Canadian
employment and
labour quarterly

March 2026 | Issue 04

Responding to Hateful Speech in the Workplace

Best Practices in Conducting Workplace Investigations

Court and tribunal decisions

The pace of change in Canadian employment and labour law is rapid as legislatures, courts and tribunals try to keep up with the evolving world of work. Across 10 provinces, three territories and the federal jurisdiction, the volume of news for employers to digest is significant. Our regular newsletter keeps employers up to date on Canadian E&L developments and best practices.

If you have any questions, contact a member of our team.

Andrew Schafer

Partner, Vancouver

Contact me

Read my bio

Responding to Hateful Speech in the Workplace

Words can hurt. Slurs, offensive jokes or hateful views, when spoken in the workplace, can harm employees and undermine workplace morale in general. When employees, or persons with whom they engage with as part of their jobs, use such hateful speech it is incumbent on the employer to respond to protect the workplace. This obligation stems in part from an employer’s legislated duties to prevent workplace discrimination, harassment and violence. It is also a necessary part of any organization’s efforts to foster a culture of safety and inclusion.

Setting and enforcing a standard for acceptable employee speech is an ongoing project. Workplace policies and training alone will not inoculate the workplace against corrosive words. While these are necessary, they are not sufficient by themselves. Maintaining a culture of respectful workplace conduct requires an ongoing program of:

  • Setting expectations for appropriate speech through policies and training.

  • Enforcing expectations by creating mechanisms for reporting hateful speech and by training the management team on responding to complaints assertively and promptly.

  • Ensuring fairness by properly investigating each reported incident of hateful speech to establish what was said and the context in which it was said. See our "Best Practices in Conducting Workplace Investigations" below.

  • Fostering accountability by implementing appropriate discipline, or even summary dismissal, or customer bans, for hateful speech, and by following up with appropriate training for employees and management to reinforce expectations of respectful speech in the workplace.

Concerning this last point – fostering accountability through appropriate discipline – employers should treat hateful speech as serious misconduct. Adjudicators now view hateful speech as akin to assault or theft, potentially justifying summary dismissal. It is not a defense that speakers did not intend to cause harm, or believed they had license to speak as they did. The mere utterance of hateful speech presents a risk of harm that demands a corrective response. For more on this subject, see our update “It Was Just a Joke’: Hateful Words in the Workplace”.

The Norton Rose Fulbright employment and labour team is available to support employers in navigating challenges related to hateful speech in the workplace.

Best Practices in Conducting Workplace Investigations

Workplace investigations can be an essential component of an employer’s response to allegations or suspicions of workplace misconduct. They establish the facts of what has happened so the employer can decide what to do next. A good investigation provides a defensible foundation for imposing discipline, for taking remedial measures, or for dismissing an allegation as unfounded. A bad investigation undermines the integrity of such actions, opening them to dispute.

The issues that might prompt a workplace investigation vary widely, including fraud, theft, harassment (including hateful speech, as described above), safety violations, prohibited drug or alcohol use, or even off-duty misconduct that affects the employer’s interests. In some cases, an investigation may be required by legislation, as is the case in most Canadian jurisdictions for workplace harassment or violence.

Despite this diversity of subject matter and legislated rules, the best practices below are essential to the success of any workplace investigation.

Investigate Promptly

Develop an Investigation Mandate

Appoint an Open-Minded and Independent Investigator

Preserve Evidence

Interview All Witnesses

Get the Respondent’s Side of the Story

Comply with Legislation and Company Policies

Consider Interim Measures During the Investigation

Prepare Interview Questions

Have a Note-taker in Interviews

Draft a Fact-Focused Report

Ask For Help

Court and tribunal decisions

Canadian employment law is largely driven by court and tribunal decisions. The Norton Rose Fulbright employment and labour team tracks such decisions, updating our clients when impactful or instructive decisions arise. These are a few recent decisions of interest for Canadian employers.

British Columbia

Alberta

Ontario

Quebec

Labour board upholds LTD plan capped at age 65

Workplace pension and benefit plans are subject to exemptions under human rights legislation in several Canadian jurisdictions. These exemptions allow for the plans to make otherwise prohibited distinctions between employees. For example, under British Columbia’s Human Rights Code the general prohibition on discrimination in employment does not apply as it relates to marital status, physical or mental disability, sex or age to operating a “bona fide” retirement, pension or benefits plan. Whether a pension or benefit plan is “bona fide” may be disputed by employees or unions.

In 2024 an arbitrator found that a long-term disability (LTD) plan discriminated against plan members by terminating coverage and benefits at age 65. The arbitrator’s view was that the LTD plan was not “bona fide” because the employer had not exhausted funding and coverage options that might have extended benefits beyond age 65. The employer sought review by the British Columbia Labour Relations Board.

In Okanagan College, 2026 BCLRB 39 the British Columbia Labour Relations Board reversed the arbitral award and found the LTD plan was “bona fide.” The proper analysis, previously established by the Supreme Court of Canada, asks only whether a plan is “legitimate” in that it is adopted in good faith and not for the purpose of defeating human rights. There is no need to parse funding options that might have made a plan more inclusive.

In this case, the LTD plan was provided by a major benefits provider and was negotiated between the employer and the employees’ union. From the employer’s perspective the LTD plan terms were negotiated with a view to its statutory duty to balance its budget and operate within its financial bargaining mandate. This was enough to prove the LTD plan’s “bona fide” status, and it could be maintained despite capping benefits at age 65.