortgage mandate is entered into before the notary public. The actual registration in the relevant registers can take up to 2 months (see further below).
Mortgage (Hypotheek)
Yes, loans are in general made available on the date that the mortgage is entered into before the notary public. The actual registration in the relevant registers can take up to 2 months (see further below).
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
Further actions are required for enforcement.
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
Mortgage mandate (Hypothecair mandaat)
The same enforcement procedure (see summary of mortgage for further details) will be applied after the mortgage mandate has been converted into an actual mortgage.
Mortgage (Hypotheek)
If the parties have entered into a mortgage deed with executory title, the enforcement procedure can be initiated immediately by the mortgagee. If this is not the case than a prior court judgement has to be obtained for the purposes of initiating the enforcement procedure.
Executory title: A mortgage deed only contains an executory title in the event that it comprises all the elements necessary to exactly calculate the amounts due under the loan agreement at the time of enforcement. In such case, the enforcement procedure can be initiated promptly (by means of a (court supervised) executory seizure):
The enforcement procedure starts with a formal request to the mortgagor to pay the secured debt. It is in the interests of the mortgagee to register this demand at the mortgage register. As from that moment, no encumbrance or transfer of the mortgaged property is effective vis-à-vis the mortgagee.
Fifteen days following the formal request to pay, the mortgagee can proceed with the enforcement of the mortgage and can instruct a bailiff to seize the real property. During the fifteen day period, the debtor can still pay the secured obligations and can thereby avoid the enforcement of the real property. The real property has to be seized within six months after the demand to pay. If this is not the case, the creditor will have to formally request payment again in order to realise a valid seizure.
The writ of seizure will have to be deposited at the mortgage register within fifteen days after the seizure. This deposit is valid for three years and is renewable.
Within one month after the deposit of the writ of seizure, the creditor will file a petition with the competent court. The court will review the legal validity of the executory seizure and the notarial mortgage deed.
If the two latter documents are valid and enforceable and have the necessary specifications with respect to the secured amount and the secured obligations, the court will appoint a Notary to supervise and co-ordinate the sale of the real property. This decision will be served upon the Notary within fifteen days.
The (appointed) Notary has the obligation to sell the property within six months after his appointment by the court. After the auction of the property, any person can offer a higher price within 15 days. The mortgagee will exercise his priority right over the proceeds of the sale in accordance with his ranking vis-à-vis other creditors.
No executory title: In international (syndicated) financing transactions, it is standard practice for the parties to enter into a mortgage without executory title. Even if the parties had entered into a mortgage deed with executory title at closing, the same may be lost during the life of the loan given that the facilities may be amended from time to time and, consequently, the initial elements as contained in the mortgage deed may no longer contain the correct details (such as interest rate, maturity date, etc.) to allow the mortgagee to determine the actual outstanding amount under the loan agreement, and hence losing the executory title under the mortgage. In such case, the enforcement procedure can only be initiated on the basis of a court judgement under the laws of the loan agreement determining the amounts due but unpaid. In case of a foreign judgement, the same will first have to be recognised in Belgium by means of an administrative procedure which will take between 2 to 4 weeks, pre-Brexit). Judicial intervention is thus required for mortgages without executory title, after which the above described enforcement procedure can be initiated.
Time table:
No mortgage with executory title:
(Foreign) court order: [x]
Belgian recognition: [x] + 2 to 4 weeks
Executory title via the mortgage or court decision:
Demand to pay: + 15 days
Seizure: + 5 business days
Deposit of seizure: + max 15 days
Deposit of writ of seizure: + max 1 month
Court review: + between 1 to 4 weeks
Notary appointment: + 15 days
Sale process: + max 6 months (+15 days) (+delays of involvement of prior ranking parties)
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
N/A
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
N/A
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
N/A
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
Yes
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
N/A
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
Yes
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
"All-risk" including fire, pipe water, storm and hail
Terrorism
Natural disasters
Building and property owner liability insurance
Other risks
What other insurances are usually required?
All-risk insurance covering the construction site, material damages, thefts and injuries.
Other risks specific to the real estate project.
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
A valuation will normally be executed by an independent valuation expert. An initial valuation will usually be carried out prior to entering into the loan agreement. As there are no legal provisions in Belgium regarding the valuation intervals, this will be agreed upon between the parties on a case by case basis. An annual valuation is common but this might of course vary on a case by case basis.
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
Receivables pledge (insurance, lease receivables, project documents receivables, LC receivables, etc.);
Bank accounts pledge (reserve accounts, collection account, project accounts, etc.);
Share pledge over the shares of the SPV.
Contacts
Lydian
Tom Geudens
[email protected]
+32 2 787 9008
Achille Lemey
[email protected]
+32 2 787 90 40
Dries Leirs
[email protected]
+32 11 260 052
France
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Mortgage (Hypothèque immobilière conventionnelle)
Special legal mortgage (Hypothèque légale spéciale)
Real estate pledge (gage immobilier)
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
French law provides for three types of security interests over real estate: mortgage (hypothèque immobilière conventionnelle), special legal mortgage (hypothèque légale spéciale) and real estate pledge (gage immobilier). The real estate pledge is rarely used because it operates with dispossession as a temporary transfer of title to the lender which carries with it obligations as to the management, insurance and leasing of the property, which lenders are not willing to assume, and even if they enter into back-to-back arrangements, the structure is too complex and the risk of liability remains. The special legal mortgage (hypothèque légale spéciale, formerly known as privilège de prêteur de deniers) is used in relation to the purchase of property, since it can notably be implemented in relation to securing the funds which finance the purchase of a real estate asset. This special legal mortgage should be used every time the conditions for it to be granted are met since the registration costs are lower than the conventional mortgage. The most commonly used security interest in the market is the mortgage (hypothèque immobilière conventionnelle). A mortgage can now also be enforced by self-appropriation (pacte commissoire), rather than only by court action. A mortgage may be granted in conjunction with a special legal mortgage where the sums lent exceed the purchase price of the property, for example when financing the purchase of land and also the construction or development of a building on the land, or when financing a capex program on top of the acquisition price, or when a mortgage must be granted to secure any sums due under any hedging instruments with a counterparty risk.
When refinancing, the new creditor can benefit from the mortgages granted by the borrower to the former creditor by way of subrogation and/or by way of novation. The subrogation allows the new creditor to benefit from the existing mortgage up to the amount of the refinanced debt and the related interest and accessories (pursuant to article 1346-2 of the French Civil code) and the novation allows the new creditor to benefit from the existing mortgage relating to the amount that is subject to the novation (réserve des sûretés pursuant to article 1334 of the French Civil code).
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Mortgage: Yes
Special legal mortgage: No
Real estate pledge: No
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Yes
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
N/A
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
Like all contracts granting rights over real estate, it must be signed by way of a notarial deed, in the presence of a notary. The absence of notarial deed is sanctioned by absolute nullity: it has no legal value.
When executing an amendment agreement to an existing facility agreement initially signed by way of a notarial deed in order to postpone the initial maturity date of the financing, it is not required that such amendment agreement be signed by way of a notarial deed. The notary shall however ensure that the initial mortgage registration is renewed so that the duration of the registration corresponds to the new maturity date.
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
Mortgage
Legal, judicial and conventional mortgages must be registered by the notary at the Land Registry Office (service chargé de la publicité foncière) where the property is located, as soon as possible (the date of registration of the mortgage determines the rank of the mortgage). The mortgage is granted for the same term as the loan, plus one year. After such date, if the registration is not renewed, the registration is no longer effective and the mortgage is no longer binding on third parties. However, the mortgage itself is still in force after the expiry of the registration, until the principal amount of the secured loan is fully repaid and the related interests and accessories are fully paid. The duration of the registration of the mortgage cannot exceed 50 years.
Special legal mortgage
The special legal mortgage must be registered by the notary at the Land Registry Office (service chargé de la publicité foncière) where the property is located as soon as possible (the date of registration of the mortgage determines the rank of the mortgage). The lien is granted for the same term as the loan, plus one year. After such date, if the registration is not renewed, the registration is no longer effective and the mortgage is no longer binding on third parties. However, the mortgage itself is still in force after the expiry of the registration. The duration of the registration of the mortgage cannot exceed 50 years.
Real estate pledge
The pledge must be registered by the notary at the Land Registry Office (service chargé de la publicité foncière) where the property is located.
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
Mortgage: Yes
Special legal mortgage: Yes
Real estate pledge: Yes
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
Mortgage
The mortgage needs to be granted before (or simultaneously) the loan is made available. The loan agreement includes a covenant, sanctioned by an event of default, pursuant to which (i) the mortgage must be filed with the Land Registry Office by a certain date and (ii) the mortgage must remain in full force and effect until the loan is fully repaid and the related interests and accessories are fully paid.
Special legal mortgage
The facility agreement shall provide for the purpose and use of the loan, being the acquisition of the property, for the special legal mortgage to be legally qualified as such. If the property is acquired after the execution of the facility agreement (differed drawdown), a promise to use the funds to acquire the property must be included in the facility agreement.
Real estate pledge
The agreement contains a covenant, sanctioned by an event of default, pursuant to which the mortgage must be filed with the Land Registry Office by a certain date.
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
Further actions are required prior to enforcement.
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
The instrument is binding between the parties from its execution, then registration at the Land Registry Office ensures that it is binding on third parties. The notary must file with the Land Registry as soon as possible as the registration date determines the rank of the mortgage.
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
If a “pacte commissoire” clause has been included in the facility agreement/mortgage deed, this simplifies the enforcement process in respect of real property as compared to a ‘simple’ mortgage
A “pacte commissoire” clause provides for an expert valuation of the mortgaged asset and, in the event that the outstanding amount of the secured debt exceeds the value of the mortgaged asset, recovery of the balance from the mortgagor. It also enables a lender to become the owner of the property without an application to the court, which speeds up the recovery process.
Sale of the asset without “pacte commissoire” involves a lengthy court procedure which involves the court determining the method of sale, minimum price and distribution of proceeds.
Notwithstanding the advantages of “pacte commissoire” provisions for a secured lender, it is not standard market practice to include these. Secured lenders may be reluctant to become the owner and manager of a property but prefer to just receive the cash proceeds following a judicial sale . It is also simpler to share cash proceeds pro rata where there is more than one lender secured.
In addition, "pacte commissoire" can not be exercised following an insolvency proceeding has occurred.
