Cross-border guide
Business and human rights around the world
Whether your joint venture (JV) is entirely domestic in nature or has a cross border dimension, this guide enables you to review the answers in selected jurisdictions to 10 commonly asked questions. Use our interactive map to explore the answers for each jurisdiction.
For more information, resources and training on JVs, visit our JV hub.
CN
DE
FR
GB
HK
IT
LU
NL
PO
SA
SG
TR
UAE
Select a jurisdiction
China
China
France
France
Germany
Germany
Hong Kong
Hong Kong
Italy
Italy
Luxembourg
Luxembourg
Netherlands
Netherlands
Poland
Poland
Saudi Arabia
Saudi Arabia
Singapore
Singapore
Turkey
Turkey
United Arab Emirates
United Arab Emirates
United Kingdom
United Kingdom
Back to home
China
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
What are the common forms that joint ventures take in your jurisdiction?
There is no prescribed form for a joint venture under PRC law. The most common forms are:
Limited liability companies (which will be the main focus here)
Companies limited by shares
What laws in your jurisdiction will apply to a joint venture?
There are no laws in China which relate specifically to joint ventures
Joint ventures in China will be subject to company law, foreign investment law, foreign investment negative list and regulations applicable to regulated entities if the joint venture is to be set up in a regulated industry as well as the articles of association and provisions of the contracts entered into between the joint venture parties
Where foreign entities are considering setting up a joint venture in China, it is advisable to consider the foreign investment negative list and the laws and regulations (if any) applicable to the specific industry in which the joint venture will operate
Is there an obligation under the law of your jurisdiction to disclose the ultimate ownership of a joint venture entity?
A foreign invested joint venture company is required to file its ultimate ownership at the official website of the Administration for Market Regulation at the time when the joint venture is set up and when there is a change to the ultimate ownership
How does the law in your jurisdiction impact the governance arrangements and decision-making processes of a joint venture?
Directors of a limited company are subject to general fiduciary duties but these are not as strict and detailed as in many other jurisdictions. These include the duty to avoid conflicts of interest, to act in the best interest of the company for the benefit of its members and to exercise independent judgment, as well as take reasonable care, skill and diligence in the performance of their duties
PRC law does not include the concept of shadow directors
Generally speaking, the shareholders’ meeting (or shareholders’ general meeting) is the highest decision-making authority of a joint venture company. The board of directors may make decisions on certain matters as authorized by a shareholders’ meeting (or a shareholders’ general meeting) or as set out in the articles of association of the company. Management then operates under the supervision of the board of directors
How do the joint venture parties usually exercise control over the activities of the joint venture in your jurisdiction?
According to the PRC Company Law, certain matters are reserved to a decision of the shareholders’ meeting, for example, decisions on amendments to the articles of association, increase/reduction of the registered capital, merger/split/dissolution or change of the company form will all require approval by the shareholders representing at least two thirds of the voting rights in the company. The decision-making mechanism for all other matters may be agreed by the shareholders and set out in the articles of association of the joint venture and joint venture agreement
The board of directors will make general operational decisions and report to the shareholders’ meeting. Directors will be appointed by a shareholders’ meeting according to the nomination of shareholders which will generally be based on their level of equity interest in the joint venture
The joint venture may have one or two supervisors or a board of supervisors, which mainly serve the function of supervising the performance of duties by the directors and senior management personnel of the company
The joint venture company is likely to be run by a management team with specific delegated authority from the board of directors to make certain day to day decisions
Are there protections under the law of your jurisdiction for joint venture parties with a minority interest?
Shareholders of a limited company, in particular, minority shareholders, may assert their rights in the following ways:
Certain decisions (as mentioned above) as a matter of company law require two thirds majority shareholder approval and therefore a minority with an interest in excess of one third (representing at least one third of the voting rights) will be able to block those decisions
Shareholders representing at least 10% of the voting rights may convene and chair a shareholders’ meeting, if the board of directors (or the executive director in the absence of a board of directors) and the board of supervisors (or the supervisor(s) in the absence of a board of supervisors) fail to convene and chair a shareholders’ meeting (Article 40 and Article 101 of the PRC Company Law)
Shareholders representing at least 10% of the voting rights may propose to convene an interim shareholders’ meeting of the company (Article 39 and Article 100 of the PRC Company Law)
Shareholders representing at least 10% of the voting rights may propose to convene an interim meeting of board of directors of the company (Article 110 of the PRC Company Law)
Shareholders representing at least 10% of the voting rights may apply to the People’s court to dissolve the company if the operation of the company is facing severe difficulty and the continuing existence of the company will severely impair the interests of the shareholders and such difficulty cannot be resolved through other means
All the shareholders (including minority shareholders) have access to the accounting books of the company
Are there restrictions on contributing to or on distributing assets or cash from a joint venture entity in your jurisdiction?
It is generally speaking permissible for shareholders to contribute assets (e.g. real estate property, equipment or intellectual property rights) to a joint venture entity. However, in some regulated sectors (e.g. financial services), any capital contribution is subject to more stringent requirements (e.g. minimum amount of cash contribution)
There are restrictions under law preventing shareholders from extracting cash or assets from a company where the company is loss-making
A company may declare and pay dividends to its shareholder if it is profit-making, has made up the loss in the previous years and set aside statutory (and discretionary) reserve funds according to the applicable laws and the company’s articles of association. This generally means it is only possible to distribute a dividend once every year
Joint venture parties may choose to fund the joint venture company by way of shareholder loans to allow value to be realised by way of interest payments on the loan and to make cash extraction easier
Reductions in the registered capital of a company and distribution of proceeds require completion of registration procedures and there can in practice be delays in completing such registrations
How do joint venture parties most commonly resolve disputes in your jurisdiction?
There are no restrictions on the method of dispute resolution chosen by the parties to a joint venture
Joint venture agreements may have some matters which are resolved by expert determination (such as value on exit), some matters which are addressed via escalation (such as deadlock) and others will be referred to mediation, arbitration or the courts (although arbitration within or outside China (e.g. in Hong Kong or Singapore) is more common than courts)
Majority shareholders may wish to be able to call upon other shareholders to sell their shares under certain circumstances (for example if a minority shareholder is blocking the company’s decision making processes by causing deadlock)
Minority shareholders may wish to be able to put their equity interest on the company or other shareholders under certain circumstances and even for nominal value (for example to protect their reputation in the event of regulatory breach)
What does your jurisdiction offer parties setting up a joint venture there?
Tried and tested joint venture structures
Tax incentive scheme and other preferential treatments designed to attract investment in certain industries or locations
Gradually relaxing regulatory regime applicable to foreign investment
Access to one of the world’s largest and fastest growing markets
Are there any laws or regulations that relate specifically to foreign joint venture parties?
Foreign investment in certain sectors is subject to qualification requirements on the shareholders which are normally set out in the laws and regulations relating to a particular industry sector (e.g. financial services)
Governmental approvals may be required for investment into certain sectors, including e.g. financial services and telecoms
Foreign ownership is capped in certain sectors (e.g. automobile and airlines)
Contacts
Sun Hong
Partner
[email protected]
+86 21 6137 7020
Tom Luckock
Partner
[email protected]
+86 10 6535 3135
France
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
What are the common forms that joint ventures take in your jurisdiction?
There is no prescribed form for a joint venture under French law
However, chiefly for its flexible corporate format, the most common form is the société par actions simplifiée (SAS), which is a limited liability company
Other forms, such as contractual partnerships/unincorporated joint ventures (no legal entity) can be also used
What laws in your jurisdiction will apply to a joint venture?
There are no laws in France which relate specifically to joint ventures
Joint ventures in France will notably be subject to company, commercial and civil laws as well as tax, competition, intellectual property, data privacy, and financial regulation (amongst others) as well as the provisions of the contracts entered into between the joint venture parties
Where international entities are considering setting up a joint venture in France, it is advisable to consider the laws of their home jurisdictions as well
Is there an obligation under the law of your jurisdiction to disclose the ultimate ownership of a joint venture entity?
Any company (whether of a commercial or civil nature) in France is required to disclose to the competent Commercial Court its ultimate beneficiary(ies)
Contractual partnership are not subject to this regime
How does the law in your jurisdiction impact the governance arrangements and decision-making processes of a joint venture?
Given the flexibility of an SAS, joint venture parties are free to determine in the articles of association of the joint-venture, and also in a shareholders’ agreement, as the case may be, their governance arrangements and decision-making processes (except for few mandatory exceptions). It is worth noting that the articles of association prevail over any contradictory provisions set out in a shareholders’ agreement or other arrangements between the parties
The CEO, deputy CEO(s) and, if appointed, Directors, of a SAS are subject to fiduciary duties, including duties to avoid conflicts of interest, to act in the best interests of the company for the benefit of its shareholders and to exercise independent judgment, as well as reasonable care, skill and diligence in the performance of their duties
How do the joint venture parties usually exercise control over the activities of the joint venture in your jurisdiction?
Decisions on certain matters are reserved to a decision of the shareholders by French law, for example matters relating to a limited company’s constitution, share capital and winding-up
Additional matters may be reserved for the special approval (or veto) of a certain percentage of shareholders or directors (or specifically identified shareholders or directors)
The CEO and any deputy CEO(s) will make day-to day decisions under possible limitations of powers (such limitations not being enforceable in most cases against a third-party however); a board of directors may be established in an SAS, the directors of which will usually have been appointed by the shareholders based on their level of interest in the joint venture. The board of directors may be entrusted with a list of decisions which must be pre-approved by them before they can be implemented by the joint venture
Contractual partnerships do not have the same restrictions as to governance and decision-making. They will usually be run by an operational management team and the procedures for this will generally be set out in the relevant partnership agreement
Are there protections under the law of your jurisdiction for joint venture parties with a minority interest?
French corporate Law provides the following protections for minority shareholders (this list not exhaustive):
Depending on the corporate form of the company, certain decisions require the approval of the shareholders by a two-thirds majority (limited liability companies) or unanimously (an SAS) (e.g. amendment of the articles of association). However, the minority shareholder must use his/her/its voting rights with caution to avoid an abuse of its minority position (i.e. when by its vote the minority shareholder has adopted an attitude contrary to the company’s corporate interest by blocking a transaction that is essential for the company)
Minority shareholders may bring an action to nullify a decision contrary to the company's corporate interests which has been taken by the majority shareholders. In this case, the minority shareholders may also claim for damages
Any shareholder has the right to receive various documents regarding the management of the company, including financial information prior to annual shareholders’ meetings
Depending on the corporate form of the company, any shareholder has the right to address questions in writing to the company’s management regarding management operations
One or more shareholders, as long as he/she/it represents a certain percentage of the company’s share capital (at least 10% in a public limited liability company or 5% in joint stock companies) may request the Court to approve the appointment of an expert in charge of presenting a report on management operations
Any shareholder may act individually, on behalf of the company, against the company’s director(s) who have caused damage to the company (action ut singuli)
Shareholders representing at least 5% of the share capital of a limited liability company may require in court the appointment of an ad hoc representative to convene a general meeting of shareholders
Shareholders holding at least 5% of the share capital of a limited liability company whose share capital does not exceed EUR 750,000, may request the addition of one or several new items to the agenda of meetings that have already been convened
Are there restrictions on contributing to or on distributing assets or cash from a joint venture entity in your jurisdiction?
