For years, Ontario employers have faced a frustrating dilemma: no matter how clearly a termination clause expressed the parties’ intent to comply with the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA), courts might seize on an unlikely interpretation to find a breach, voiding the clause and exposing employers to the very common law reasonable notice liability the clause was meant to control.
In Baker v. Van Dolder’s Home Team Inc. and its companion case Li v. Wayfair Canada ULC, the Court of Appeal for Ontario provided clear guidance: unlikely, technical interpretations of termination clause language should not outweigh the parties’ clear intention to comply with the ESA.
Both cases involved termination clauses stating the employer could terminate employment without cause “at any time.” Some courts, including the lower court in Baker, held that this language could permit termination contrary to statutory protections (such as protected leaves under the ESA) rendering the entire clause void.
The Court of Appeal rejected this reasoning, holding that courts must focus on the parties’ intentions and not strain to find ambiguity where none exists. The phrase “at any time” does not imply a right to terminate contrary to the ESA. An employer can reserve the right to terminate at any time while doing so lawfully. More importantly, the contracts in issue repeatedly referred to complying with the ESA at all times. Where a contract, read as a whole, shows an intention to comply with legislation a court should not interpret the contract as contracting out of that same legislation.
For a detailed summary, see our update “’Any time’ is now: Ontario Court of Appeal applies common-sense approach in upholding termination provisions.”
Baker and Li are welcome decisions for Ontario employers, providing confidence that termination clauses expressly assuring ESA compliance will not be invalidated by technical arguments about hypothetical statutory breaches. Instead, courts are to give effect to an intention to comply with the ESA where that intention is plain on the face of the employment contract. That said, employers must still exercise care: direct breaches, such as providing insufficient notice or excluding an ESA entitlement, may still void a clause. As always, consult counsel when drafting or enforcing termination provisions.