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
It is possible for a company to secure/guarantee the obligations of another company in the same group with a third party mortgage guarantee (“caution réelle hypothécaire”) provided the granting of the guarantee or security is in the corporate interests of the affiliate group company, and within its permitted corporate purpose.
Where a third party security/guarantee is being granted within a group of companies, case law has established several criteria which need to be met in order to ensure that the security/guarantee is not considered invalid (“abus de biens sociaux”). These include that the transaction must be on balanced terms and provide some (direct or indirect) corporate benefit to the third party security/guarantee provider (the amount secured will be limited to the amount of such benefit received by the company, for instance through an intra-group loan from its parent company if the security/guarantee is upstream).
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
Enforcement of security often occurs in the context of either amicable arrangements with a borrower to realise the asset, or in an insolvency situation, where judicial procedures are underway. In the event of an insolvency a number of issues could prevent and/or delay enforcement, for example:
Sale by the mortgagor: a mortgagor can prevent a forced sale by asking the court to grant leave for the amicable sale of its property, which if granted could allow the mortgagor up to 3 months to find a purchaser and complete the sale;
Overbid (“surenchère”): where within 10 days of a sale by way of auction, a third party makes an offer which is at least one tenth higher than the auction price, the initial sale can be set aside and a new auction can be held; and
Failure to sell at auction: Where the auction does not result in a sale, a subsequent sale must be demonstrated to be a new auction, rather than a resumption of the original auction (“réitération des enchères”).
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
When advising on real estate financings, it is customary for law firms to issue validity and enforceability opinions on security interests that are not notarial security interests (sûretés sous seing privé).
While law firms may issue validity and enforceability opinions relating to a notarial deed, law firms should exclude from the scope of the opinion the mortgages and any other notarial security interests.
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
Notaries are officiers ministériels and as such are liable in relation to any instrument signed before them. Parties rely on such liability. By law, all notaries are required to insure their professional civil liability. While law firms do not always issue opinions, notaries may be requested to do so. When law firms issue validity and enforceability opinions relating to a notarial deed, law firms should exclude from the scope of the opinion any opinion relating to the mortgages.
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
N/A
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
"All-risk" including fire, pipe water, storm and hail
Terrorism
Natural disasters
Loss of rent insurance
Other risks
What other insurances are usually required?
Mortgage
By law the mortgagee is subrogated to the rights of the insured party: insurance indemnities due as a result of insurance against fire, against hail, against livestock mortality, or other risks, are allocated without the need for express delegation, to privileged or mortgage creditors, according to their rank (délégation légale d'assurances).
The insurance indemnities of a nature other than those referred to above shall be subject to an assignment of receivables (or, if the lenders cannot benefit from an assignment of receivables, a pledge of receivables).
In any case, it is usual that the lender is designated as first loss payee for amounts due under the loan agreement.
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
Valuations are not required by law (unless the borrower is an OPCI (organisme de placement collectif immobilier) in which case the OPCI shall mandate an independent expert to establish two valuations of its real estate assets per year), but it is usual to require valuations at signing and then annually in order to test the LTV ratio. It is also usual to provide for valuations to be carried out at the request of the lender upon suspicion of an event of default (at the cost of the borrower if the suspicion is confirmed, or at the cost of the lenders if not). Any additional security would need to take the form of a mortgage.
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
A customary security package, in addition to the security over real estate may include a:
Receivables pledge or assignment agreement (in particular with respect to rentals, acquisition deeds (as the case may be), VAT (as the case may be), and insurance proceeds, other than third party liability insurance and legal insurance delegation which is coming with the mortgage)
Pledge of shares
Pledge over bank accounts
Assignments of sums of money (Cession-espèces à titre de garantie)
Guarantee (cautionnement), letter of intent (lettre d'intention)
Contacts
Kamel Ben Salah
[email protected]
+ 33 6 85 84 67 03
Valentin Tschaen
[email protected]
+33 6 68 94 09 20
Germany
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Land charge (Grundschuld)
Mortgage (Hypothek)
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Land charge (Grundschuld)
Non-accessory/ abstract
Mortgage (Hypothek)
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
German law knows two types of security over real estate, a land charge (Grundschuld) and a mortgage (Hypothek). The major difference between a land charge and a mortgage is that a land charge is a non-accessory/ abstract security interest while a mortgage is and accessory security interest.
Mortgages are typically used in real estate financings for retail customers as they provide for a higher degree of protection for the mortgagor than a land charge. In order to use mortgages in syndicated financings, you would need to rely on a parallel debt structure. Therefore, in commercial real estate financings (regardless whether these relate to hospitality, logistics, office, residential or any other use) land charges are the standard security interest.
Mortgages can be issued both with a certificate (Grundschuldbrief) and without a certificate (ohne Brief). Today it is rather customary to provide for mortgages and land charges without any certificate.
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Fixed ranking
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
N/A
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
This depends on whether the mortgage deed itself includes a submissions to immediate enforcement (Unterwerfung unter die sofortige Zwangsvollstreckung).
In cases where the entire mortgage is subject to immediate enforcement, the mortgage or land charge needs to be notarised (beurkundet) in German language in front of a notary.
In cases where the mortgage is only partially (or not at all) subject to immediate enforcement, only the signatures of the persons executing the mortgage deed need to be legalised (beglaubigt). However, in case of a mortgage which is only partially subject to immediate enforcement, the separate submission to immediate enforcement remains subject to notarisation.
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
Mortgages need to be filed with and registered in the relevant land register for the charged property. The filing is usually conducted by the notary who has notarised the mortgage.
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
Yes
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
In cases where draw down is intended/ required prior to the mortgage being registered (not filed) with the relevant land register and additional notarial confirmation (Notarbestätigung) is required pursuant to which the notary who has notarised the mortgage confirms, that the mortgage once registered will have the agreed ranking. In order to do so, the notary is required to check with the relevant land register whether there are any filings pending, which might affect the ranking of the mortgage. This requires a check of the files of the land register (Einsicht in die Grundakte).
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
This depends on the way the security interest is created.
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
Under German law mortgages can be created either as being subject to immediate enforcement (Unterwerfung unter die sofortige Zwangsvollstreckung).
From a lenders perspective it is preferential to have the full mortgage subject to submission to immediate enforcement (Unterwerfung unter die sofortige Zwangsvollstreckung) but sometimes, for cost reasons, only a certain part of the mortgage is subject to immediate enforcement. In these cases a separate power of attorney needs to be granted in favor of the lender in order to put the lender into a position to submit that part of the mortgage to immediate enforcement which has not been submitted originally.
Although it is possible to create a mortgage which is not subject to immediate enforcement, this should generally be avoided as it would question whether the mortgage can be realised "in a timely manner" as the secured party would need to obtain a title/ writ of execution first, which in turn would require a full legal proceeding.
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
No out of court enforcement options are available in relation to real property security. An enforcement procedure for Land Charges is quicker if it is subject to submission to immediate enforcement, without such submission, an enforceable court judgment is required in order to commence enforcement.
Once the above steps are completed, enforcement against the property can be by way of auction and/or forced administration. Both options are regulated by law and require court proceedings at the relevant local court.
The aim of an auction is to repay a creditor from the proceeds of sale. A forced administration seeks to repay a creditor with the proceeds of administration of an asset, for instance rental income. The two alternatives can be combined to maximise realisation.
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
This depends on the specific circumstances.
Cross-collateralisation is generally possible in Germany and subject to any contractual limitation language included, the bank could enforce against the real estate assets of a German co-borrower to repay all outstanding amounts due by itself and its co-borrower/s to the lenders.
In respect of a German borrower group, if limitation language has been included, this could either prohibit enforcement or limit the distribution of enforcement proceeds to the extent the security in question secures cross-stream or up-stream obligations. There are ways to structure a transaction to avoid this issue.
German capital maintenance rules (Kapitalerhaltungsregeln) may further limit the enforcement of third party security interests beyond any express limitations contained in the loan documentation (this applies to German lenders as well as UK lenders).
Cross-collateralisation issues also have an effect on covered bond eligibility. For German real estate financing transactions it is therefore customary to try to avoid cross collateralisation issues by not including any limitation language, particularly in a land charge.
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
Factors to be aware of in an enforcement situation include:
Once court enforcement proceedings have been initiated, the process is not within a creditor’s control.
The debtor can delay enforcement by applying for a six month temporary suspension.
Minimum bid rules can delay the auction process.
The debtor’s insolvency can affect and further delay the enforcement process unless the creditor can work with the insolvency administrator to facilitate a private sale.
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
Yes
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
N/A
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
Yes
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
"All-risk" including:
Fire
Pipe water
Storm and hail
Terrorism
Natural disasters
Building and property owner liability insurance
Loss of rent insurance
What other insurances are usually required?
N/A
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
At least every three years (in some cases every two years) and at any time upon the request of the lender (anlassbezogene Prüfung). In practice this is usually dealt with through the cost provisions of the loan documentation. The borrower is usually required to bear the costs for the regular valuations as well as costs for valuations on request of the lender to the extent these evidence a breach of agreed financial covenants or in some cases are obtained at a time an event of default is continuing.
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
Security over bank accounts, security over rental income claims, security over insurance claims, security over receivables from sale and purchase agreements, security over the shares in the borrower (in particular where the Borrower is an SPV), duty of care agreements in case of third party asset/ property managers, subordination of any shareholder debt, pledge of hedging receivables in case of floating rate interest loans which require interest rate hedging.
Contacts
Bernhard Fiedler
[email protected]
+49 69 505096 216
Julia Tschickardt
[email protected]
+49 69 505096 204
Kristina Thielemann
[email protected]
+49 69 505096 271
Ireland
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Mortgage (also referred to as "Charge")
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
For clarity, the accessory / abstract distinction is not one that is made under Irish law. It is the case that an Irish charge secures only the obligations set out in the charge and if those obligations cease to exist, the security provider will typically have an entitlement to redeem the security. However it is also the case that there are circumstances (albeit they are less common) where a security interest could, as a matter of contract, survive a novation of the obligations secured. This would depend on the particular wording of the relevant charge and of the relevant novation documentation.