Different rules apply depending on the nature of the assets contributed to the company, but strictly speaking there are no restrictions under French law on contributions to a joint venture
In principle, for any contribution in kind, a statutory auditor (commissaire aux apports) must issue a report on the proposed contribution, its valuation and the applicable valuation method
There are restrictions under French law regarding the extraction of cash or assets from a company. Specific procedures must be followed depending on the nature of such extraction
There are some specific rules under French law relating to the distribution of dividends which must be decided by the general meeting of the shareholders, after having approved the annual accounts, and effectively distributed to the shareholders within 9 months of the end of the financial year. However, under certain circumstances, an advance on the payment of the dividends may be decided by a general meeting of shareholders before the approval of the company’s annual accounts
How do joint venture parties most commonly resolve disputes in your jurisdiction?
There is no specific rule on a method of dispute resolution in a joint venture
The parties may decide to bring their dispute to mediation, arbitration or to court
Generally, parties will agree dispute resolution provisions to provide for an amicable escalation process before going to arbitration or court (e.g. to the CEOs of each party)
What does your jurisdiction offer parties setting up a joint venture there?
The rules applicable to an SAS are very flexible and offer the parties a wide range of possibilities to organize their business relationship as they wish, particularly in terms of governance, without having to deal with a cumbersome legal framework
Are there any laws or regulations that relate specifically to foreign joint venture parties?
Foreign investments in certain identified sectors affecting national defence or likely to jeopardize public order and activities essential to the country's interests, are subject to a prior authorization procedure under the French Monetary and Financial Code
The following foreign investments are subject to the prior authorization of the Ministry of the Economy (but only if they fall within the sectors mentioned above);
the acquisition of control, within the meaning of Article L. 233-3 of the French Commercial Code, directly or indirectly, of a company incorporated in France or of a branch registered in France by a foreign investor (whether from a Member State of the European Union or from a third party state);
the acquisition of all or part of a branch of activity/going concern of a company incorporated in France;
the crossing, directly or indirectly, of the 25% threshold of ownership of the voting rights of a company incorporated in France. The prior authorization is however not applicable in this case where the investor is (i) an individual who is a national of a Member State of the European Union or of a State which is a party to the Agreement on the European Economic Area and which has concluded an administrative assistance agreement with France with a view to combating tax fraud and tax evasion and domiciled in one of these States, or (ii) an entity of which each of the members of the chain of control, within the meaning of II of Article R. 151-1 of the French Monetary and Financial Code, are registered in one of these same States or are nationals of and domiciled in one of these States;
the crossing, directly or indirectly, of a threshold of 10% in companies incorporated in France.. The prior authorization is however not applicable in if the investor is (i) an individual who is a national of a Member State of the European Union or of a State which is a party to the Agreement on the European Economic Area and which has concluded an administrative assistance agreement with France with a view to combating tax fraud and tax evasion and domiciled in one of these States, or (ii) an entity of which each of the members of the chain of control, within the meaning of II of Article R. 151-1 of the French Monetary and Financial Code, are registered in one of these same States or are nationals of and domiciled in one of these States
Contacts
Karine Montagut
Partner
[email protected]
+33 1 56 59 54 10
Marilou Falomi
Associate
[email protected]
+33 1 56 59 52 63
Germany
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
What are the common forms that joint ventures take in your jurisdiction?
There is no prescribed legal form for a joint venture under German law. The basic distinguishing criterion is whether or not the joint venture is (i) purely contractual or (ii) incorporated
Purely contractual joint ventures are unincorporated, i.e. there is no separate corporate vehicle for the joint venture
Incorporated joint ventures can in theory be formed in a variety of legal forms. In practice, most incorporated joint ventures under German law are in the legal form of a German limited liability company (GmbH). The latter is widely perceived as allowing most flexibility to adapt the governance structure to the specific requirements of a joint venture
What laws in your jurisdiction will apply to a joint venture?
There are no laws in Germany which specifically relate to a joint venture
Joint ventures in Germany will be subject to the German Civil Code (BGB) and, depending on individual circumstances, on other laws such as the German Commercial Code (HGB), tax, competition, intellectual property and financial regulation (amongst others)
If the joint venture partners are of non-German origin, questions of tax domiciliation should, in particular, be carefully assessed in connection with the setting up of a joint venture in Germany (so also taking into consideration the specific requirements of the respective laws and regulations applying to respective jurisdictions of origin of the joint venture partners)
Is there an obligation under the law of your jurisdiction to disclose the ultimate ownership of a joint venture entity?
Under the German Anti Money Laundering Act (GwG), legal entities under private law (juristische Personen des Privatrechts) and registered partnerships (eingetragene Personengesellschaften) have to disclose their respective ultimate beneficial owners within the so-called transparency register
The disclosure requirements for the economic beneficiaries in the transparency register also apply to incorporated joint ventures
Purely contractual joint ventures would not be subject to the above regime
How does the law in your jurisdiction impact the governance arrangements and decision-making processes of a joint venture?
The governance arrangements and decision-making processes applicable to an incorporated joint venture follow the respective statutory regime under German law of the legal form chosen by the parties for the joint venture
Depending on the specific individual requirements of the parties involved and the requirements of the nature of the business operations, the German Limited Liability Companies Act (GmbHG) is widely perceived as offering most flexibility to adapt the governance regime of the joint venture
Such flexibility allows the joint venture partners (within certain limits) to either entrust wide-ranging powers of representation to the directors (Geschäftsführer) of the joint venture, or, if preferred, to make operational decisions and measures by the directors subject to the prior consent of the shareholders
How do the joint venture parties usually exercise control over the activities of the joint venture in your jurisdiction?
Decisions on certain matters will be reserved to a decision of the shareholders under German law, for example matters relating to a limited company’s articles of association and the appointment and removal of directors
Additional matters may be reserved for the special approval (or veto) of a certain percentage of shareholders or directors (or specifically identified shareholders or directors)
The directors will make day-to day decisions and run the business of the joint venture company; the directors are appointed by the shareholders based on their respective shareholding in the joint venture
Partnerships (in contrast to a limited liability company) have a more complex governance and decision-making process and the procedures will generally be set out in the relevant partnership agreement
Are there protections under the law of your jurisdiction for joint venture parties with a minority interest?
Shareholders of a limited company, in particular, minority shareholders, may assert their rights in the following ways:
Certain decisions, as a matter of German company law, require 75% shareholder approval and therefore a minority interest in excess of 25% will be able to block those decisions (for example changing the articles of association, reducing share capital or voluntarily winding up the company)
Minority shareholders are able to contest shareholder resolutions and take other appropriate legal action on the basis of fiduciary duties (Treuepflichten) if the affairs of the company are being conducted in a manner which unfairly prejudices their legal rights. This may include a derivative action (actio pro socio) by the minority shareholder against a co-shareholder for violation of fiduciary duties vis-à-vis the minority shareholder
Shareholders representing at least 10% of the voting rights may apply to the competent court for the winding up the company (Auflösungsklage) if it becomes impossible to achieve the company’s purpose or if there are other important grounds for winding up the company, for example a serious dispute amongst conflicting groups of shareholders (s. 61 of the German Limited Liability Companies Act)
Shareholders representing at least 10% of the voting rights can require that the directors convene a general meeting of the company or, in case of the directors refusing the request or all directors having resigned from office, convene a general meeting by themselves (s. 50 of the German Limited Liability Companies Act)
Each shareholder (irrespective of its shareholding) may request from the company’s directors the receipt of information on the company’s affairs and be permitted to inspect the company’s books and records. Directors must comply with such request without undue delay (s. 51a of the German Limited Liability Companies Act)
Are there restrictions on contributing to or on distributing assets or cash from a joint venture entity in your jurisdiction?
There are no restrictions under German law with regard to contributing assets to a joint venture entity although tax and accounting advice should always be sought
There are restrictions under German law preventing shareholders from extracting cash or assets from a limited company where it could impact the rights of creditors
A limited company requires sufficient distributable reserves to be able to make distributions to shareholders out of profits, and may only distribute profits by following a prescribed procedure applicable to private companies under company law
Directors of limited companies have a fiduciary duty to retain sufficient resources to pay the company’s debts as they fall due
Joint venture parties may choose to fund the joint venture company by way of shareholder loans to allow value to be realised by way of interest payments on the loan and to make cash extraction easier
How do joint venture parties most commonly resolve disputes in your jurisdiction?
There are no restrictions on the method of dispute resolution chosen by the parties to a joint venture
Joint venture agreements may have three different methods of dispute resolution:
some matters which are resolved by expert determination (such as valuations on formation of, or exit from, the joint venture);
some matters which are addressed via internal dispute resolution (such as escalation to the joint venture parties’ top management level, or other deadlock resolution mechanisms); and
other matters will be referred to external dispute resolution, in the form of (a) mediation (rarely and still not widely accepted yet), (b) state courts (more common) or (c) German or international arbitration (most common, in particular for confidentiality reasons)
Majority shareholders may wish to be able to call upon other shareholders to sell their shares under certain circumstances (for example if a minority shareholder is blocking the company’s decision making processes by causing deadlock)
Minority shareholders may wish to be able to put their shares on the company or other shareholders (even for a nominal amount) under certain circumstances (for example to protect their reputation in the event of regulatory breach)
What does your jurisdiction offer parties setting up a joint venture there?
Tried and tested joint venture structures
Access to capital markets and funding
Freedom of contract
High level of flexibility as well as reliability, security and predictability, both in terms of the legal landscape as well as the economic environment; in particular in navigating through the COVID-19 pandemic and the future post-pandemic world (with e.g. strong German state aids, companies’ turnover fallout protections, as well as quick and continuous adaption of the German economic legislation creating a greater flexibility of corporate, insolvency and other key areas of commercial law, to allow joint venture companies and other market participants to address challenging and rapidly changing market conditions)
Are there any laws or regulations that relate specifically to foreign joint venture parties?
Under German Foreign Direct Investment Laws, the German Federal Ministry of Economic Affairs and Climate Action (BMWK) assesses investments by foreign JV parties under two different tests: (i) a sector-specific screening for acquisitions of companies active in the military sector or in IT security technology, and (ii) a cross-sector screening for all other types of companies. Depending on the set of rules, the addressee of the foreign investment screening (foreign investor or non-EU/EEA investor), the thresholds and screening procedures differ. In either case, the FDI rules apply to any direct investment as well as any indirect investment in a German company. Furthermore, acquisitions by a German acquirer, whose predominant shareholder is a foreign investor, may trigger governmental screening. Finally, an acquisition of a German company by way of an asset deal may also be subject to FDI controls
Sector-specific investment control - The sector-specific FDI screening applies to companies active for example in the production of weapons, military equipment and IT security products. An investment in these specific sectors may become subject to governmental screening if a foreign investor acquires 10% or more of the voting rights of a target company operating in this sector;
Cross-sector investment control: Today, the BMWK screens FDI in many different civil sectors, such as energy, information technology and telecommunications, government communication, transport and traffic, essential pharmaceutical and specific medical products, protective equipment, water supply, food, finance and insurance, software for critical infrastructure, cloud-computing services, artificial intelligence, data-networks, specific raw materials, nuclear technology, satellites, autonomous driving, semiconductors, quantum technologies and media. As for sector-specific examinations, filings are mandatory for acquisitions in these sectors if certain materiality thresholds – 10%, 20% and 25% - are met, and acquisitions are subject to a stand-still obligation pending such regulatory assessments
Under German Merger Control Laws, JVs with foreign parent companies are caught if the JV has an ‘appreciable effect’ within the territory of Germany and filing thresholds (turnover or transaction value) are met. Subject to review on a case-by-case basis, this can be the case even if neither the JV nor the parents have subsidiaries or other assets within Germany, but the parents meet the set of filing thresholds and have significant activities relating to the JV, e.g. on up-or downstream markets. In that case a JV with a foreign investor may require clearance from the German Federal Cartel Office (BkartA), and, as under the German FDI regime, acquisitions are subject to a stand-still obligation pending such regulatory assessments
Contacts
Karsten Kuehnle
Partner
[email protected]
+49 69 505096 304
Heiko Bertelmann
Partner
[email protected]
+49 40 970799 126
Frank Henkel
Partner
[email protected]
+49 89 212148 456
Hong Kong
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
What are the common forms that joint ventures take in your jurisdiction?