Since 1 December 2009, being the commencement date of the relevant provisions of the Land and Conveyancing Law Reform Act 2009 (“LCLRA 2009”), Irish law provides that a legal mortgage of land may only be created by a charge by deed (a "Charge"). In commercial real estate financing transactions, the usual approach is for security over real estate to be created by a Charge, which is incorporated into an "all assets" debenture/security agreement. While other methods (both consensual and non-consensual) of securing real estate are possible, none of them would be typical of a real estate financing transaction.
Since 1 December 2009, being the commencement date of the relevant provisions of the Land and Conveyancing Law Reform Act 2009 (“LCLRA 2009”), Irish law provides that a legal mortgage of land may only be created by a charge by deed (a "Charge"). In commercial real estate financing transactions, the usual approach is for security over real estate to be created by a Charge, which is incorporated into an "all assets" debenture/security agreement. While other methods (both consensual and non-consensual) of securing real estate are possible, none of them would be typical of a real estate financing transaction.
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
No
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
The rules on priorities of interests over real estate in Ireland are complex and differ depending on whether the title is Registered Title or Unregistered Title (both explained below). By way of general guidance as to how it applies to security interests: (i) priority is typically determined by the date of registration, rather than creation, of a Charge; and (ii) the default position (with a limited number of exceptions) is that a Charge which has been registered on the appropriate register with Tailte Éireann will take priority over security interests that are either subsequently created or registered. In practice priority is preserved and risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated, by effective due diligence and enquiries during the transaction, supported by appropriate public register searches on completion and prompt registration of the Charge post-completion.
There are two mutually exclusive systems in Ireland for land registration, both overseen by Tailte Éireann: (i) the Land Registry registration of title system (with the resulting title referred to generally as “Registered Title”) and (ii) the Registry of Deeds registration of deeds system (with relevant title referred to generally as “Unregistered Title”). With Registered Title, the register itself is conclusive evidence of title (subject to the rights of the holders of any “overriding interests” (a limited list of interests which affected Registered Title without themselves being registered) and to the fact that the register is not generally conclusive as to boundaries). With Unregistered Title, the register kept by the Registry of Deeds is simply a register of relevant deeds submitted to it; an assessment of the title held must be made by reading all relevant deeds.
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
Yes. A Charge may only be created by the execution of a deed, which requires compliance with certain Irish law formalities.
When security is taken over Registered Title a specific form of Charge must be executed in accordance with the Land Registry’s Land Registration Rules, the most usual form for a commercial real estate financing transaction being a Form 52.
Also, where a foreign entity is granting security over Registered Title, execution of both the Charge and the relevant Land Registry form, e.g. the Form 52, should be in compliance with the law governing execution by the foreign entity, supported by a legal opinion in a prescribed form from a lawyer authorised to practice in the relevant jurisdiction, confirming that the documents have been duly executed by the foreign entity.
Any forms or documents required to be submitted to or registered at either the Land Registry or Registry of Deeds must be executed in wet-ink. The registries do not yet accept DocuSign or other forms of electronic execution.
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
A Charge (and all related applications) should be registered on the appropriate register(s) with Tailte Éireann to preserve priority and, for Registered Title, to facilitate the exercise by the secured lender or their appointed receiver of their power of sale.
For Registered Title, it is the relevant Land Registry form, e.g. the Form 52, that is submitted for registration. Also, as already indicated, where a foreign entity is granting the security, the Land Registry requires a legal opinion in a prescribed form from a lawyer authorised to practice in the relevant foreign jurisdiction, confirming that the security documents have been duly executed by the foreign entity.
Depending on the nature of the borrower, additional registrations may also be required in other registries (e.g. a Charge granted by a company must be registered in the Companies Registration Office within a strict timeline in order to be enforceable against the company).
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
Yes
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
The parties and their lawyers would usually agree (and give undertakings in respect of) a process and timelines for compliance with relevant formalities, including registration. For Registered Title, it is possible to make a priority entry application, which preserves the priority of the Charge for a period of 44 days, pending its lodgement for registration. Priority entry applications freeze the register in respect of which they are made for the 44 day period; they are not generally made as standard but are considered on a case by case basis.
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
Further actions are required for enforcement.
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
The LCLRA 2009 sets out certain statutory prerequisites for the enforcement of security entered into on or after 1 December 2009 including a requirement for court orders before taking possession or exercising a power of sale, unless the borrower consents otherwise.
Other than for Charges which give effect to a “housing loan mortgage” as provided for in the LCLRA 2009, these statutory provisions may be disapplied.
For general commercial real estate financing, a well-drafted Charge will expressly disapply these and any other statutory provisions that could otherwise delay enforcement, while also contractually setting out the circumstances in which the Charge can be enforced. Typically, a Charge would be enforced following a default by the borrower, the service of a demand by the secured lender and the expiry of a reasonable period of time (usually twenty-four hours) to allow the borrower to satisfy the demand.
A “housing loan mortgage” is typically a Charge taken to secure a loan provided to a consumer in respect of a principal private residence, to which particular statutory protection applies. While the precise definition is outside the scope of this guide, it is important for a secured lender to be satisfied in every transaction that the Charge does not, in fact, constitute a “housing loan mortgage” and to consider the implications where it does.
Also, for Charges entered in before 1 December 2009, the LCLRA 2009 has no application - the statutory regime in place prior to the LCLRA 2009 will apply instead.
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
In Ireland a secured lender can enforce security over commercial real estate directly without involving a court.
Other than for housing loan mortgages, statutory provisions that would otherwise apply to require court orders for possession and for sale may be disapplied and the Charge would typically do this.
The Charge would also typically supplement the secured lender’s statutory rights and powers to optimise the process of enforcement, including, by providing for an appointed receiver to have a power of sale. While the secured lender can enforce as mortgagee, in the vast majority of cases, they will opt to appoint a receiver who will take control of the secured assets and ultimately sell them, applying the net proceeds, and any income received in the interim, in discharge of the secured debt.
A receiver is under an obligation to obtain the “best price reasonably obtainable” but this does not mean that the receiver must wait for a market to improve. The receiver will usually engage a real estate agent to market the property and agree a sale and the market will determine how quickly a sale can be achieved.
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
There are no restrictions on a company providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of the borrowings of an affiliate provided the affiliate is, effectively, a member of the same “group of companies” for the purposes of the Companies Act 2014; and there are no express restrictions to that effect in the constitution of the guarantor or security provider. If either of these requirements is not met, the issue may be overcome by approval and/or amendment, depending on the particular issue that presents. The board of directors of the guarantor or security provider must also be satisfied that it is in the best interests of the guarantor or security provider to facilitate the lending arrangement for the borrower. This tends to be easily satisfied where the companies are closely connected.
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
Ensuring that all registrations in respect of a Charge over Registered Title have been made and completed, is important.
If a borrower is subject to a statutory insolvency rescue process, such as examinership, then the secured lender’s rights to enforce may be postponed for a period provided for in the legislation.
It is also important for a secured lender to be satisfied in every transaction concerning a Charge that the Charge does not constitute a “housing loan mortgage” and to consider the implications where it does.
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
Yes
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
N/A
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
No
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
In addition to the insurance cover mentioned below, the loan agreement will usually require the borrower to insure such other risks as a prudent company or other person in the same business as the borrower would insure. Where financing is being provided for development of a property, contractors' all risks insurance and professional indemnity insurance for contractors and other relevant persons will usually also be required as well as, in some cases, delay in start-up insurance and non-negligence insurance. The typical practice in Ireland is that secured lenders will engage their own insurance broker as insurance advice usually falls outside the scope of legal advice.
What other insurances are usually required?
"All-risk" including fire, pipe water, storm and hail
Terrorism
Building and property owner liability insurance
Loss of rent insurance
Other risks
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
On domestic lending transactions, Irish loan agreements tend to provide the lender with the right to call for a valuation at any time with the costs of the valuation being covered as follows:
by the borrower where there is a default or an event of default;
by the borrower for an initial valuation and one valuation in any 12 month period thereafter; and
by the lender in all other instances save where the valuation confirms the existence of an event of default.
The timing and cost elements of the above are often varied by agreement.
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
Security over all assets of the borrower, including bank accounts, rental income claims, insurance claims (with the lender also being named on the insurance policy as composite insured), rights and receivables under relevant acquisition agreements, pledge of hedging receivables in case of floating rate interest loans which require interest rate hedging. In addition, security over the shares in the borrower (in particular where the borrower is an SPV), subordination of and security over any shareholder debt, duty of care agreements in case of third party asset/ property managers, and, in the case of development financing, collateral warranties with the appropriate contractors and consultants.
Contacts
McCann FitzGerald
Jennifer Halpin
[email protected]
+353 1 607 1794
Philip Murphy
[email protected]
+353 1 611 9139
Niall McDowell
[email protected]
+353 1 511 1619
Martina Firbank
[email protected]
+353 1 611 9124
Martin O’Neill
[email protected]
+353 1 607 1786
Italy
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Mortgage (Ipoteca)
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
Pursuant to Article 2808 of the Italian Civil Code, a mortgage is a security right in rem entitling the mortgagee the right to expropriate the secured property, regardless if it is owned by the mortgagor or it has been meanwhile sold to a third party by the mortgagor, and to be preferred to other unsecured creditors ( the mortgagee being a “privileged creditor”, creditore privilegiato) over the price obtained from the sale of the mortgaged property as a result of the enforcement procedure.
It is worth noting that, pursuant to Italian Civil Procedure Code, the secured property shall be sold pursuant to the provisions established therein (i.e. offer or public auction, etc.). Therefore, upon default of the mortgagor, the mortgagee may enforce the mortgage but will not be assigned the secured property but will instead be entitled to receive the price obtained from the sale of the secured property.
A mortgage can only be established against the owner of the property (or against the subject entitled to the other in rem rights listed below) at the time of the deed of mortgage. However, the mortgagee may enforce the mortgage even if the secured property has then been sold by the mortgagor to a third party and it is owned by the latter.
A mortgage can be granted only over identified assets. Mortgages are said to be “indivisible”, meaning that, in the event that the property is partially sold, divided or transferred to several heirs, the mortgage will not be divided accordingly and, instead, will remain valid and effective over the entire secured property. The mortgagee, however, may waive such indivisibility and accept the occurred divisions.
According to Article 2817 and followings of the Italian Civil Code, there are three types of mortgage, depending on the title pursuant to which such mortgage is established: (i) legal mortgage, when the mortgage is established directly by the law; (ii) judicial mortgage, when the mortgage is established by a judgement (including enforceable arbitration awards and foreign judgments made enforceable in Italy); and (iii) voluntary mortgage, when the mortgage is contractually established. Such agreement must have the form of a notarial deed (atto pubblico) or private deed authenticated by a Notary Public (scrittura private autenticata).
Article 2810 of the Italian Civil Code provides for the following list of assets and in rem rights that can be secured by mortgage: (i) real estate properties and their appurtenances; (ii) usufruct on immovable properties and their appurtenances; (iii) surface rights, (iv) emphyteusis right and the grantor's right to the emphyteustic fund; (v) State annuities; (vi) registered movable properties (such as, inter alia, cars and boats).
Mortgages are established by registration in the relevant land register where the secured property is located. The security right is perfected through such registration.
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Fixed ranking
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
N/A
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
The deed of mortgage shall be executed: (i) in notarial form (atto pubblico notarile); or (ii) in the form of a private deed authenticated on signing by a Notary Public (scrittura privata autenticata).
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
The deed of mortgage shall be registered with the competent real estate register where the asset is located (Conservatoria). Under Italian law, this kind of registration is deemed as the effective moment of creation of the security over the asset (trascrizione costitutiva).
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
No
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
N/A
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
Further actions are required for enforcement.
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
The usual procedure to enforce the mortgage is the following (on the assumption that the borrower has not become insolvent): (i) the enforcement procedure may be started through a writ of enforcement (atto di precetto) served by the creditor to the debtor/obligor by means of a court bailiff (ufficiale giudiziario), representing a formal injunction based on an enforceable title, i.e. the deed of mortgage and its registration; (ii) the debtor is required to pay the outstanding amounts within a certain term (being not less than ten days after receipt of the writ); (iii) if the payment default persists, the creditor is then entitled to proceed with the seizure of the mortgaged asset, after serving a writ of seizure (atto di pignoramento) by means of a court bailiff (ufficiale giudiziario) of the locally competent court office; (iv) a judge will set a hearing for the authorisation of the sale, summoning the creditor holder of the mortgage as well as all other registered and secured creditors shown on the land register (Conservatoria). All other creditors (whether secured or unsecured) may intervene in such proceedings, provided that they have an enforceable title against such debtor; (v) the sale of the real estate asset then takes place, according to the judge’s decision, either by means of single purchase offers or by auction. In both cases the relevant order is made public so as to publicise the purchase opportunity to potential buyers; (vi) following the sale, the proceeds are distributed amongst all creditors in the enforcement procedure, after prior payment of the beneficiary of the mortgage.
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
N/A
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
N/A
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
N/A
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
Yes
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
N/A
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
No
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
"All-risk" including fire, pipe water, storm and hail
Natural disasters
Building and property owner liability insurance
What other insurances are usually required?
N/A
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
Valuation is usually conducted before drawdown of the loan and thereafter, updated on an annual basis.
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
In case of leasing, lenders typically ask also for the assignment by way of security of all the receivables arising from the lease of the asset. Generally, they would require also the creation of special privilege (privilegio speciale) over the movable assets included in the mortgaged asset (they don't usually ask for pledges over movable assets, as it requires the deprivation of the goods from the debtor, and the custody of such goods by the creditor).
Contacts
Luigi Costa
[email protected]
+39 02 86359 412
Giulia Carnevale
[email protected]
+39 02 86359 442
Luxembourg
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
A Luxembourg law governed mortgage (Hypothèque)
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
When the real estate asset is located in Luxembourg, a Luxembourg law governed mortgage over the real estate asset is usually granted by the company owning the property. It may be taken over the plot of land on which the real estate is located and/or over the building attached to such plot of land. In addition to this mortgage, lenders will usually ask to be provided with a pledge over the company’s bank account(s) and receivables, including receivables deriving from rental income and insurance proceeds. A pledge over the shares of the company owning the property is also not unusual.
Luxembourg law grants to real estate sellers a legal privilege (privilège du vendeur) over the real estate asset to be sold. Such privilege remains as long as the sale price of the real estate (including the principal price, interests and accessory costs provided that these have been mentioned in the deed of sale) has not been fully paid by the buyer to the seller. Such legal privilege will prevail over any Luxembourg law mortgage created by the buyer.
The main difference between a mortgage and a pledge over shares, receivables or bank accounts (which will qualify as financial collateral arrangements (the Financial Collateral Arrangements)) is that the enforcement procedure for a Luxembourg law mortgage is more formal and cumbersome than an enforcement of a Financial Collateral Arrangement whose regime is very creditor-friendly.
A Luxembourg law mortgage will also not benefit from the same level of protection as a Financial Collateral Arrangement in case an insolvency proceeding would be opened against a Luxembourg mortgagor.
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Yes, it does. It should be noted that under Luxembourg law, the rank of mortgagees is determined by the date of registration of the Luxembourg law mortgages in the register of the Luxembourg Bureau de la Conservation des Hypothèques.
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
N/A
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
On closing, certain perfection formalities have to be completed (i.e. notification and acknowledgment of the account bank for an account pledge, notification of the debtor (when it is not a party to the pledge agreement) for a receivables pledge, registration of the pledge over the (registered) shares in the shareholder register of the company whose (registered) shares are pledged for a share pledge and registration of the Luxembourg law mortgage with the Luxembourg Administration de l’Enregistrement et des Domaines – Bureau de la Conservation des Hypothèques) for a Luxembourg law mortgage.
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
With respect to the Luxembourg law Financial Collateral Arrangements (share pledge, receivables pledge, account pledge), there are no filing requirements.
With respect to a Luxembourg law mortgage, please note that it will have to be taken pursuant to a notarial deed. On the day on which such a deed will be enacted, the mortgage will need to be registered by the notary who has enacted the deed with the Luxembourg Bureau de la Conservation des Hypothèques and the Administration de l’Enregistrement et des Domaines. A fixed fee of 0.05% of the amount secured under the mortgage will apply.
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
No
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
N/A
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
Immediately enforceable upon registration with the Luxembourg Bureau de la Conservation des Hypothèques.
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
Please refer to the question on filing and registration requirements.
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
a) Under Luxembourg law, a mortgagee can enforce a Luxembourg law mortgage upon the occurrence of and/or following a contractual trigger event as provided for in the Luxembourg law mortgage deed.
b) It is usual to include in a Luxembourg law mortgage deed, a clause of immediate execution without recourse to legal procedure (“clause de voie parée”) which gives the mortgagee an enforceable title.
The procedure for enforcing the Luxembourg law mortgage will be governed by Article 879 of the Luxembourg New Code of Civil Procedure, which provides that mortgagees are authorised to have a mortgaged real estate asset sold by a notary of their choice in order to have the proceeds of the sale paid towards discharge of principal, interest and costs. In accordance with Article 879 of the Luxembourg New Code of Civil Procedure, the sale can only take place 30 days after the order to enforce the Luxembourg law mortgage.
In the absence of a clause of immediate execution without recourse to legal procedure, the formalities relating to the seizure of real estate assets contained in Articles 809 and seq. of the Luxembourg New Code of Civil Procedure must be complied with, in which case, the seizure proceeding may take several months.
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
The provision of guarantees by Luxembourg companies is subject to corporate benefit restrictions.
A guarantee provided by a Luxembourg company must be for the benefit ("intérêt social') of that company, i.e. the company must derive from any transaction a direct or indirect economic or commercial benefit.
The provision of guarantees for the obligations of direct or indirect subsidiaries is unlikely to raise any concerns, but the provision of cross-stream and upstream guarantees may be more problematic.
Failure to comply with the corporate benefit requirement will typically result in liability for the managers, but not in the invalidity of the guarantee.
However, Luxembourg company law has a concept of misuse of corporate assets that may impact the validity of the guarantee itself in the following situations. If:
the guaranteed liabilities would materially exceed the (direct or indirect) benefit derived by the Luxembourg company from the loan to its affiliate, or
the Luxembourg company derives no personal benefit or obtains no direct or indirect consideration for the guarantee provided, or
the commitment of the Luxembourg company exceeds its financial means,
the managers of the Luxembourg company may be held criminally liable for having misused the Luxembourg company's assets. In such a case, the guarantee itself could be held unenforceable, as its provision would have been contrary to public policy ("ordre public").
The above analysis is slightly different within a group of companies where a group interest can be recognised, which prevents the guarantee from falling foul of the misuse of assets corporate prohibition, in which case three criteria must be met. These are:
the "assisting" company must receive some benefit, or there must be a balance between the respective commitments of all the affiliates;
the financial assistance must not exceed the assisting company's financial means, in which case it is usual for the guarantee to be limited to an aggregate amount not exceeding 80% to 95% of the guarantor's own funds ("capitaux propres"); and
the companies involved must form part of a genuine group operating under a common strategy aimed at a common objective.
No specific limitation is required in connection with the granting of security interests (including real estate security).
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
Pursuant to articles 2146 of the Luxembourg Civil Code and 445 of the Luxembourg Commercial Code, a Luxembourg law mortgage may be null and void if it relates to a debt previously incurred by the Luxembourg company owning the real estate asset during a period of up to 6 months prior to a bankruptcy judgment.
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
Yes
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
N/A
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
No
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
"All-risk" including fire, pipe water, storm and hail
Terrorism
Natural disasters
Building and property owner liability insurance
Loss of rent insurance
Other risks
What other insurances are usually required?
N/A
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
A valuation is usually required in case of specific events, such as the occurrence of an event of default and more generally at any time upon the request of the lender. The borrower is usually required to bear the costs for the valuations.
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
If the real estate asset is located in Luxembourg, in addition to the Luxembourg law mortgage, lenders will usually require a pledge over the company’s bank account(s) and receivables, including rental income and insurance proceeds.
Contacts
Stephané Braun
[email protected]
+352 28 57 39 210
Cyril d'Herbes
Cyril.D'[email protected]
+352 28 57 39 265
Charlène Thibaudon
Cyril.D'[email protected]
+352 28 57 39 240
Netherlands
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Mortgage over real property, pledge over shares, pledge over membership interests, pledge over partnership interests and pledge over other assets.
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
Dutch law deed of mortgage
In Dutch real estate financings it is common practice to vest (i) a mortgage over real property and (ii) also to include in the deed of mortgage a pledge over the moveable assets.
A mortgage over real property should always be done by way of a notarial deed.