There is no prescribed form for a joint venture under Hong Kong law. The most common forms are:
Private company limited by shares (in addition to Hong Kong incorporated companies, the use of companies incorporated in the British Virgin Islands, Bermuda and the Cayman Islands is very common)
Contractual/unincorporated joint venture (with no separate corporate vehicle)
What laws in your jurisdiction will apply to a joint venture?
There are no laws in Hong Kong which relate specifically to joint ventures
Joint ventures in Hong Kong will be subject to company law, common law, and may be subject to partnership law, as well as tax, competition, intellectual property and financial regulation (amongst others) as well as the provisions of the contracts entered into between the joint venture parties
Where international entities are considering setting up a joint venture in Hong Kong, it is advisable to consider the laws of their home jurisdictions as well
Is there an obligation under the law of your jurisdiction to disclose the ultimate ownership of a joint venture entity?
Limited companies (incorporated in Hong Kong) are required to keep and maintain a register of persons with significant control (although the register is not generally available for public inspection)
Contractual joint ventures would not be subject to the same regime
How does the law in your jurisdiction impact the governance arrangements and decision-making processes of a joint venture?
Directors of a limited company are subject to fiduciary duties, including the duties to avoid conflicts of interest, to act in the best interests of the company for the benefit of its members and to exercise independent judgment, as well as reasonable care, skill and diligence in the performance of their duties
Hong Kong law includes the concept of shadow directors, which may include a shareholder of the company, if the directors of the joint venture are accustomed to act in accordance with the instructions of that shareholder (or other person)
If a joint venture company is party to the joint venture agreement, the joint venture company should not agree to any governance arrangements or decision making processes that would fetter the company’s statutory powers
How do the joint venture parties usually exercise control over the activities of the joint venture in your jurisdiction?
Decisions on certain matters will be reserved to a decision of the shareholders under law, for example matters relating to a limited company’s constitution and share capital
Additional matters may be reserved for the special approval (or veto) of a certain percentage of shareholders or directors (or specifically identified shareholders or directors)
Board of directors will make day-to day decisions; the directors will usually have been appointed by the shareholders based on the level of interest in the joint venture
Joint venture company is likely to be run by a management team with specific delegated authority from the Board to make certain decisions
Are there protections under the law of your jurisdiction for joint venture parties with a minority interest?
Shareholders of a limited company, in particular, minority shareholders, may assert their rights in the following ways:
Certain decisions as a matter of company law require 75% shareholder approval and therefore a minority interest in excess of 25% will be able to block those decisions (for example changing the articles of association, reducing share capital or voluntarily winding up the company)
Shareholders are able to present an unfair prejudice petition if the affairs of the company are being conducted in a manner which unfairly prejudices their interests (s. 724 of the Companies Ordinance, Cap.622)
A minority shareholder may bring a derivative action on behalf of the company against a director who has acted improperly in specific ways (s. 732 of the Companies Ordinance, Cap.622)
A minority shareholder may apply to wind up a company where it is just an equitable to do so, even if the company is solvent (s. 177(1)(f) of the Companies (Winding Up and Miscellaneous Provisions) Ordinance, Cap. 32)
Shareholders representing at least 5% of the voting rights can require that the directors convene a general meeting of the company (s. 566 of the Companies Ordinance, Cap.622)
Shareholders representing at least 2.5% of the voting rights can require that the company circulates a statement in relation to matters to be dealt with at a general meeting (s. 580 of the Companies Ordinance, Cap.622) or can require a resolution is put to a vote at an annual general meeting (s. 615 of the Companies Ordinance, Cap.622)
Are there restrictions on contributing to or on distributing assets or cash from a joint venture entity in your jurisdiction?
There are no restrictions under law on contributing assets to a joint venture entity although tax and accounting advice should always be sought
There are restrictions under law preventing shareholders from extracting cash or assets from a limited company where it could impact the rights of creditors. A limited company requires sufficient distributable reserves to be able to make distributions to shareholders out of profits, and may only distribute capital by following a prescribed procedure under company law
Directors of limited companies have a fiduciary duty to retain sufficient resources to pay the company’s debts as they fall due
Joint venture parties may choose to fund the joint venture company by way of shareholder loans to allow value to be realised by way of interest payments on the loan and to make cash extraction easier
How do joint venture parties most commonly resolve disputes in your jurisdiction?
There are no restrictions on the method of dispute resolution chosen by the parties to a joint venture
Joint venture agreements may have some matters which are resolved by expert determination (such as value on exit), some matters which are addressed via escalation (such as deadlock) and others will be referred to mediation, arbitration or the courts
Majority shareholders may wish to be able to call upon other shareholders to sell their shares under certain circumstances (for example if a minority shareholder is blocking the company’s decision making processes by causing deadlock)
Minority shareholders may wish to be able to put their shares on the company or other shareholders under certain circumstances and even for nominal value (for example to protect their reputation in the event of regulatory breach)
What does your jurisdiction offer parties setting up a joint venture there?
Tried and tested joint venture structures
Low-tax regime designed to attract investment
Access to capital markets and funding
Freedom of contract
Are there any laws or regulations that relate specifically to foreign joint venture parties?
Foreign investment is not treated differently from domestic investment
Certain sectors require governmental approvals for investment above certain levels, including financial services and telecoms
Contacts
Charles Bremner
Partner
[email protected]
+852 64603391
Italy
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
What are the common forms that joint ventures take in your jurisdiction?
There is no prescribed form for a joint venture under Italian law. The most common forms are:
Società per azioni or S.p.A. (joint stock company)
Società a responsabilità limitata or S.r.l. (limited liability company)
Contractual/unincorporated joint venture (with no separate corporate vehicle)
What laws in your jurisdiction will apply to a joint venture?
There are no laws in Italy which relate specifically to joint ventures
Joint ventures in Italy will be subject to company law, as well as tax, competition, intellectual property and financial regulation (amongst others) as well as the provisions of the contracts entered into between the joint venture parties
Where international entities are considering setting up a joint venture in Italy, it is advisable to consider the laws of their home jurisdictions as well
Is there an obligation under the law of your jurisdiction to disclose the ultimate ownership of a joint venture entity?
There is no general obligation to disclose the ultimate ownership of a joint venture entity
Information about direct holdings is available through the company registry
Stricter disclosure requirements apply in certain regulated sectors
Compliance with anti-money-laundering regulation may require the disclosure of ultimate parents to certain parties (e.g. the notary involved in the incorporation of the joint venture entity)
How does the law in your jurisdiction impact the governance arrangements and decision-making processes of a joint venture?
While there is no general obligation to disclose the ultimate ownership of a joint venture entity,
specific disclosure requirements in respect of the ultimate beneficial owners (UBO) of Italian companies
have been recently introduced. However, the application of such disclosure obligation is currently
suspended (we expect that the suspension will not be lifted before September 2024)
Investors in a joint venture company have much flexibility to make governance arrangements through a shareholders’ agreement and the company’s articles of association subject to compliance with certain mandatory provisions, especially in respect of directors’ duties and the allocation of competence between the shareholders and the directors
Directors have a duty to act with reasonable care, skill and diligence in the performance of their duties and must disclose conflicts of interest
Shareholders and directors’ resolutions may generally be adopted through a written decision in a limited liability company (with a few exception), while they require a meeting (which may be via video or
telephone call) in a joint stock company
How do the joint venture parties usually exercise control over the activities of the joint venture in your jurisdiction?
Decisions on certain matters may be reserved for the approval (or veto) of a certain percentage of shareholders or directors
The members of the board of directors are usually appointed by the shareholders based on the level of interest in the joint venture
Resolutions on relevant matters are usually reserved at board level, while day to day decisions are delegated to executive directors and managers
Are there protections under the law of your jurisdiction for joint venture parties with a minority interest?
Protections afforded to minority shareholders under Italian law include the following:
Shareholders in a limited liability company that are not involved in the management of the company have the right to request information about the business operations of the company and to access corporate books and relevant documentation
A shareholder of a joint stock company may inspect the shareholders’ ledger and the minutes of the
shareholders’ meeting and may request a copy of the same at its expenses
Certain decisions by the shareholders of a joint stock company, as a matter of company law, require the approval of a qualified majority to be passed, and therefore a certain minority interest will be able to block those decisions (for example amendments to the articles of association, capital increases, mergers)
Shareholders representing at least 1/3 of the share capital of a limited liability company or 10% of the share capital in a joint stock company can require that the directors convene a shareholders’ meeting
Any shareholder of a limited liability company and shareholders representing at least 5% of the share capital in a joint stock company may challenge a shareholders’ resolution
Any shareholder of a limited liability company and shareholders representing at least 20% of the share capital in a joint stock company may bring a derivative action on behalf of the company against the directors
Any shareholder of a limited liability company and shareholders representing at least 10% of the share capital in a joint stock company can initiate court proceedings leading to the replacement of the directors of the company on the grounds of serious wrongdoings
Certain resolutions (e.g. certain amendments to the articles of association) may trigger the right of the shareholders that do not vote for the resolution to withdraw from the company and liquidate their shares
Are there restrictions on contributing to or on distributing assets or cash from a joint venture entity in your jurisdiction?
There are no general restrictions on contributing assets to a joint venture entity although tax, accounting and valuation advice should always be sought
Contributions in kind require an expert appraisal, subject to certain exceptions
A company can make distributions to shareholders to the extent that it has sufficient profits and distributable reserves
Joint venture parties may choose to fund the joint venture company by way of shareholder loans to allow value to be realised by way of interest payments on the loan
Shareholder loans to a limited liability company are subordinated to other company’s debts under certain circumstances
How do joint venture parties most commonly resolve disputes in your jurisdiction?
There are no general restrictions on the method of dispute resolution chosen by the parties to a joint venture
Joint venture agreements may have some matters which are resolved by expert determination (such as value on exit), some matters which are addressed via escalation (such as deadlock) and others which are to be referred to arbitration or the court
Majority shareholders may wish to be able to call upon other shareholders to sell their shares under certain circumstances (for example in case of a deadlock)
Minority shareholders may wish to be able to put their shares on other shareholders under certain circumstances (for example in case of a deadlock).
What does your jurisdiction offer parties setting up a joint venture there?
Tried and tested joint venture structures
Access to capital markets and funding
Freedom of contract
Italian company law as a flexible choice to implement international best practices in the joint venture documentation
Are there any laws or regulations that relate specifically to foreign joint venture parties?
As a general rule, foreign investment is not treated differently from domestic investment under current legislation
However, foreign investment in companies and assets in certain strategic sectors is subject to government screening
Screening of foreign direct investments must comply with the framework established by EU Regulation 2019/452
Contacts
Claudio Di Falco
Partner
[email protected]
+39 335 7326927
Arturo Sferruzza
Partner
[email protected]
+ 39 335 841 6743
Luxembourg
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
What are the common forms that joint ventures take in your jurisdiction?
There is no prescribed form for a joint venture under Luxembourg law. The most common forms are:
Private limited liability company (société à responsabilité limitée) (SARL)
Public limited liability company (société anonyme) (SA)
What laws in your jurisdiction will apply to a joint venture?
There are no laws in Luxembourg which relate specifically to joint ventures
Joint ventures in Luxembourg will, amongst other things, be subject to company law, civil law, as well as tax, competition, intellectual property and financial regulation laws as well as the provisions of the contracts entered into between the joint venture parties
Where international entities are considering setting up a joint venture in Luxembourg, it is advisable to consider the laws of their home jurisdictions as well
Is there an obligation under the law of your jurisdiction to disclose the ultimate ownership of a joint venture entity?
The identity of shareholders of SARLs, their respective professional or personal address and the number of shares they hold in the SARL, must be filed with and published in the Luxembourg Trade and Companies Register. This requirement does not apply to SAs
Any Luxembourg entity registered with the Luxembourg Trade and Companies Register (including SAs and SARLs) is required to file certain identifying information regarding each of its beneficial owner(s) with the Luxembourg Register of Beneficial Owners
How does the law in your jurisdiction impact the governance arrangements and decision-making processes of a joint venture?
Directors of SAs and managers of SARLs are subject to fiduciary duties, including the duty to act with reasonable care, loyalty, skill and diligence, in good faith and in the company’s corporate interest, and must exercise independent judgment and comply with the company’s articles of association and Luxembourg laws and regulations
Luxembourg law includes the concept of shadow directors/managers (which could be a shareholder of the company), who can become subject to some of the liability rules applicable to duly appointed directors/managers if they independently engage in active acts of management
If a joint venture company is party to the joint venture agreement, the joint venture company should not agree to any governance arrangements or decision-making processes that would fetter the directors’/managers’ obligation to act in the joint venture company’s corporate interest
How do the joint venture parties usually exercise control over the activities of the joint venture in your jurisdiction?
Decisions on certain matters will be reserved to a decision of the shareholders under Luxembourg law, for example the approval of the company’s annual accounts, the appointment of the directors/managers and the amendment of the company’s articles of association
Additional matters may be reserved for the special approval (or veto) of a certain percentage of shareholders or directors/managers (or specifically identified shareholders or directors/managers)
The board of directors/managers is tasked with carrying out the management and supervision of the company
The board may delegate authority for certain specific decisions, as well as broader powers (e.g. the day-to-day management), to directors/managers and other officers
Directors/managers are usually appointed by the shareholders based on their equity stake in the joint venture in accordance with contractual provisions agreed between the joint venture parties
Are there protections under the law of your jurisdiction for joint venture parties with a minority interest?
Some of the protections afforded to shareholders under Luxembourg law include the following:
Certain decisions require the approval of shareholders representing a qualified majority, and therefore the holder(s) of a certain minority interest will be able to block those decisions (for example changing the articles of association, change of nationality, increasing/reducing the share capital or voluntarily winding up the company), although in exceptional cases such blocking could amount to an abuse of the powers of the minority
Decisions to increase the shareholders’ commitments to the company (e.g change of the legal form of the company from limited to unlimited liability of shareholders) require unanimous vote from the shareholders, therefore protecting minority interests
The general principle of equality of shareholders under Luxembourg law also constitutes a safeguard for minority interests
A minority shareholder may be able to claim the annulment of a corporate decision taken by a majority of shareholders in certain cases, e.g. where the decision was taken against the company’s corporate interest and for the sole purpose of favouring the majority shareholders to the detriment of the minority shareholders (damages may also be claimed by the minority shareholders)
A minority shareholder representing at least 10% of the voting rights in SAs may bring a derivative action on behalf of the company against a director who has acted improperly in specific ways
Any shareholder may apply to a court to request that a company be wound up for “just cause”
Any shareholder has the right to access certain financial information prior to annual shareholder meetings
Any shareholder has the right to address questions to the company’s management during annual and other shareholders meetings (subject to certain exceptions)
One or several minority shareholders representing at least 10% of the share capital or 10% of the voting rights of the shares issued by an SA or an SARL may address questions in writing to the company’s management regarding one or several acts of management of the company and entities controlled by it
Shareholders representing at least 10% of the share capital in SAs may require the board of directors to convene a general meeting of shareholders and may request the addition of one or several new items to the agenda of meetings that have already been convened
Are there restrictions on contributing to or on distributing assets or cash from a joint venture entity in your jurisdiction?
There are no restrictions under Luxembourg law regarding contributing assets to a joint venture entity although tax, accounting and valuation advice should always be sought
In SAs, contributions in kind require the issuance of an auditor’s report on the proposed contribution, valuation and valuation methods
There are restrictions under Luxembourg law preventing shareholders from extracting cash or assets from SAs and SARLs and a specific legal procedure must be followed depending on the legal structure of that extraction
The principal equity-based methods for distributing cash to shareholders include:
an annual or extraordinary dividend decided by a general meeting of shareholders
an interim dividend decided by the board of directors/managers (this requires an authorisation in the articles of association and may require the involvement of an auditor)
a repayment of share premium/account 115 premium to the shareholders of the company
a buy-back and/or cancellation of shares
Directors/managers have a fiduciary duty to retain sufficient resources to pay the company’s debts as they fall due
Joint venture parties may choose to fund the joint venture company by way of shareholder loans to allow value to be realised by way of interest payments on the loan and to make cash extraction easier
How do joint venture parties most commonly resolve disputes in your jurisdiction?
There are no specific restrictions on the method of dispute resolution chosen by the parties to a joint venture
Joint venture agreements may have some matters which are resolved by expert determination (such as value on exit), some matters which are addressed via escalation (such as deadlock) and others can be referred to mediation, arbitration or the courts
In cases of urgency (for example in order to prevent a majority abuse or in cases of deadlock), shareholders may request a court to appoint an interim judicial administrator of the company
Majority shareholders may wish to be able to call upon other shareholders to sell their shares under certain circumstances (for example if a minority shareholder is blocking the company’s decision-making processes by causing deadlock)
Minority shareholders may wish to be able to put their shares on the company or other shareholders (even for a nominal amount) under certain circumstances (for example to protect their reputation in the event of regulatory breach)
What does your jurisdiction offer parties setting up a joint venture there?
Tried and tested joint venture structures
Access to capital markets and funding
Freedom of contract
Luxembourg law as a flexible and neutral choice for international investors from different jurisdictions
Are there any laws or regulations that relate specifically to foreign joint venture parties?
Through the law of 14 July 2023, Luxembourg has introduced effective as of 1 September 2023 a new foreign direct investment regime with a mandatory notification requirement for certain investments made in Luxembourg entities carrying out “critical activities” in a broad range of sectors listed in the law. Such sectors include, without limitation, investments made in the energy, water, health, cybersecurity, defence, aerospace or media sectors. The acquisition of a Luxembourg entity carrying out research or activities connected to “critical activities” may also give rise to the mandatory notification requirement.
Under this new regime, Investors outside the European Economic Area shall notify the Luxembourg Ministry of the Economy any direct or indirect investments made in a Luxembourg entity carrying out ‘critical activities” in Luxembourg. Under certain conditions, the Ministry of the Economy may approve the investment, approve it subject to certain requirements or deny it.
Contacts
Torsten Sauer
Partner
[email protected]
+352 28 57 39 255
Netherlands
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
What are the common forms that joint ventures take in your jurisdiction?
There is no prescribed form for a joint venture under Dutch law
The most common forms are:
a private company with limited liability (besloten venootschap met beperkte aansprakelijkheid or B.V.) (being the most commonly used form); and
a contractual partnership (maatschap)
Joint ventures using the legal form of a cooperative (coöperatief) are also seen, but are much less common
What laws in your jurisdiction will apply to a joint venture?
Joint ventures in the Netherlands will be subject to company law or partnership law (depending on the form of the joint venture vehicle), contract law as well as tax, competition, intellectual property and financial regulation (amongst others). There is no specific legislation relating to joint ventures alone
Where international entities are considering setting up a joint venture in the Netherlands, it is advisable to consider the laws of their home jurisdictions as well, for example, an arrangement that is not characterised as a partnership in the Netherlands may be viewed as a partnership elsewhere
Is there an obligation under the law of your jurisdiction to disclose the ultimate ownership of a joint venture entity?
Yes, on 7 July 2020, the Act implementing registration of ultimate beneficial owners (UBO) of companies and other legal entities (Implementation Act) was published. The Act applies to all legal entities, except to listed entities and their full subsidiaries, and obliges these legal entities to submit information regarding their UBO’s to the ‘UBO-register’ of the Dutch Chamber of Commerce
non-listed B.V.s are required to submit information regarding their ultimate beneficial owners (UBO) to the ‘UBO-register’ of the Dutch Chamber of Commerce
UBO's are the natural persons that indirectly or directly hold more than 25% of the shares in a B.V.. If a B.V. does not have a UBO in accordance with the requirements set out in the preceding sentence, such B.V. must register a ‘pseudo-UBO’. These are usually the highest office holders of the entity (e.g. the managing directors)
How does the law in your jurisdiction impact the governance arrangements and decision-making processes of a joint venture?
Directors are responsible for the day-to-day management and policymaking of a B.V. and, in doing so, directors of B.V.s have a statutory duty to act in accordance with the corporate interests of the B.V., taking into account the interests of all stakeholders (such as shareholders, employees, creditors, etc.). In joint venture situations, when determining the joint venture’s corporate interests particular emphasis is given to the continuing cooperation between the joint venture partners
In the event that a director of a B.V. has a conflict of interest, that director may not take part in the deliberation and decision-making process of the management board of the B.V.. A qualitative conflict of interest in itself (e.g. the fact that the director is an employee of one of the shareholders) is not sufficient for a conflict of interest to exist under Dutch law, rather the director must not have a personal conflict of interest
In terms of potential liability relevant for the joint venture partners, Dutch law stipulates that actual policymakers within a B.V. (which can be the joint venture partners themselves) can be held liable in addition to statutory directors in bankruptcy scenarios
How do the joint venture parties usually exercise control over the activities of the joint venture in your jurisdiction?
Decisions on certain matters are within the authority of the shareholders as a matter of law, for example matters relating to amendment of the B.V.’s articles of association and winding up the B.V. In joint ventures, shareholders usually agree to different majority requirements with regard to such decisions
In addition, matters that are within the authority of the management board may be made subject to shareholder approval or an increased majority within the board (or may be made subject to the approval of specifically identified shareholders or managing directors)
The managing directors will usually have been appointed by the shareholders based on the level of shareholding interest in the joint venture. Specific shareholder classes may be introduced pursuant to which the holders of a particular class may appoint, for example, a particular number of directors
The joint venture company is likely to be run by the management board team with specific managing directors having specific tasks and duties (e.g. CEO, CFO, COO etc.); the authority to represent the joint venture company is usually with two (or more) managing directors acting jointly (each being an appointee of a different shareholder) and/or delegated to proxyholders
Joint venture companies sometimes have a two tier board structure under which the management board will be supervised by a supervisory board, which may also have veto rights in respect of certain decisions of the management board (in addition to the shareholders in general meeting)
Are there protections under the law of your jurisdiction for joint venture parties with a minority interest?