The respective rank of a Dutch mortgage can be verified through searches in the Dutch Land Registry (Kadaster) after the mortgage has been executed and validly registered (this is however not possible for a pledge over movables).
Dutch law deed of pledge of shares
A pledge over registered shares in a Dutch B.V. or N.V. can only be created and perfected by notarial deed. The articles of the company whose shares are pledged must be amended before the notarial deed of pledge is executed if they prohibit the granting of a right of pledge over the company’s shares (and/or the attribution of voting and meeting rights to the pledgee).
Dutch law pledge of membership interests and partnership interests.
A right of pledge over membership interests in a cooperative (coöperatie) or over partnership interests in a limited partnership (commanditair belang) can be created and perfected by either a notarial deed or a private deed, if and to the extent permitted under the constitutional documents of the co-operative and the limited partnership respectively.
A Dutch law deed of pledge of shares and Dutch law pledge of membership interests and partnership interests are commonly preferred by lenders as such security creates a single point of enforcement pursuant to which pledgees can relatively easily have the entities lower in the corporate structure, and their assets, disposed as part of the enforcement process.
Dutch law omnibus deed of pledge
Security over claims and receivables (except rights to order (recht aan order) or rights to bearer (recht aan toonder)) is created by a right of pledge. It is common practice in the Netherlands for real estate financings that an omnibus deed of pledge includes (i) a disclosed pledge over bank accounts, lease receivables (where there are a limited number of tenants), insurance receivables, intercompany receivables, acquisition receivables, movable assets, receivables under management agreements, receivables under development documents (in the case of a development financing) and hedging receivables and (ii) an undisclosed pledge over trade receivables and lease receivables (where the property is leased to a high number of tenants or fluctuating group of tenants).
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Fixed ranking, but mandatory Dutch law enforcement provisions apply such as claims against the bankruptcy estate (e.g. salary of the liquidator (curator) and interest starting from the day of the bankruptcy) and preferential claims (e.g. claims from the Dutch Tax Administration).
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
N/A
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
Yes. A Dutch law deed of mortgage is executed as a notarial deed by the mortgagor by either appearing in front of the notary or, more commonly, by granting authority to a Dutch notary pursuant to a Dutch law notarial power of attorney.
A Dutch law share pledge is executed as a notarial deed by each party by either appearing in front of the notary or, more commonly, by granting authority to a Dutch notary pursuant to Dutch law powers of attorney. Signatures on such powers of attorney will have to be legalised by a Dutch notary or a non-Dutch public notary that is admitted to the BAR of the respective non-Dutch jurisdiction and an apostille will be required if such legalisation is performed by a non-Dutch notary.
Dutch law pledges of membership interests, partnership interests and Dutch law omnibus deeds of pledge are executed as (non-notarial) agreements by the parties. In respect of Dutch law omnibus pledges:
a disclosed right of pledge must be created by a written deed of pledge and notice of the right of pledge to the debtor.
an undisclosed right of pledge must be created by a written deed of pledge and either:
a) executed in the form of a notarial deed; or
b) more commonly, executed as a private deed of pledge and registered with the Dutch tax authorities.
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
After a Dutch law mortgage is executed, it is submitted by the Dutch notary to the Dutch Land Registry (Kadaster), usually on the same business day. The Dutch Land Registry (Kadaster) can be checked to verify the registration and correct ranking the next business day, or the following day if submitted on or after 15.00 pm on the day the deed is executed.
A Dutch law share pledge is registered by the Dutch notary in the shareholders’ register of a Dutch B.V. or N.V. which shares are pledged immediately upon the execution of such share pledge.
A Dutch law pledge of membership interests and partnership interests in respect of a cooperative (coöperatie) is registered by the cooperative (coöperatie) in the members’ register of cooperative (coöperatie) which membership interests are pledged immediately upon the execution of such pledge.
A Dutch law pledge of membership interests, partnership interests and a Dutch law omnibus deed of pledge are customarily registered as a (private) deed of pledge with the Dutch tax authorities. It may take two weeks or so for such registration to be completed and evidence of such registration has been received from the Dutch tax authorities.
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
No
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
N/A
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
Under Dutch law, a pledgee is entitled to take recourse against the assets if the pledgor (and/or any other obligors, where applicable) is in default (verzuim) with the performance of the secured obligations. In certain circumstances, a notice of default (ingebrekestelling) will be required before the Pledgee can initiate the enforcement process.
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
Depending on the assets that will be subject to the security, delivery of copies of title documents and evidence of registration of title to the property in the Dutch Land Registry.
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
General
Under Dutch law, a pledgee is entitled to take recourse against the pledged assets (the Assets) if the pledgor (and/or any other obligors, where applicable) is in default (verzuim) with the performance of the obligations which are secured pursuant to the pledge (the Secured Obligations). A notice of default (ingebrekestelling) will be required before the pledgee can initiate the enforcement process.
There are two ways to enforce a pledge under Dutch law: (i) by public auction, or (ii) by private sale. This constitutes mandatory Dutch law.
Public auction
The Dutch Civil Code (Burgerlijk Wetboek) provides that the enforcement of a pledge by means of a sale should, in principle, be done by public auction. The auction must be held in accordance with local standards and general terms of sale are applicable. The sale will take place under the supervision of a court bailiff or a notary. The pledgee will be entitled to participate in the bidding process.
The enforcement of a pledge in respect of assets other than real estate assets by public auction is rare in practice. In the majority of cases, parties choose a private sale which can be quicker and less costly.
The enforcement of a mortgage in respect of real estate assets usually takes place by way public auction (which is likely to generate wider interest from buyers) in accordance with the general enforcement rules applicable to pledges although some additional rules relating to enforcement of a deed of mortgage may apply.
Private sale
In accordance with Dutch law, the pledgee is entitled to enforce its security rights through a private sale of the assets, after the approval of the court of the pledgor or its trustee, as the case may be.
Alternatively, the pledgee has the option to ask such court to decide that the assets may stay (verblijven) with the pledgee providing ownership free from the pledge.
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
There are no restrictions on third party guarantees/security, provided that the articles of association of a Dutch company allow this (if this is not the case, an amendment of the articles of association can be requested at the outset).
Provided the security document secures the obligations of co-borrowers, the proceeds can be used to repay the secured obligations under a loan facility agreement.
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
The rights of secured creditors generally remain unaffected by insolvency proceedings under the laws in the Netherlands.
Secured claims take priority in respect of the proceeds of the secured assets without the involvement of an insolvency practitioner and can be enforced directly.
However, an insolvency court may order a temporary moratorium or "freeze-order" (afkoelingsperiode) during which creditors may not enforce rights against assets of the debtor without the approval of the bankruptcy judge (rechter commissaris) of the Court. Such moratorium may be ordered for a period of up to two months (and extended once by another two months) or, if part of a creditor accord proceeding, for a period of up to four months (and extended once by another period of up to four months).
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
Yes
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
N/A
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
No
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
"All-risk" including fire, pipe water, storm and hail
Terrorism
Building and property owner liability insurance
Loss of rent insurance
What other insurances are usually required?
Professional indemnity cover in respect of the property manager and the asset manager.
There is lender’s tendency to ask for insurance against flooding, but such security can be expensive to maintain in The Netherlands and for that reason (as applicable) dropped as an insurance requirement.
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
As a condition precedent, at any time when the facility agent/lender considers a default is outstanding or is likely to occur as a result of the request by the facility agent/lender, following completion of any (major) development of the property and in connection with the compulsory purchase of all or part of the property and each year.
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
Security may also be taken over moveable assets, lease receivables, insurance receivables, intercompany receivables, acquisition receivables, receivables under management agreements, receivables under development documents (in the case of a development financing), hedging receivables and trade receivables, and bank accounts.
Contacts
Jasper Dijkshoorn
[email protected]
+31 6 43262672
Poland
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Mortgage (Hipoteka)
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
Transfer of title by way of security (przewłaszczenie na zabezpieczenie) offers outright transfer of ownership to real estate with obligation to re-transfer once the loan is repaid in full; mortgage is limited right in rem which does not transfer ownership title to real estate to the beneficiary of the security, but rather provides priority on enforcement
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Fixed ranking
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
N/A
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
As a rule, if a Polish bank or a Polish branch of an EEA-based credit institution is a beneficiary of a mortgage, a simple written form with the bank's stamps is sufficient (a so-called bank form). If a beneficiary is a different creditor, a notarial deed is needed to establish a mortgage.
Regardless of the identity of the beneficiary of the mortgage, a notarial deed is needed to establish a mortgage in favour of a security agent to secure claims of multiple creditors (a so-called administrator's mortgage).
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
A mortgage enters into force on the date of its registration in the land and mortgage register maintained by the common courts in Poland.
A mortgage statement in the form of a notarial deed is filed for registration by a notary public.
A mortgage statement in a so-called form is filed for registration using dedicated forms.
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
Yes
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
Given lengthly mortgage registration process in Poland (2-8 months) it is common practice to utilise loans based on requiring the mortgage statement and confirmation of its due filing for registration as conditions precedent.
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
Immediately enforceable
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
N/A
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
No out of court enforcement options are available in relation to real property security. It is advisable therefore that any borrower establishing a mortgage over real estate submits to execution in the form of a notarial deed, which allows the creditor to bypass the need for court proceedings.
Enforcement proceedings are regulated by the Polish Civil Procedure Code and enforcement is effected by a court bailiff.
A secured creditor has to follow the prescribed court process in order to enforce its security, which includes obtaining an enforcement title (e.g. a court judgement or notarial deed) with an execution clause granted by a relevant court in separate proceedings or a judgment/award of a foreign court enforceable in accordance with the relevant EU regulation or recognised in Poland in a special court procedure on the basis of Polish Civil Procedure Code (also applicable to UK court judgements following the UK’s exit from the European Union).
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
There is no concept of corporate benefit in Poland. Assuming that an affiliate of a borrower is incorporated under Polish law and the up-stream or cross-stream security or guarantee is governed by Polish law, there are no restrictions on the provision of such security/guarantee by that affiliate, save for:
the capital maintenance restrictions applicable to private limited companies (sp. z o.o.), where such companies are providing guarantees for the debts of their parents (normally dealt with by the guarantee limitation language in each guarantee); and
financial assistance restrictions in case of joint-stock (S.A.) companies.
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
The enforcement of security over real estate in Poland is not quick, and obtaining an enforcement title through court proceedings is usually time-consuming and requires proving the claims against the borrower in court.