Shareholders of a B.V., in particular, minority shareholders, may assert their rights in the following ways:
Usually the articles of association prescribe that for certain decisions of the general meeting of shareholders, an increased majority (e.g. 2/3) is required and therefore a minority interest will be able to block those decisions (for example the amendment of the articles of association and the winding up of the joint venture vehicle). However, this is not a legal requirement as, by default, most decisions of the general meeting of shareholder can be taken by simple majority
Each shareholder can attend, speak and vote at a general meeting
Each shareholder holding at least 1% of the entire issued and outstanding share capital of a B.V. can be authorised by the court to convene a general meeting when such a meeting is due and the competent corporate body (management board / supervisory board) has failed to do so. A joint venture agreement will often contain a right for a joint venture partner to convene such a meeting
Each shareholder has a pre-emptive right upon issuance of the shares proportional to its shareholding, save with regard to certain specified share issuances and unless provided for otherwise by the articles of association or limited by a general meeting
(Minority) shareholders may initiate court proceedings to assert certain rights vis-à-vis other (majority) shareholders (see question 8 below)
Are there restrictions on contributing to or on distributing assets or cash from a joint venture entity in your jurisdiction?
There are no legal restrictions on contributing assets or cash to a joint venture entity although tax and accounting advice should always be sought
There are restrictions under law preventing shareholders of a B.V. from making distributions from capital:
If a B.V. has any mandatory legal reserves (i.e., which it is required to maintain pursuant to the law or its articles of association) it may only make distributions to the extent the amount of its equity capital exceeds the amount of the mandatory reserves. If a B.V. does not have mandatory legal reserves, it is free to distribute from its capital even if this would lead to a negative capital, provided that any distribution is only permitted if, following such distribution, the B.V. will be able to continue to pay its due debts following the distribution; and
When a resolution for a distribution is adopted, the distribution is subsequently only permitted if the management board has approved the distribution. The management board may only withhold its approval if it knows or reasonably foresees that the B.V. cannot pay debts which are due and payable following the distribution
Joint venture parties may choose to fund the joint venture company by way of shareholder loans to allow value to be realised by way of interest payments on the loan and to make cash extraction easier
How do joint venture parties most commonly resolve disputes in your jurisdiction?
There are, in principle, no restrictions on the method of dispute resolution which may be chosen by the parties to a joint venture
Joint venture agreements may have some matters which are resolved by expert determination (such as value on exit), some matters which are addressed via escalation (such as deadlock) and others will be referred to mediation, arbitration or the courts
Since 1 January 2019, the Dutch Code for Civil Procedure allows civil disputes, including disputes between joint venture partners, to be brought before the Netherlands Commercial Court in Amsterdam (the NCC). The NCC is a division of the district court of Amsterdam specialising in commercial disputes and allows for proceeding to be conducted in English instead of Dutch
In addition to normal court proceedings (whether or not in accordance with the NCC rules), a minority shareholder (in case of a company with a total share capital of EUR 22.5m or more, a shareholder holding at least 1% of the entire issued shares and in case of a company with a total share capital of EUR 22.5m or less at least 10% of the entire issued shares) can request the Enterprise Division (Ondernemingskamer) of the Amsterdam Court of Appeal to institute an investigation (enquête) into the management and general course of the business of the company and request the court to put in place certain provisional arrangements. An arbitration clause does not preclude the Enterprise Division’s competence
Outside of a request to the Enterprise Division for a provisional measure in respect of a B.V.’s management and the general course of business and in case no arbitration clause or other alternative dispute resolution provision is agreed, the following corporate dispute resolution (geschillenregeling) actions are available::
minority shareholders holding at least 1/3 of the entire issued share capital of the company may initiate court proceedings against any shareholder to demand the transfer of that other shareholder’s shares, if such other shareholder, by using its voting rights, prejudices the interest of the company to such an extent that the continuation of its shareholding cannot reasonably be tolerated; and
each shareholder can demand in court that its shares are acquired by another shareholder, if the other shareholder prejudices the interest of that shareholder to such an extent that the continuation of its shareholding cannot reasonably be expected (however this is a high threshold to be successful). Effective January 1, 2025, the recently adopted act "Wetsvoorstel aanpassing geschillenregeling en verduidelijking ontvankelijkheidseisen enquêteprocedure (Wagevoe)”, enhances the corporate dispute resolution by broadening expulsion grounds to include misbehaviour of parties outside shareholder capacity (e.g. if the party is not only a shareholder, but also a director). In addition, the circle of parties that are authorized to initiate investigation procedures is expanded to include certain categories of depositary receipt holders.
What does your jurisdiction offer parties setting up a joint venture there?
Tried and tested joint venture structures
Freedom of contract
Specialist court proceedings for corporate governance conflicts
The Dutch tax system is very well suited to facilitate international JVs. Examples of favourable tax provisions in the Netherlands are:
The Dutch corporate income tax rate is 25.8% (19% for taxable profits under EUR 200,000). However, the Dutch tax regime provides for a full participation exemption in respect of dividend income and capital gains on the sale of shares. As a result any dividends received from and capital gains realised on the sale of qualifying shareholdings in subsidiaries worldwide by the Dutch JV vehicle are fully tax exempt
The Netherlands is party to some 100 tax treaties, which generally provide for a tax efficient repatriation (reduced or no foreign withholding taxes) of funds from subsidiary companies up to the Dutch JV vehicle and onwards to the JV partners
Are there any laws or regulations that relate specifically to foreign joint venture parties?
There is no specific legislation relating to joint ventures alone
In general, foreign investment is not treated differently from domestic investment under current legislation
On 1 March 2020 the Telecommunications Sector (Undesirable Control) Act (Wet ongewenste zeggenschap telecommunicatie) came into force. Pursuant to this Act, a party that intends to acquire a controlling interest in a telecommunications entity must notify the competent minister if such control will lead to relevant influence within the telecommunications sector
From 11 October 2020, EU Regulation 2019/452 established a framework for screening foreign direct investments (FDI) into the European Union on the grounds of security and public order considerations. The regulation does not make it mandatory for EU member states to adopt FDI control regimes, however those that do so must comply with the requirements of the Regulation, in particular as to transparency and non-discrimination. The bill for the Dutch implementation act related to this FDI regulation is expected to be adopted and come into force in November 2020. The bill, however, only regulates those elements that are necessary to guarantee the effective operation of the FDI regulation and to ensure that the Netherlands complies with its obligations in relation thereto. The bill does not introduce any new Dutch investment tests or screening mechanisms (nor does it change anything in existing screening mechanisms)
On 1 June 2023, the Investments, Mergers and Acquisitions Security Screening Act (Wet veiligheidstoets investeringen, fusies en overnames, (Vifo)) came into force. The Vifo act introduces a mandatory and suspensory FDI screening framework for investments, mergers and acquisitions in target companies active in vital processes and companies active in sensitive technologies that might pose a threat to national security. The act presents a notification obligation for these vital or sensitive companies and covers investment activities by both EU and non-EU investors
Contacts
Saskia Blokland
Partner
[email protected]
+31 20 462 9412
Heimon Smits
Partner
[email protected]
+31 20 462 9415
Jasper Geerdes
Associate
[email protected]
+31 20 462 9362
Poland
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
What are the common forms that joint ventures take in your jurisdiction?
There is no prescribed form for a joint venture under Polish law
For its flexible corporate format, the most common form of joint venture entity is spółka z ograniczoną odpowiedzialnością (SPZOO), which is a limited liability company
Other forms, such as joint-stock companies (SA), partnerships and/or unincorporated joint ventures (no legal entity) can also be used
What laws in your jurisdiction will apply to a joint venture?
There are no laws in Poland which relate specifically to joint ventures
Joint ventures in Poland are subject to company, commercial and civil laws as well as tax, competition, intellectual property, data privacy, and financial regulation (amongst others) as well as the provisions of the contracts entered into between the joint venture parties
Where international entities are considering setting up a joint venture in Poland, it is advisable to consider the laws of their home jurisdictions as well
Is there an obligation under the law of your jurisdiction to disclose the ultimate ownership of a joint venture entity?
The identity of direct shareholders of a SPZOO, their address and the number of shares they hold in the SPZOO must be filed with the local registry court of the SPZOO and is available to the public in the archives of such court. In addition, the identity of direct shareholders of an SPZOO holding more than 10% of all shares (and the number of shares they hold in the SPZOO) is available online to the public on the website of the registry court
For SAs, the above requirement applies only to the sole shareholder of the SAs (so in practice is not relevant for joint ventures)
In addition, any Polish company (including SAs and SPZOOs) is required to file certain identifying information regarding its beneficial owner(s) with the Polish Register of Beneficial Owners, such information being available online to the public
How does the law in your jurisdiction impact the governance arrangements and decision-making processes of a joint venture?
Parties to a joint venture in the form of an SPZOO have significant flexibility to determine their governance arrangements and decision-making processes in the articles of association of the joint-venture (subject to certain mandatory exceptions)
Directors of SPZOOs are subject to fiduciary duties, including the duty to act with reasonable care, loyalty, skill and diligence, in good faith and in the company’s corporate interest, and must exercise independent judgment and comply with the company’s articles of association and Polish law
Polish law enables a shareholder of the company to be subject to some of the liability rules applicable to directors/managers if such shareholder independently engages in active acts of management
How do the joint venture parties usually exercise control over the activities of the joint venture in your jurisdiction?
Decisions on certain matters are reserved under Polish law to a decision of the shareholders, for example the approval of the company’s annual accounts, the appointment of the directors/managers, the amendment of the company’s articles of association or its share capital, and/or the winding-up of the company
Additional matters may be reserved for the special approval (or veto) of a certain percentage of shareholders or directors (or specifically identified shareholders or directors)
Mandatorily for SAs and optionally for SPZOOs ( where such option is set out in the articles of association), the shareholders appoint a supervisory board tasked with the supervision of the company and comprising at least three members
The management board / directors are tasked with carrying out the management of the company
The management board may delegate authority for certain specific decisions, as well as broader powers (e.g. day-to-day management matters), to directors and other officers
Directors are usually appointed by the shareholders (or by the supervisory board, if one has been appointed) based on their equity stake in the joint venture and in accordance with contractual provisions agreed between the joint venture parties
Are there protections under the law of your jurisdiction for joint venture parties with a minority interest?
Polish corporate law provides the following protections for minority shareholders (this list not being exhaustive):
Certain decisions require the approval of shareholders representing a qualified majority, and therefore minority shareholders with the requisite shareholding are able to block those decisions (for example changing the articles of association, increasing/reducing the share capital or voluntarily winding up the company)
Any shareholder may be able to claim the annulment of a shareholder resolution taken by a majority of shareholders in certain cases, e.g. where the decision was taken against the company’s corporate interest, in breach of the law and/or for the sole purpose of favouring the majority shareholders to the detriment of the minority shareholders (damages may also be claimed by the minority shareholder)
Any shareholder may act individually, on behalf of the company, against the company’s director(s) who have caused damage to the company
Any shareholder in a SPZOO has the right to access books and records of the company (subject to certain exceptions)
Shareholders representing at least 10% of the share capital of the SPZOO may require the management board to convene a general meeting of shareholders and may request the addition of one or several new items to the agenda of meetings that have already been convened
Are there restrictions on contributing to or on distributing assets or cash from a joint venture entity in your jurisdiction?
There are no restrictions under Polish law regarding the contribution of assets to a joint venture entity although obtaining tax, accounting and valuation advice should be considered
In SAs, contributions in kind require the issue of an auditor’s report on the proposed contribution and its valuation
The net profit generated by the company (less certain mandatory reserves) is distributable to shareholders in the form of: (i) an annual dividend decided by the annual meeting of shareholders; (ii) an interim dividend decided by the management board ( this also requires an authorisation in the articles of association and certain ratios being achieved) and/or (iii) redemption of shares
To the extent exceeding the distributable net profit, there are restrictions under Polish law preventing shareholders from extracting cash or assets from companies and a specific legal procedure must be followed, including a public announcement and the right for the company’s creditors to object to the extraction (or request collateral from the company)
Directors have a fiduciary duty to retain sufficient resources to pay the company’s debts as they fall due
As an alternative to typical registered capital contributions, joint venture parties may choose to fund the joint venture company by way of: (i) shareholder loans to allow value to be realised by way of interest payments on the loan and to make cash extraction easier (with tax advice recommended to identify potential thin-capitalization limitations) and/or (ii) for SPZOOs only – additional pro rata contributions/payments to the reserve capital (dopłaty), which bear no interest and can be returned (also pro rata and subject to certain exceptions) to the shareholders who contributed such payments
How do joint venture parties most commonly resolve disputes in your jurisdiction?