It is therefore advisable to require that any borrower establishing a mortgage over real estate submits to execution in the form of a notarial deed, which allows the creditor to bypass the need for court proceedings against the debtor and enforce the claim faster.
It is also worth noting that the standard package of commercial real estate security usually also includes security over the shares in the property owning company enabling an alternative enforcement of the share security rather than going through lengthy court-led enforcement proceedings.
There are also certain restrictions surrounding who may participate in a sales auction relating to the enforcement of a mortgage, especially in relation to agricultural land, that need to be considered and may impact enforcement.
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
Yes
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
N/A
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
No
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
"All-risk" including fire, pipe water, storm and hail
Natural disasters
Building and property owner liability insurance
Loss of rent insurance
What other insurances are usually required?
N/A
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
2 year intervals for full valuation
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
Security over receivables under lease agreements (security assignment)
Security over receivables under insurance agreements (security assignment)
Security over bank accounts (financial pledge, registered pledge, accounts power of attorney, blockade)
Security over assets (registered pledge)
Security over shares in borrower (financial pledge, registered pledge, power of attorney to exercise corporate rights)
Contacts
Grzegorz Dyczkowski
[email protected]
+48 22 581 4949
Tomasz Rogalski
[email protected]
+48 22 581 4988
Daniel Popek
[email protected]
+48 22 581 4916
Spain
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Mortgage (Hipoteca)
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
The “Hipoteca” (commonly translated as Mortgage) is a security interest over real estate property under Spanish law. It is an in rem right which is attached to the real estate or property affected by the security and will therefore continue to affect it even when the owner of the property changes. It is ancillary to the secured obligation and decays once the secured obligation is settled and will benefit the assignee creditor, although such assignment will also require registration. It requires a Spanish public deed granted before a Spanish notary public and due registration in the Land Property Registry in order to become fully enforceable.
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Fixed ranking
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
N/A
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
Mortgages must be notarised before a Spanish notary in a public deed (escritura pública). Public deeds require simultaneous appearance of all parties (creditors and mortgagor) before the notary.
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
After notarisation, stamp duty must be settled and the public deed must be filed with the Land Registry. Notaries send electronic copies of the deed to the Registry promptly after execution in order to secure ranking, but this must be complemented with the original document after a few days. Standard time for registration is 15 business days after filing if no defects are found by the registrar.
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
Yes
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
No particular requirements are usually required other than notarial formalities and contractual deadlines for registration of the mortgage (generally no less than 1-2 months).
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
Further actions are required for enforcement.
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
The mortgage should be first registered in the Land Registry. Standard registration time is 15 business days after filing but it generally takes longer (1-2 months).
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
Enforcement of a mortgage is a well-established and tested process generally undertaken through special judicial proceedings. Assuming there are no insolvency proceedings involved and that there are no grounds for opposition by the security provider (grounds for opposing a mortgage enforcement are very limited and generally related to formal matters regarding the mortgage title), the process may take between 4-6 months. The proceeds would be realised at the end of the process. This is assuming the security provider is not a consumer.
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
In principle there is no restriction. The only general restriction relates to “financial assistance” (asistencia financiera) prohibitions ‑i.e. when securing or guaranteeing debt incurred by the borrower to purchase share capital (including by way of capital increase) of the security or guarantee provider or an affiliate of the security or guarantee provider.
These rules vary slightly depending on whether the company granting security or guarantee is (i) a “sociedad anónima” (in which case it cannot provide guarantee or security for debt incurred to purchase its shares or the shares of its controlling company) or (ii) a “sociedad limitada” (in which case it cannot provide guarantee or security for debt incurred to purchase its shares or the shares of any other company of its corporate group).
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
Subject to regulation applicable under an insolvency scenario, in principle there should not be any particular issues preventing enforcement assuming a standard property mortgage (and not granted to consumers), but enforcement of each property needs to be analysed on a case-by-case basis.
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
Yes
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
N/A
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
No
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
"All-risk" including fire, pipe water, storm and hail
Building and property owner liability insurance
What other insurances are usually required?
N/A
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
This is highly dependent on the transaction and lender, but generally yearly.
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
Pledge over borrower and propco shares
Pledge of bank accounts
Pledge of receivables under main agreements
Pledge of subordinated debt receivables.
Contacts
Garrigues
Gaspar Atienza
[email protected]
+34 91 514 50 62
Jon Goirigolzarri
[email protected]
+34 91 514 52 00
Switzerland
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Mortgage certificate (Schuldbrief)
Mortgage contract (Grundpfandverschreibung)
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Mortgage certificate (Schuldbrief)
Non-accessory/ abstract
Mortgage contract (Grundpfandverschreibung)
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
A security interest over real estate may be created in the form of a mortgage certificate (Schuldbrief) or in the form of a mortgage contract (Grundpfandverschreibung). No other types of mortgages are permitted under the current law. In certain cantons of Switzerland, there is sometimes a combined form of a mortgage certificate (Schuldbrief) and a mortgage contract (Grundpfandverschreibung), which is, however, going back to old cantonal and customary law. Because of its rarity and the regional particularities, this type of security interest is not further discussed.
The mortgage certificate (Schuldbrief) serves as security for claims whose existence is clearly and unambiguously determined in every respect. The mortgage certificate has the form of either a register mortgage certificate (Register-Schuldbrief) or a mortgage certificate on paper (Papier-Schuldbrief). For a mortgage certificate on paper (Papier-Schuldbrief), a security paper is issued, which is not the case for register mortgage certificates (Register-Schuldbriefe).
In contrast to the mortgage certificate (Schuldbrief), the mortgage contract (Grundpfandverschreibung) serves to secure any claim. It can be used to secure a present or a future claim or even just a possible claim. The claim has its own existence. It exists independently of the mortgage contract (Grundpfandverschreibung), and the creation of the security interest does not result in a novation. The creditor may request from the land registrar to provide an extract from the land register showing the mortgage contract (Grundpfandverschreibung). Such an extract has only evidential status and does not constitute a security paper.
The choice of the type of security interest is at the discretion of the parties. For statutory security interests over real estate, however, only mortgage contracts (Grundpfandverschreibungen) are available. There are no statutory mortgage certificates (Schuldbriefe).
It is market standard for real estate financing transactions to use mortgage certificates (Schuldbriefe). Apart from that, the nature of the claim to be secured and cantonal practice often determine the type of security interest used.
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Fixed ranking
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
N/A
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
The creation of a security interest over real estate in the form of a mortgage certificate (Schuldbrief) or in the form of a mortgage contract (Grundpfandverschreibung) requires a contract or a declaration in the form of a public deed, to be signed in front of a notary public, and the registration of the security interest in the land register. If the lender is a person abroad in the sense of the Swiss Federal Act on the Acquisition of Immovable property in Switzerland by foreign non-residents (so-called "Lex Koller"), further restrictions must be considered and may require a prior formal decision of the competent authority.
The land register entry is constitutive, subject to certain statutory security interests that are created by operation of law once the legal requirements are fulfilled, for instance a statutory mortgage relating to public-law charges in connection with real estate.
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
The registration of the security interest in the land register occurs in a two step process.
As the first step, upon application by the landowner, the security interest is registered in the daybook of the land register. This registration is decisive for the rank and for the age priority of the security interest.
In due course after the registration in the daybook, the second step is for the land registrar to check all legal registration requirements and, if they are fulfilled, register the security interest in the main book of the land register. This registration is decisive for the security interest to be created and become legally effective. The time of its legal effect is referred back to the registration in the daybook of the land register.
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
No, except for construction loans for which in practice the security interest is not always created before the first draw down but sometimes only during construction or even at the end of construction, depending on the type of construction loan.
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
No, except for construction loans for which in practice the security interest is not always created before the first draw down but sometimes only during construction or even at the end of construction, depending on the type of construction loan.
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
Further actions required for enforcement.
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
Mortgage certificate (Schuldbrief)
The realisation of a mortgage certificate (Schuldbrief) depends on the way in which it secures a particular claim.
In the case of a direct security, the creditor acquires ownership in the mortgage certificate (Schuldbrief) and waives the underlying claim. The mortgage certificate claim (Schuldbriefforderung) replaces the extinguished underlying claim (novation). The realisation of the mortgage certificate (Schuldbrief) requires a debt enforcement proceeding on the realisation of a real estate pledge (Betreibung auf Grundpfandverwertung).
In the case of an assignment by way of security (Sicherungsübereignung), the creditor acquires fiduciary ownership in the mortgage certificate (Schuldbrief). The underlying claim remains in existence. The parties agree that the creditor may only use the mortgage certificate claim (Schuldbriefforderung) to the extent it is necessary to enforce the underlying claim. The realisation of the mortgage certificate (Schuldbrief) requires a debt enforcement proceeding on the realisation of a real estate pledge (Betreibung auf Grundpfandverwertung).
In the case of an indirect security, the debtor grants the creditor a pledge (Faustpfand) over the mortgage certificate (Schuldbrief). The realisation of the mortgage certificate (Schuldbrief) requires a debt enforcement proceeding on the realisation of a pledge of chattels (Betreibung auf Faustpfandverwertung).
In the case of a special agreement between the parties, it may not be necessary to go through a formal debt enforcement proceeding on the realisation of a pledge. This applies if the parties have agreed that the creditor may realise the pledge privately, which may be possible within a short period of time.
Otherwise, the duration of the realisation procedure depends largely on whether or not the debtor defends himself against the realisation of the pledge. If the debtor does not object against the payment order, then the request for realisation of pledged chattels may be filed at the earliest one month after the payment order has been served to the debtor. In the case of a real estate pledge, the creditor must wait for six months until he may file the request for realisation of the real estate pledge. Thereafter, the realisation of movable property must take place within two months and the realisation of real property must take place within three months.
If, on the other hand, the debtor defends himself against the realisation of the pledge, in particular by objecting against the payment order and by defending himself in the subsequent legal proceedings, then the realisation may take several months to years.
Mortgage contract (Grundpfandverschreibung)
The realisation of a mortgage contract (Grundpfandverschreibung) requires a debt enforcement proceeding on the realisation of a real estate pledge (Betreibung auf Grundpfandverwertung).
In the case of a special agreement between the parties, it may not be necessary to go through a formal debt enforcement proceeding on the realisation of a pledge. This applies if the parties have agreed that the creditor may realise the pledge privately, which may be possible within a short period of time.