There is no specific rule on the method of dispute resolution in a joint venture
The parties may decide to bring their dispute to mediation, arbitration or to court
Deadlocks (if regulated in the shareholders’ agreement) are usually addressed via escalation to the chief officers of the shareholders and/or to a third party mediator. Infrequently, deadlock resolution mechanisms are used (such as internal auction or call/put options exercisable in case of deadlock)
What does your jurisdiction offer parties setting up a joint venture there?
Tried and tested joint venture structures
Freedom of contract
The rules applicable to SPZOOs are flexible and offer the parties a wide range of possibilities to organize their business relationship
Are there any laws or regulations that relate specifically to foreign joint venture parties?
In certain sectors affecting national defence or likely to jeopardize public order and activities essential to Poland’s interests, foreign investments are subject to a prior authorization procedure. As the authorization requirement applies predominantly to acquisitions of an interest in companies already: (i) holding certain critical public infrastructure and/or (ii) exceeding the annual turnover de minimis threshold (EUR 10m), the requirement may be unlikely to apply to establishing a new joint venture in Poland (although should be taken into consideration in the context of a future divestment)
Subject to certain exemptions, investors who are not based/resident in the European Economic Area are required to obtain the prior permission of the Polish Minister of Internal Affairs in order to acquire: (i) ownership of or right of perpetual usufruct to a real property in Poland or (ii) a controlling stake in a company/entity owning or holding right of perpetual usufruct to a real property in Poland
Contacts
Agnieszka Braciszewska
Partner
[email protected]
+48 22 581 4946
Artur Jończyk
Counsel
[email protected]
+48 22 581 4985
Saudi Arabia
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
What are the common forms that joint ventures take in your jurisdiction?
There is no prescribed form for a joint venture under KSA law. The most common forms are:
Limited liability company (LLC)
Closed joint stock company (CJSC)
Whilst using a LLC is a popular choice for foreign investors, due to its flexibility and ease of establishment, some investors opt for a CJSC to enable them to freely trade their shares, this is particularly useful for larger ventures which requires an element of public investment.
A relatively new legal entity form was introduced by the new Companies Law (from 2023): the Simplified Joint Stock Company (SJSC). This is a hybrid between an LLC and CJSC. As it is new, they have not be used much in practice yet, however SJSCs are designed to be a more streamlined and adaptable option for companies looking for the benefits of a CJSC structure without its complexities.
What laws in your jurisdiction will apply to a joint venture?
There are no laws in KSA which relate specifically to joint ventures
Joint ventures in KSA will be subject to the Companies Law, Sharia, Civil Transaction Law, Tax Laws, Competition Law, Foreign Investment Laws (if an international entity is a shareholder), Intellectual Property Laws, Labor Law, Civil Procedure Law, Bankruptcy Laws, and any other law that regulates the practice sector of the joint venture
Nothing precludes the parties from agreeing to English or other governing laws, however, it is increasingly common to see KSA as the chosen governing law, especially with the increasing investments made by Saudi government owned entities.
Is there an obligation under the law of your jurisdiction to disclose the ultimate ownership of a joint venture entity?
There is no direct requirement to disclose the ultimate beneficiary of the joint venture entity at the incorporation stage, except for direct (one level up) ownership. However, banks and other financing entities would usually ask for the purpose of KYC the ultimate ownership details of such entity,
If the joint venture requires competition clearance, the anti-trust authority will want to know the ultimate ownership information.
LLCs are required to obtain governmental approvals before any changes happen to the share register/ledger, such information is not publicly available, however can be requested for a minimal fees.
CJSCs and SJSCs are required to maintain a share register, and periodically update the same online via the Ministry of Commerce (MOC) portal. Such information is not publicly available.
How does the law in your jurisdiction impact the governance arrangements and decision-making processes of a joint venture?
An LLC is required to have articles of association (Articles) that set out various provisions, including corporate governance. The Articles are prepared based on a template prepared by the MOC. The template allows some degree of flexibility particularly in relation to corporate governance
A CJSC and a SJSC have both Articles and by-laws. Similar to an LLC, these corporate documents are prepared using a template prepared by the MOC
It is common for shareholders to have a joint venture agreement (JVA) or shareholders’ agreement (SHA) that provides additional details regarding corporate governance. This is because, as mentioned above, the MOC requires the shareholders to use its template. Shareholders generally supplement the Articles and by-laws with a JVA or SHA
While SHAs and similar agreements were not explicitly recognised or enforceable under the old Companies’ legislation, if the provisions are not mentioned under the Articles, ( from 2023) the new Companies’ Law now recognises and allows for the inclusion of binding agreements like SHAs and family charters within the Articles of companies, as long as it does not conflict with the law
Directors of all available entities type are subject to extensive obligations that are similar to what would be seen in other jurisdictions such as the USA and UK, however the obligations on directors of an LLC tend to be lighter
The Companies Law, broadly imposes fiduciary duties towards the company and shareholder and in particular addresses the following aspect as part of the overall obligations of the Directors to exercise their duty of care and loyalty:
carrying out his duties within the scope of his powers;
acting in the interest of the company and promoting its success;
making decisions or voting independently thereon;
exercising reasonable and expected due diligence, skill, and care;
avoiding conflict of interest;
disclosing any direct or indirect interest he has in the transactions conducted and the contracts concluded for the company’s account; and
not accepting any benefit granted thereto by third parties in relation to his role in the company.
How do the joint venture parties usually exercise control over the activities of the joint venture in your jurisdiction?
Decisions on certain matters will be reserved to a decision of the shareholders under KSA law, for example matters relating to a limited company’s constitution and share capital;
Additional matters may be reserved for the special approval (or veto) of a certain percentage of shareholders or directors (or specifically identified shareholders or directors);
The Board of Directors will make day-to day decisions; the directors will usually have been appointed by the shareholders based on the level of interest in the joint venture;
The joint venture company is likely to be run by an executive manager/chief executive officer with specific delegated authority either from the Shareholders or the Board to make certain decisions
Are there protections under the law of your jurisdiction for joint venture parties with a minority interest?
Shareholders of an LLC may assert their rights in the following ways:
Certain decisions, as a matter of company law, require unanimous shareholder approval. For an LLC, this includes (i) changing the nationality of the LLC and (ii) increasing the share capital by increasing the nominal value of the parties shares (iii) the limitation of any pre-emption right . Moreover, though not expressly provided for, the dissolution of a LLC also requires the unanimous approval of the shareholders;
75% shareholder approval is required for amending the Articles of an LLC, and to increase the Company capital (unless the shareholders agree to a lower threshold);
Setting forth a particular requirement in relation to having a valid quorum (must be at least a simple majority though it may be agreed to be a higher threshold);
The right of directors and a certain percentage of the shareholders to call a board meeting.
Shareholders of a CJSC and a SJSC may assert their rights in the following ways:
Setting forth specific requirements in relation to valid quorums for general meetings (25 percent) and extraordinary meetings (at least 50 percent). Shareholders may agree to have higher thresholds for both general and extraordinary meetings;
Decisions at general meetings require at least a simple majority of the shareholders present at a validly constituted meeting. Decisions at an extraordinary meeting require the approval of at least two thirds of the shares present at a validly constituted meeting except for (i) decisions relating to the amendment of the share capital; (ii) dissolution or (iii) a merger, which requires the approval of three quarters of the share capital present at an extraordinary meeting.
Are there restrictions on contributing to or on distributing assets or cash from a joint venture entity in your jurisdiction?
There are minimal restrictions under law on contributing assets to a joint venture entity although tax and accounting advice should always be sought. Any asset contribution for a CJSC would need to be valued by an accredited valuer and subsequently approved by the extraordinary general assembly.
LLCs and SJSCs can choose to be exempted from appointing an accredited valuer if the asset contributed is considered less than 50% of the share capital of the company.
LLCs CJSCs and a SJSCs are not restricted from distribution of profits unless, they state under the company constitutional documents i.e. Bylaw or Articles of Association that they will be contributing part of the profits to a reserve for up to a certain threshold is met.
How do joint venture parties most commonly resolve disputes in your jurisdiction?
There are no restrictions on the method of dispute resolution chosen by the parties to a joint venture;
Joint venture agreements may have some matters which are resolved by expert determination (such as value on exit) whilst others will be referred to arbitration or the courts;
What does your jurisdiction offer parties setting up a joint venture there?
Access to the largest market in the Arab world;
Relatively easy to obtain foreign investment licensing;
Potential funding for industrial activities and large projects established in certain areas.
Are there any laws or regulations that relate specifically to foreign joint venture parties?
Foreign investment is not treated differently from domestic investment under current legislation;
All entities operating in KSA are subject to Saudization, which basically relates to employing a certain number of KSA nationals.
Contacts
Mohammed Altammami
Partner
+966 (56) 5511550
[email protected]
Singapore
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
What are the common forms that joint ventures take in your jurisdiction?
There is no prescribed form for a joint venture under Singapore law. The most common forms are:
Private company limited by shares (a private company)
Partnerships (including limited partnerships (LPs) and limited liability partnerships (LLPs))
Contractual/unincorporated joint venture (with no separate corporate vehicle)
What laws in your jurisdiction will apply to a joint venture?
There are no laws in Singapore which relate specifically to joint ventures
Joint ventures in Singapore will be subject to company law, partnership law, common law as well as tax, competition, intellectual property and financial services regulation (amongst others) as well as the provisions of the contracts entered into between the joint venture parties
Where international entities are considering setting up a joint venture in Singapore, it is advisable to consider the laws of their home jurisdictions as well, for example, an arrangement that is not characterised as a partnership in Singapore may be viewed as a partnership elsewhere
Is there an obligation under the law of your jurisdiction to disclose the ultimate ownership of a joint venture entity?
Private companies and LLPs are required to keep and maintain a register of persons with significant control which is primarily used for purposes of know-your-client checks, anti-money laundering and combating the financing of terrorism procedures
Partnerships, LPs and contractual joint ventures would not be subject to the aforementioned regime
How does the law in your jurisdiction impact the governance arrangements and decision-making processes of a joint venture?
Directors of a private company are subject to fiduciary duties (many of which are codified in the Companies Act 1967 of Singapore), including the duties to avoid conflicts of interest, to promote the best interests of the company as a whole and to exercise independent judgment, as well as reasonable care, skill and diligence in the performance of their duties
Singapore law includes the concept of shadow directors (who are held to the same standard as other directors under law), which may include a shareholder of the company, if the directors of the joint venture are accustomed to act in accordance with the instructions of that shareholder (or other person)
If a joint venture company is party to the joint venture agreement, the joint venture company should not agree to any governance arrangements or decision-making processes that would fetter the directors’ discretion
How do the joint venture parties usually exercise control over the activities of the joint venture in your jurisdiction?