Otherwise, the duration of the realisation procedure depends largely on whether or not the debtor defends himself against the realisation of the pledge. If the debtor does not object against the payment order, then the request for realisation of the real estate pledge may be filed at the earliest six months after the payment order has been served to the debtor. Thereafter, the realisation of real property must take place within three months.
If, on the other hand, the debtor defends himself against the realisation of the pledge, in particular by objecting against the payment order and by defending himself in the subsequent legal proceedings, then the realisation may take several months to years.
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
Private enforcement of a mortgage and/or sale of a mortgage certificate
Swiss law distinguishes between mortgages (Grundpfandverschreibungen) and mortgage certificates (Schuldbriefe) as the main types of securities over real estate.
a) Mortgages
If all involved parties have agreed by way of a public deed, then no proceedings with the Swiss authorities are required for the enforcement of a mortgage. In such a case, how and within what period the mortgage may be enforced are governed by the public deed and, to a small extent, mandatory Swiss law provisions. Such agreements are, however, unusual in practice.
b) Mortgage certificates
The mortgage certificate qualifies as a negotiable security. Therefore, instead of initiating proceedings with the Swiss authorities to enforce a mortgage certificate, in most cases the creditor may simply sell the mortgage certificate to a third party, who then becomes the new mortgagee.
Generally, such private enforcements may be completed within a relatively short period as the creditor is not obliged to observe specific statutory deadlines.
Enforcement of real estate collaterals by way of debt collection proceedings
To initiate debt collection proceeding, the creditor whose claim is secured by a real estate collateral has to file a request for debt collection with the debt collection office. Based on this request, the debt collection office will send a payment order (Zahlungsbefehl) to the debtor. Upon receipt of the payment order, the debtor has ten days to raise an objection (Rechtsvorschlag) with the debt collection office. If the debtor raises such an objection, the debt collection proceedings will be stayed and the creditor has to set aside the objection in court proceedings (as detailed below).
Once a judgment to set aside the objection is in force, or if the debtor has not objected to the debt collection proceedings, the creditor may file a request for the realisation of the real estate collateral. Such request may be filed by the creditor with the debt collection office at the earliest six months, and at latest two years after the payment order has been sent to the debtor.
Upon receipt of the request for the realisation of the real estate collateral, the debt collection office will determine the realisation method. Under Swiss law, real estate collateral is generally realised by way of public auction and after officially publishing the auction conditions and summoning all the parties concerned to file their potential claims to the real estate collateral.
The costs of administration, realisation and distribution are deducted directly from the proceeds of the realisation of the real estate collateral. Only the net proceeds are distributed to the creditor up to the amount of his claim.
Generally, the enforcement of real estate collateral by way of debt collection proceedings is rather cumbersome, as the creditor is obliged to observe specific statutory deadlines and formalities. It takes at least six to twelve months. If the debtor exhausts all available legal remedies, the enforcement of real estate collateral by way of debt collection proceedings may take several years.
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
From a Swiss corporate law perspective, the provision of any security in favour of other group companies (or third parties) must also be in the interests of the guarantor company.
In addition, intra-group up-stream and cross-stream security must fulfil specific corporate law requirements, such as an explicit basis in the articles of association, board and shareholder resolutions, as well as freely distributable funds in the required amount.
Further, intra-group security may not constitute a prohibited repayment of contributions. If there is no actual and credible intention of the borrower to repay the loan, or if the borrower was unable to repay the loan from the outset, a prohibited repayment of contributions is assumed.
Should these requirements not be fulfilled, then the legal validity of the security is called into question, which may result in liability claims against the board members and other persons acting on behalf of the companies involved.
The enforcement of third party real estate security would require the creditor to observe certain additional formal requirements, such as the involvement of the third party security provider in the debt enforcement proceedings from the outset.
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
The main issue that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of real estate collateral is the debtor's right to raise an objection against the payment order (see above). The creditor must apply to court to set aside such an objection. The duration and nature of the court proceeding depends on the evidence the creditor can put forward. Only if the creditor can provide written evidence of the existence of his claim and the mortgage and/or mortgage certificate, can the objection be set aside in expedited summary court proceedings. While Swiss law stipulates short deadlines for a court to issue a judgment in expedited summary proceedings, such proceedings may still take several months. The debtor has the right to appeal against an expedited summary judgment or bring action for revocation of the claim (Aberkennungsklage). As a rule of thumb, it takes an appellate court or a first instance court in ordinary proceedings about a year to render a judgment, which may be subject to further appeal.
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
Yes
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
N/A
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
No
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
"All-risk" including fire, pipe water, storm and hail
Terrorism
Natural disasters
Building and property owner liability insurance
Loss of rent insurance
What other insurances are usually required?
N/A
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
Neither Swiss law nor the Swiss Banking Guidelines for the Assessment, Valuation and Processing of Mortgage-Backed Loans (SwissBanking Richtlinien für die Prüfung, Bewertung und Abwicklung grundpfandgesicherter Kredite) provide for a defined minimum valuation interval.
Rather, the Swiss Banking guidelines provide that the bank determines the maximum permissible intervals at which the mortgaged properties are revaluated. These intervals depend on the type of property, the amount of the loan and the market situation. In the event of negative market changes, the bank estimates the risk potential and defines the necessary measures. Within the framework of a specific risk analysis to be carried out periodically, the bank assesses the impact on the value of the mortgage portfolio, with a focus on the properties that are valued by using valuation models.
The Swiss Banking guidelines are binding self-regulation that have been approved by the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA) and that are considered to be the minimum regulatory standard. The auditors check compliance with these standards.
In practice, banks use contract clauses entitling them at any time to assess the value of the mortgaged property. To this end, the borrower must grant the bank’s representatives or appointed experts unrestricted access to the mortgaged property and provide such persons with any information which is requested.
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
Depending on the borrower, its business activities and the potential risks related to the individual case, lenders may ask for security over bank accounts, security over accounts receivables such as rental income, purchase price claims and insurance claims, guarantees from group companies, subordination of shareholder and related group company loans, as well as security over the shares in the borrower.
Contacts
Pestalozzi
Dr. iur. Michael Lips
[email protected]
+41 44 217 92 67
Dr. iur. Larissa Rickenbacher
[email protected]
+41 44 217 92 33
Turkey
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Mortgage (İpotek)
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
Under Turkish Law, a security interest over a real estate asset can only be established in the form of a:
Mortgage (ipotek)
Mortgage bond (ipotekli borç senedi)
Land charge note (irat senedi)
Among these, the mortgage is the only option that is widely used in practice, both in local and cross-border transactions. Mortgage bonds and land charge notes are almost never used in practice, as they require much more complex formalities for establishment and enforcement.
In addition, a mortgage on leaseholds orbuilding rights (üst hakkı rehni) is also an option that is commonly used in financing transactions, especially in construction and energy projects. Leaseholds or building rights which are established independently (i.e. transfer of ownership to third parties is not restricted) and continuously (i.e. established for a period of at least 30 years, or indefinitely) may be mortgaged.
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
Fixed ranking
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
N/A
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
Establishment of a mortgage requires execution of a mortgage deed before the Land Registry Office where the immovable property is located. In order to execute the mortgage deed, the parties (or their representatives) must be present at the Land Registry Office at the same time.
Although the legal framework allows parties to execute the mortgage deed remotely from other Land Registry Offices (regardless of the location of the immovable property), in practice, the Land Registry Offices are very reluctant to exercise this option, especially in complex transactions.
It should also be noted that powers of attorney to be used for representation before Land Registry Offices must be issued in a specific format. Also, certain formal requirements are applicable to powers of attorney issued abroad. Accordingly, these powers of attorney must be issued by a notary in the official language of the country of issuance and apostilled (or issued before a Turkish consulate) and bear the photographs of the grantors. These powers of attorney are then translated into Turkish by a sworn translator and certified by a Turkish notary.
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
Establishment of a mortgage over an immovable property requires:
Execution of a mortgage deed before the Land Registry Office.
Registration of the mortgage with the Land Registry Office, upon application of the mortgagee or the mortgagor.
A statement of the principal amount and applicable interest that is subject to the mortgage deed. If a definite amount cannot be determined at the time of execution of the mortgage deed, a maximum amount must be stated.
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
No
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
N/A
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
This depends on the way the security interest is created.
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
Enforcement of a security interest following an event of default is initiated and overseen by the Execution Offices. Enforcement is achieved by way of sale of the property through public auction. The underlying principle for the requirement to use a public auction to enforce a security interest is that the debtor and creditor are not allowed to agree in advance that the creditor automatically acquires title to the secured asset upon default by the debtor (the so-called “lex commissoria” principle).
In order to determine the prerequisites and timeframe of enforcing Turkish law mortgages, a distinction based on the scope of the mortgage has to be made. There are two types of mortgage under Turkish law, depending on their scope:
Principal (definite) amount mortgages (ana para ipoteği), which cover only the payment of a principal amount, costs related to the execution proceedings and default interest. A principal amount mortgage is available only if the sums due at the time of establishment of the mortgage are readily ascertainable.
Maximum amount mortgages (üst sınır ipoteği), which cover all claims, including the interest and other secondary claims up to a maximum amount. If the sums due by the debtor cannot be ascertained at the time of establishment of the mortgage, then a maximum amount mortgage must be established.
A principal amount mortgage can be enforced without obtaining a court judgment first, and therefore is easier to enforce. The enforcement process can be completed within approximately 6 months.
By contrast, the mortgagor has the right to object to the existence of an obligation under a maximum amount mortgage. Therefore, enforcement of maximum amount mortgages may be significantly longer (approximately 3 years), due to the judicial process prolonged by the hearing of the mortgagor's objections and defences.
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
To enforce security over real estate, a lender can apply to an execution office for the issuance of a payment order. The payment order will demand the payment of the debt. If the debt is not paid or an objection against the payment order is not filed within the time specified in the order, the execution proceedings will resume and the property will be sold through public auction.
Depending on the documents (forming the legal basis of the debt) available to the lender, there are two types of execution proceedings the lender may pursue; (i) execution proceedings with judgment; and (ii) execution proceedings without judgment.