Decisions on certain matters are reserved to a decision of the shareholders under company law, for example matters relating to a private company’s constitution and share capital
Additional matters may be reserved for the special approval (or veto) of a certain percentage of shareholders or directors (or specifically identified shareholders or directors) by contract
Board of directors will make day-to-day decisions for and on behalf of the joint venture company; the directors will usually have been appointed by the shareholders based on the level of shareholding interest in the joint venture company
A joint venture company is likely to be run by a management team with specific delegated authority from the board of directors to make certain decisions
Partnerships (including LPs and LLPs) do not have the same restrictions as to governance and decision-making and the procedures will generally be set out in the relevant partnership agreement
Are there protections under the law of your jurisdiction for joint venture parties with a minority interest?
Shareholders of a private company, in particular, minority shareholders, may assert their rights in the following ways:
Certain decisions, as a matter of company law, require 75% shareholder approval and therefore a minority interest in excess of 25% will be able to block those decisions (for example changing the constitution, reducing share capital or voluntarily winding up the company)
Shareholders are able to present an unfair prejudice petition if the affairs of the company are being conducted in a manner which unfairly prejudices their interests (s. 216 Companies Act 1967 of Singapore)
A minority shareholder may bring a derivative action on behalf of the company against a director who has acted improperly in specific ways (s. 216A Companies Act 1967 of Singapore)
Shareholders representing at least 10% of the total number of paid-up shares carrying the right to vote at general meetings can require that the directors convene a general meeting of the company (s.176 Companies Act 1967 of Singapore)
Shareholders holding not less than 5% of the total voting rights or comprising at least 100 shareholders holding shares on which there has been an average sum paid up, per member, of at least SGD500, can requisition the company to circulate, notice of resolutions concerning the matters which the shareholders intend to table at that meeting along with a statement of the matters referred to therein (s.183 Companies Act 1967 of Singapore)
Two or more members holding not less than 10% of the total number of issued shares of a company may call a meeting of the company (s.177 Companies Act 1967 of Singapore)
Are there restrictions on contributing to or on distributing assets or cash from a joint venture entity in your jurisdiction?
It is possible to contribute assets to a joint venture entity although tax and accounting advice should always be sought
There are restrictions under law preventing shareholders from extracting cash or assets from a private company where it could impact the rights of creditors
A private company requires sufficient profit to be able to make distributions to shareholders out of profits, and may only distribute capital by following a prescribed procedure applicable to private companies under company law
Directors of private companies have a fiduciary duty to ensure that the company retains sufficient resources to pay the company’s debts as they fall due
Joint venture parties may choose to fund the joint venture company by way of shareholder loans to allow value to be realised by way of interest payments on the loan and to facilitate cash extraction
How do joint venture parties most commonly resolve disputes in your jurisdiction?
There are no restrictions on the method of dispute resolution chosen by the parties to a joint venture
Joint venture agreements may have some matters which are resolved by expert determination (such as value on exit), some matters which are addressed via escalation to senior shareholder representatives (such as deadlock) and others will be referred to mediation, arbitration or the courts for resolution
Majority shareholders may wish to be able to call upon other shareholders to sell their shares under certain circumstances (for example if a minority shareholder is blocking the company’s decision making processes by causing deadlock)
Minority shareholders may wish to be able to put their shares on the company or other shareholders (even for a nominal amount) under certain circumstances (for example to protect their reputation in the event of regulatory breach)
What does your jurisdiction offer parties setting up a joint venture there?
Tried and tested joint venture structures
Low-tax regime designed to attract investment
Access to capital markets and funding
Freedom of contract
Efficient and reliable dispute resolution regime
Are there any laws or regulations that relate specifically to foreign joint venture parties?
Foreign investment is not treated differently from domestic investment under current legislation (except in some specific sectors such as broadcasting)
Significant investments in, and control of, certain critical entities are regulated in order to protect the national interests of Singapore. Notification to the relevant authority is required at such time that a shareholding threshold of 5% of certain designated entities is acquired, and prior approval of the relevant authority will be required before any acquisition resulting in an increased shareholding interest beyond each of 12%, 25% and 50% (Significant Investments Review Act 2024 of Singapore)
Contacts
Craig Loveless
Partner
[email protected]
+65 6309 5338
Turkey
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
What are the common forms that joint ventures take in your jurisdiction?
There is no prescribed form for a joint venture under Turkish law. The most common forms are:
Ordinary partnership (adi ortaklık)
Limited company (limited şirket)
Joint stock company (anonim şirket)
What laws in your jurisdiction will apply to a joint venture?
If the joint venture is formed as an unincorporated entity, the provisions of the Turkish Code of Obligations (TCO) in relation to ordinary partnerships apply
If the joint venture is formed as an incorporated entity, the provisions of the Turkish Commercial Code (TCC) in relation to the relevant business form (i.e. limited company or joint stock company, as the case may be) apply
In addition, among other things, tax, competition, intellectual property, public-private partnerships and public tender laws will also apply where relevant
Is there an obligation under the law of your jurisdiction to disclose the ultimate ownership of a joint venture entity?
Ordinary partnerships are not required to be registered with a public registry and, therefore, disclose their ultimate ownership
Limited companies and joint stock companies are required to be registered with the trade registry. However, there is no requirement to disclose ultimate ownership to the trade registry for registration purposes
Certain sector-specific regulations (e.g. energy, telecommunications, payment services, etc.) require the disclosure of the ultimate owner(s) to the relevant public authority for licensing purposes
How does the law in your jurisdiction impact the governance arrangements and decision-making processes of a joint venture?
In ordinary partnerships, management rights belong to all partners, unless the management of the partnership is left only to one or more partners or to a third party by contract or by the partners’ decision. Moreover, partnership decisions will be taken unanimously by all partners unless otherwise agreed to by all partners
As a general rule, shareholders of limited companies and joint stock companies, may include specific provisions in relation to the governance of the company and the decision-making procedures in the articles of association of the company but this is to the extent permitted under the TCC
How do the joint venture parties usually exercise control over the activities of the joint venture in your jurisdiction?
The answer varies depending on the form the JV parties choose, but the general rule of thumb is that the JV’s activities are under the control of those who manage the JV, that is, the partners in an ordinary partnership, and the management bodies in joint stock and limited companies
If the JV is an ordinary partnership: If not delegated to specific persons, each and all of the partners are entitled to exercise control over the JV, but each partner may object to any exercise of control by another partner. While appointing a third party to exercise control over the JV’s activities as well as carrying out extraordinary activities on behalf of the JV requires a unanimous decision by all partners, if there are time constraints, each partner is authorized to exercise singular control over the JV’s activities
If the JV is incorporated as a limited company: Exercise of control is typically possible through the board of managers (müdürler kurulu), who are in turn supervised, from time to time, by the limited company’s shareholders. Although the board of managers is an independent management organ of the limited company, shareholders may have indirect control over the board of directors, in particular, through the appointment of the members of the board of managers and the approval of the activities of the board annually
If the JV is incorporated as a joint stock company: Exercise of control is typically possible through the board of directors (yönetim kurulu). The board of directors may or may not be constituted from shareholders, who, in turn, supervise the board of directors. Although the board of directors is an independent management organ of the joint stock company, shareholders may have an indirect control over the board of directors, in particular, through the appointment of the members of the board of directors and the approval of the activities of the board annually
Are there protections under the law of your jurisdiction for joint venture parties with a minority interest?
Any shareholder, regardless of the number of shares, may petition the company’s board to request information. If the request is denied on grounds that the company would be disclosing commercial secrets, the shareholder may object to that denial before the courts within 10 days
Shareholders representing 10% of the total share capital (i.e. minority shareholders) may demand that the board convenes a general assembly meeting
Other key rights enjoyed by minority shareholders include, postponement of general assembly meetings, refusal of the board members’ request to be released from all obligations, and requesting the liquidation of the company through termination on just grounds, which includes allegations that majority shareholders are misusing the company to advance their own interests
Many important decisions in joint stock companies may be taken by an affirmative vote of shares representing 3/4 of the total capital, which provides minority shareholders considerable influence in the decision-making process. These decisions include, among other things, decreasing the company’s share capital, changing its purpose, and creating preferred share rights
Are there restrictions on contributing to or on distributing assets or cash from a joint venture entity in your jurisdiction?
In ordinary partnerships, there are no restrictions on contributing to or on distributing assets or cash from a joint venture although tax and accounting advice should always be sought. That being said, each partner has a contribution requirement which must be fulfilled either in cash or through contribution of an asset or assignment of a receivable or by providing services (e.g. the provision of labour)
In limited companies and joint stock companies, contributions of cash or assets may take place either during incorporation or by successive capital increases. Any item contributed to the JV as “non-cash capital” must be transferrable and free from encumbrances. Non-cash capital must be valued by an expert appointed by the commercial court. Personal services, receivables not yet due or goodwill may not be contributed as capital to limited and joint stock companies
Limited companies and joint stock companies can also distribute cash through dividend distributions.
It is possible for a shareholder to borrow money from the company and for the shareholder to lend to the company under certain conditions and subject to the advisability of tax and accounting advice
How do joint venture parties most commonly resolve disputes in your jurisdiction?
There are no restrictions on the method of dispute resolution which may be chosen by the JV parties
JV agreements may refer to local or international arbitration for dispute resolution. Note that Turkish law requires arbitration agreements to be in writing (wet ink signature or secured electronic signature) and the choice of arbitration to be exclusive and clear
It also is quite common to refer to expert determination (i.e. value on exit, indemnification) or mediation for the settlement of any kind of dispute
In addition, under TCC, a majority shareholder owning at least ninety percent of its subsidiary’s shares, can buy the shares of the minority shareholder under certain circumstances (for example if a minority shareholder blocks the operation of the company or acts against the rule of honesty) and put and call mechanisms may also be introduced in the event of disputes
What does your jurisdiction offer parties setting up a joint venture there?
Government incentive schemes across a variety of sectors and geographic regions
Similarity of Turkish laws with European continental laws
Local arbitration centers
Educated workforce
High potential of the country
Are there any laws or regulations that relate specifically to foreign joint venture parties?
Foreign investment is not treated differently from domestic investment under current legislation, although there are certain restrictions on foreign real persons and legal entities in various sectors, as outlined below
If the JV is incorporated outside Turkey it may only acquire property as defined in applicable legislation, including the Law on Tourism Incentives, the Law on Industrial Zones, and the Law on Petroleum
If the JV is incorporated in Turkey with more than 50% of its shares owned by foreign shareholders, or if foreign shareholders have the authority to appoint or dismiss the majority of the company’s board of directors, then the JV may acquire property in Turkey only for the purpose of carrying out the activities set out its articles of association
Other restrictions on foreign JV parties may be found throughout Turkish law, the most notable of which include (i) the requirement that foreign owned shares in a private media services (e.g. television, radio, and on-demand streaming) company, which must be incorporated as a joint stock company, do not exceed 50%, (ii) the related requirement that foreign real or legal person own direct shares in up to two such companies and not more and (iii) the requirement that a range of maritime activities within Turkey’s territorial waters, including the exploitation of their natural resources, should be conducted by real or legal persons of Turkish citizenship
Contacts
Utku Ünver
Partner, Istanbul
[email protected]
+90 212 386 1315
Ayşe Yüksel Mahfoud
Global Head of Corporate, M&A and Securities
[email protected]
+90 (212) 3861310
United Arab Emirates
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
What are the common forms that joint ventures take in your jurisdiction?