If there is an unconditional and absolute acknowledgement of the debt, or there is a court judgment or a document with similar legal effect, the lender can apply for execution proceedings with judgment. If none of these exist, the lender can only commence execution proceedings without judgment. The benefit of applying for execution proceedings with judgment is that the borrower can have the proceedings suspended only on very limited grounds.
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
No, a third party may provide guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations.
Under Turkish law, the rule of compulsory joinder of parties applies to such third party and the borrower. Therefore, security over real estate must be enforced against both the borrower and guarantor or security provider in the same execution proceedings.
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
Following the service of a payment order in execution proceedings without judgment, a borrower can file an objection against the order within the statutory time period and the proceedings will suspend automatically. To resume the proceedings, the lender must bring an action before a competent court to set the objection aside. The debtor’s objection may significantly delay the enforcement of security over real estate.
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
Yes
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
N/A
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
No
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
"All-risk" including fire, pipe water, storm and hail
Terrorism
Natural disasters
Building and property owner liability insurance
What other insurances are usually required?
N/A
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
Although it is not required by law, it is common practice that the mortgagor provides up-to-date valuation reports on financed properties from time to time. This period of time may depend on the specific case, information covenants under the relevant facility agreement, and general economic outlook (e.g. inflation rates, foreign exchange rates).
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
Typically in real estate financing lenders may also take security over the shares of the debtor, security over movable assets via a movable property pledge (TARES), and/or security over the bank accounts.
Assignments of receivables made for security purposes (income from rent, insurance etc.) may also be taken.
Contacts
Inal Unver Attorney Partnership
H. Alper Tüzün
[email protected]
+90 212 386 1303
Duygu Ozmen
[email protected]
Hasan Eker
[email protected]
United Kingdom
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
Security interest
Charge by way of legal mortgage
Is the security interest accessory (i.e. dependent on the principal obligation) or an abstract security interest?
Accessory
What are the differences between the respective security interests and which security interest is market standard for real estate financing transactions?
The market standard form of security interest used to take security over land under English law is the charge by way of legal mortgage. This is created by a statutory procedure by which the creditor is given a statutory interest in the land which is effectively equivalent to a legal mortgage (see below). It doesn’t transfer title to the mortgagee, but it will give the mortgagee a proprietary interest in the land.
Legal Mortgage – transfers legal title to the mortgagee and prevents the mortgagor from dealing with the mortgaged asset while it is subject to the mortgage.
Equitable Mortgage – arises where the formalities to create a legal mortgage have not been completed or where the asset being mortgaged is only an equitable interest. It only transfers a beneficial interest in the land.
Fixed Charge – similar to an equitable mortgage, it only transfers a beneficial interest in the land. Usually used to take security over future acquired real estate or real estate which is not legally owned by the chargor.
Floating Charge – usually taken over all assets of a chargor which could include land. It allows the chargor to deal with the assets that are the subject of the floating charge and only crystallises into a fixed charge if there is a default or similar event. Floating charges rank behind fixed charges.
Is the security interest recognised for temporary rights (i.e. heritable building rights, leaseholds, ground leases or similar rights)?
Yes
Does the security interest provide for a fixed rank (i.e. other creditors cannot subsequently create a charge (contractually or by law) which might rank ahead of the original charge)?
No fixed ranking
In case there is no fixed rank, how are the risks of subsequent prior ranking charges mitigated?
The priority of security is a complex area under English law. A basic analysis of rank would be that legal charges rank ahead of equitable charges and fixed charges rank ahead of floating charges.
The basic priority rule in relation to two competing security interests is that the first security interest in time prevails. There are however a number of exceptions to this rule. In summary these are: legal interests will usually take priority over equitable interests, priority may be given to a security interest where notice of that security interest has been given before the competing security interest (subject to certain exceptions), registration of the security interest at the Land Registry or Land Charges Department – the first security interest registered will take priority, where it would be inequitable to apply the first in time rule and where a security interest is granted to a lender who finances the asset being charged to it takes precedence over an earlier general charge over the assets of a company.
The risk of subsequent prior ranking charges will usually be mitigated by carrying out a search of Companies House (where the chargor is a company incorporated in England and Wales) and a “priority search” of the Land Registry shortly before completion. This Land Registry search grants the lender a clear window during which the charge by way of legal mortgage can be registered at the Land Registry ahead of other competing security or third-party interests. Moreover the borrower’s solicitors will normally give an undertaking to the lender to attend to the registration of the security at the Land Registry in a timely fashion and to deal with any queries (requisitions) raised by the Land Registry.
Are any particular formalities to be observed when the security interest is executed (e.g. notarisation)?
Any disposition of land, which would include the creation of a security interest, must be effected by a deed which must be in writing, clearly intended to be a deed on its face, validly executed and delivered as a deed. For an individual, this would require signing in the presence of a witness. For a company, a deed would need to be executed by two authorised signatories, being two directors, or a director and a secretary, or a single director in the presence of a witness.
In addition to the formalities relating to the execution of deeds generally, there are specific execution formalities to be complied with for security documents requiring registration at the Land Registry. These requirements differ depending on a number of factors including the jurisdiction of the parties, charitable and/or trust status, where parties are signing by power of attorney, whether a document is being signed using an electronic signature or in wet ink. Detailed Land Registry guidance referring to most of these formalities can be found in the Land Registry practice guides listed below, though other Land Registry practice guides may also need to be scrutinised depending on the specific transaction:
PG8 (Execution of deeds)
PG9 (Powers of attorney and registered land)
PG78 (Overseas entities)
PG82 (Electronic signatures accepted by HM Land Registry).
What are the filing and registration requirements for the security interest?
The filing requirements for security interests depend on a number of factors including the type of security interest, the nature of the property interest, whether the property is registered at the Land Registry or unregistered and the identity and/or jurisdiction of the chargor. The security may need to be registered at Companies House, the Land Registry or the Land Charges Department. Failure to register will not render the security void but it could prejudice that security's priority position. For example, the Land Registry will not accept an application to register a mortgage unless it has been registered at Companies House (where a mortgagor is a company or limited liability partnership). In turn, a mortgage will only take effect as a legal interest once it is registered at the Land Registry. Until then it will only take effect as an equitable interest.
Where security interests require registration at the Land Registry the application may need to be accompanied by additional documentation. In such cases, it is necessary to consult the relevant Land Registry guidance as early as possible in the transaction to confirm the specific requirements.
Notice of a security interest may need to be given to landlords of leasehold property, any prior lender, or third parties where the security is in respect of an equitable interest in property.
Is it customary in your jurisdiction that draw down under loans secured by real estate are made before the security interest has been registered in the relevant register?
Yes
What additional requirements need to be taken into account in these cases?
As set out above in respect of the question relating to the ranking of the security interest, lenders will be relying on the “priority search” carried out just before completion. The search certificate obtained thereby grants the lender a priority period during which the lender’s security may be registered in the relevant register ahead of other competing interests.
Is the security interest immediately enforceable or are certain prerequisites to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable?
Immediately enforceable
In cases where it depends on the way the security interest is created or where certain prerequisites are to be taken before the security interest becomes enforceable, what are these prerequisites and how long (as a rule of thumb) does it take to complete these?
N/A
How easy is it to, and in what time period is it possible to:
a) Enforce local law security over real estate in the applicable jurisdiction?; and
b) Realise the proceeds of the enforced security
Under English law, a lender can enforce security directly without an application to court
The security documents will give the secured lender rights to take possession and sell assets and apply the net proceeds against the secured debt. There are also statutory powers to do this, but the contractual rights in the security documents will be more extensive
The most common approach is to appoint a receiver who will take control of the secured assets and either apply any income, such as rental payments, or sell the assets. After costs of sale, the proceeds are used to discharge the secured debt.
Are there any restrictions on an affiliate of the borrower providing guarantees and/or real estate security in respect of a borrower’s loan obligations?
Would enforcement of those guarantees and third-party real estate security affect the enforcement process?
No, provided the directors of the guarantor company are satisfied there is a commercial benefit to the guarantor company in facilitating the lending arrangement for the borrower, there is no issue with cross or upstream guarantees. The guarantee document would usually contractually postpone the guarantor’s rights of indemnity from the debtor and subrogation of the secured creditor’s rights until the secured creditors have been fully repaid.
Are there any material issues that may prevent quick and easy enforcement of security over real estate assets?
If the debtor is subject to an insolvency rescue process, such as administration, or a director led moratorium, or a contractual standstill by agreement with creditors, then the rights to enforce may be postponed for a period. Commercial secured lenders are usually part of the discussions before such a process is started as their agreement will often be key to a successful outcome.
When advising on real estate financings, is it customary in your jurisdiction to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest?
Yes
In case it is not customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, how does the lender confirm that the security interest is enforceable?
N/A
In case it is customary to issue an enforceability opinion on the security interest, is it also customary to include specific CRR confirmations (in particular as Articles 194 para 1, 3, 4 sentence 1, and para 10, 208 para 2, 3, and 5, and 237 para 1 of the CRR)?
No
In case of not all of them, which CRR statements are usually included?
N/A
What typical insurance cover is required in loan agreements?
"All-risk" including fire, pipe water, storm and hail
Terrorism
Natural disasters
Building and property owner liability insurance
Loss of rent insurance
Other risks
What other insurances are usually required?
Insurance of the property and any plant and machinery for their full replacement value, insurance cover for site clearance, shoring or propping up, professional fees and value added tax together with adequate allowance for inflation, specifically where the financing relates to a development, contractor’s all risks insurance covering contractors and sub-contractors and professional indemnity insurance covering contractors, subcontractors and consultants with a design responsibility.
What customary valuation intervals for the valuation of financed properties through an independent valuation expert are required in loan agreements?
Annually would usual be the most frequent but for longer term loans or development loans the valuation intervals will differ.
In a typical real estate financing, what other types of security would lenders ask for?
In addition to the charge by way of legal mortgage over land in respect of the main propert(y)/(ies) being financed, lenders would usually expect to take security by way of a debenture over all of the borrower’s assets, including a fixed charge over any future acquired real estate, any rental income, insurance proceeds, all the rights that the borrower has under material contracts, the borrower’s accounts and any shares it may hold, as well as a floating charge over all of the borrower’s assets.
As the borrower will normally be a special purpose vehicle, lenders will usually also be looking to take security over the shares in the borrower, as well as security over any intercompany debt going into the borrower (which will also be subordinated).
Contacts
Sarah Cullen
[email protected]
+44 20 7444 3946