The most common vehicle for a UAE onshore joint venture is a limited liability company (LLC). The UAE Companies Law requires that at least 51 per cent of the shares in an LLC are held by a UAE national, however, the respective entitlements to profits and losses of an LLC do not need to be the same as the respective shareholdings in an LLC (see question 7 below)
It should be noted that different answers would apply to a joint venture company incorporated in one of the many free zones in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) (including the Dubai International Financial Centre and the Abu Dhabi Global Market) where different regulations or laws apply. Further, it is now possible under the UAE’s Foreign Direct Investment Law for a foreign company/foreign companies to apply to the competent authorities to hold up to 100 per cent of the shares in an LLC carrying out activities in certain specified sectors
What laws in your jurisdiction will apply to a joint venture?
Where one of the parties to the joint venture is a foreign company, the parties may choose English law as the governing law of the joint venture agreement. However, the contract will still be subject to mandatory provisions of UAE law which apply to an LLC. These include (among others) provisions in the UAE Companies Law, regulatory laws, competition laws, tax laws and employment law. It should be noted that the competent authorities only permit UAE nationals to carry out certain activities in the UAE, for example, commercial agency, certain real estate activities and insurance. Also, certain activities require additional regulatory approval (over and above the standard licensing approvals from the competent authorities), for example, healthcare, education and certain oil and gas related activities
Where all the parties to an onshore UAE joint venture are foreign (non UAE national) companies, the joint venture vehicle may often be incorporated offshore (Newco). The overall joint venture arrangements will still require the establishment of an LLC by Newco, and in most cases Newco will need to appoint a professional UAE national company to hold 51 per cent of the shares in the LLC (as Newco’s nominee)
Is there an obligation under the law of your jurisdiction to disclose the ultimate ownership of a joint venture entity?
No. Under the UAE Companies Law, LLCs are required to maintain a register of partners (the equivalent of a “shareholder” under English law) and their respective shareholdings, and an updated register must be filed with the competent authority each year. This information is not, however, publicly available
How does the law in your jurisdiction impact the governance arrangements and decision-making processes of a joint venture?
The management of an LLC is undertaken by one of more manager(s) (the equivalent of a “director” under English law) appointed by the partners of the LLC. The appointment can be set out in the LLC’s Memorandum of Association (MOA), or the partners can appoint (a) manager(s) by contract. If there is more than one manager, the partners can appoint a board of directors (Board). The manager or Board will have the powers set out in the MOA
The manager or members of the Board is/are liable towards the LLC, the partners and third parties for any acts of fraud, abuse of power, breach of the Companies Law, breach of the MOA or negligent acts. Any agreement to the contrary in the MOA or a commercial agreement is invalid. In circumstances where a decision of the Board is passed by a majority, a manager will not be held liable if the manager objected to the decision and confirmed this in writing in the minutes of the Board meeting
How do the joint venture parties usually exercise control over the activities of the joint venture in your jurisdiction?
While the parties are free to agree a set of reserved matters in a joint venture agreement, it is not typically possible for the majority of a typical set of reserved matters to be included in the LLC’s MOA. This is because the competent authorities usually require that an MOA follows a standard template based on the UAE Companies Law. The most likely remedy for breach of a reserved matter will be a damages claim for breach of contract. Injunctive relief is prohibitively difficult to obtain in the UAE Courts
Because of the procedural requirements in the UAE, all the partners in an LLC will need to approve a transfer of shares, any change to the LLC’s share capital, any amendment to the MOA, the dissolution of the LLC and the removal or appointment of a manager named/or to be named in the MOA. The manager or the Board will be responsible for the management of the LLC in accordance with the powers given to them in the MOA
The LLC is typically run on a day to day basis by a General Manager appointed by the manager or the Board who will exercise the powers granted to him under a notarised power of attorney granted by the partners of the LLC
Are there protections under the law of your jurisdiction for joint venture parties with a minority interest?
As mentioned above, because of the procedural requirements in the UAE, all the partners in an LLC will need to approve a transfer of shares, any change to the LLC’s share capital, any amendment to the MOA, the dissolution of the LLC and the removal or appointment of a manager named/or to be named in the MOA. Also, under Article 164 of the Companies Law, one or more partners holding at least 5% of the shares in an LLC can petition the competent authority (and, if the competent authority rejects the application or fails to act, the Courts), to issue a resolution if the partner(s) believe that the affairs of the LLC are being or have been conducted to the detriment of any partner(s), or that the LLC intends to act or to omit an act which may cause damage to such partner(s). The Courts can annul any such act
Are there restrictions on contributing to or on distributing assets or cash from a joint venture entity in your jurisdiction?
The Companies Law of UAE provides for share capital to be paid in cash or in kind. However, the latter is uncommon due to the procedural rules applicable to such contributions. The distribution of cash dividends is most common in the UAE. Partners can agree to distribute profits and losses in a ratio which is different from their share ownership in the LLC. In Dubai, a minority partner may (currently) be entitled to a maximum of 80 per cent of the profits. An LLC must allocate at least 10 per cent of its net profits to a legal reserve. However, the partners may resolve to suspend such contributions once the legal reserve equals half of the LLC’s share capital. The joint venture parties may choose to fund the LLC by way of partner loans to allow value to be released by way of interest payments on the loans to make the extraction of cash easier. Tax and accounting advice should be sought prior to implementing any such arrangements
How do joint venture parties most commonly resolve disputes in your jurisdiction?
Where one of the joint venture partners is a foreign company, there are no restrictions on the method of dispute resolution. The parties have a number of different options in respect of domestic and international arbitration and UAE court dispute resolution mechanisms. A party should seek tailored advice to protect its rights for the optimum outcome in terms of enforcing its rights
What does your jurisdiction offer parties setting up a joint venture there?
With the relatively recent introduction of the Foreign Direct Investment Law in 2018, the UAE government is seeking to attract foreign investment by allowing larger shareholdings (up to 100%) in certain sectors. Also, the UAE has long been regarded as a tax favourable jurisdiction as the government has not historically, and does not currently, levy corporate income taxes on most companies operating in the UAE (with some exceptions, including foreign banks and certain companies operating in the oil and gas sector)
Are there any laws or regulations that relate specifically to foreign joint venture parties?
Other than the Foreign Direct Investment Law there are no laws that relate specifically to foreign companies participating in joint ventures
Contacts
Adjou Ait Ben Idir
Partner
[email protected]
+971 4 369 6393
United Kingdom
Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below. Some kind of longer intro text here to set the scene for the entire section, possibly drawing out some of the highlights from this region. Making a solid intro for the detail which follows below.
What are the common forms that joint ventures take in your jurisdiction?
There is no prescribed form of a joint venture under English law. The most common forms are:
Private company limited by shares
Partnerships (including limited liability partnerships)
Contractual/unincorporated joint venture (with no separate corporate vehicle)
What laws in your jurisdiction will apply to a joint venture?
There are no laws in the UK which relate exclusively to joint ventures
Joint ventures in the UK will be subject to company law, partnership law, common law as well as tax, competition, intellectual property and financial regulation (amongst others) as well as the provisions of the contracts entered into between the joint venture parties
Depending how it is structured, a joint venture may qualify for a merger control review by the UK Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) or parties may need to self-assess whether their joint venture is compatible with the general competition law rules prohibiting anti-competitive agreements.
Where international entities are considering setting up a joint venture in the UK, it is advisable to consider the laws of their home jurisdictions as well, for example, an arrangement that is not characterised as a partnership in the UK may be viewed as a partnership elsewhere , and merger control approvals may be triggered in other jurisdictions (in particular, where the joint venture or its parents have activities or turnover).
Is there an obligation under the law of your jurisdiction to disclose the ultimate ownership of a joint venture entity?
Limited companies and LLPs are required to keep and maintain a public register of persons with significant control (PSCs), which can include registrable relevant legal entities (RLEs)
When s64 Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023 (ECCTA) comes into force (introducing changes to the Companies Act 2006 (CA 2006)), registrable PSCs and RLEs will additionally be subject to new identity verification requirements. As part of this, each registerable RLE will be obliged to nominate and verify the identity of a “relevant officer” (a director of the company) and provide a statement relating to this to the Registrar of Companies (Registrar), together with a statement from the relevant officer; registrable RLEs must ensure that their relevant officer (as notified to the Registrar) maintains their identity verified status for as long as the RLE is registered as such with the Registrar.
In addition, once the relevant provisions of ECCTA are in force, an individual must not act as a director of a company unless their identity has been verified. It will not only be an offence for an individual to act as a director in contravention of this requirement, but an offence will also be committed by the relevant company and every officer in default if such company fails to prevent an individual from acting as a director unless their identity has been verified
ECCTA is also introducing changes to the legislation governing limited partnerships (LPs) in the UK. Once implemented, these changes will require general partners that are legal entities to specify the name or names of a proposed registered officer and that registered officer must have their identity verified
Partnerships and contractual joint ventures would not be subject to the same regime
How does the law in your jurisdiction impact the governance arrangements and decision-making processes of a joint venture?
Directors of a limited company are subject to fiduciary duties (many of which are codified in the Companies Act 2006), including the duties to avoid conflicts of interest, to promote the success of the company for the benefit of its members and to exercise independent judgment, as well as reasonable care, skill and diligence in the performance of their duties
English law includes the concept of shadow and de facto directors (who are held to the same standard as other directors under law), which may include a shareholder of the company, if the directors of the joint venture are accustomed to act in accordance with the instructions of that shareholder (or other person)
If a joint venture company is party to the joint venture agreement, the joint venture company should not agree to any governance arrangements or decision-making processes that would fetter the company’s statutory powers
How do the joint venture parties usually exercise control over the activities of the joint venture in your jurisdiction?
Decisions on certain matters will be reserved to a decision of the shareholders at law, for example matters relating to a limited company’s constitution and share capital
Additional matters may be reserved for the special approval (or veto) of a certain percentage of shareholders or directors (or specifically identified shareholders or directors)
The company's board of directors will make day-to day decisions and in a joint venture context the directors will usually have been appointed by the shareholders based on the level of interest in the joint venture
Depending on the extent of its autonomy, the joint venture company may be run by a management team with specific delegated authority from the Board to make certain decisions
Partnerships (including LLPs) do not have the same restrictions as to governance and decision-making and such procedures will generally be set out in the relevant partnership agreement
Are there protections under the law of your jurisdiction for joint venture parties with a minority interest?
Shareholders of a limited company, in particular, minority shareholders, may assert their rights in the following ways:
Certain decisions as a matter of company law require 75% shareholder approval and therefore a minority interest in excess of 25% will be able to block those decisions (for example changing the articles of association, reducing share capital or voluntarily winding up the company)
Subject to certain conditions being satisfied, shareholders may be able to present an unfair prejudice petition if the affairs of the company are being conducted in a manner which unfairly prejudices their interests (s. 994 Companies Act 2006)
A minority shareholder may be able to bring a derivative action on behalf of the company against a director who has acted improperly in specific ways (Part 11 Companies Act 2006)
A minority shareholder may apply to wind up a company where it is just an equitable to do so, even if the company is solvent (s. 122(1)(g) Insolvency Act 1986)
Shareholders representing at least 5% of the voting rights can require that the directors convene a general meeting of the company (s. 303 Companies Act 2006)
Shareholders of a traded company may require an answer to a question put to a general meeting which relates to the business of the meeting (s. 319 of the Companies Act 2006)
Are there restrictions on contributing to or on distributing assets or cash from a joint venture entity in your jurisdiction?
There are no restrictions at law regarding contributing assets to a joint venture entity although tax and accounting advice should always be sought
There are restrictions at law preventing shareholders from extracting cash or assets from a limited company which are designed to protect the rights of creditors
A private limited company requires sufficient distributable reserves to be able to make cash distributions to shareholders out of its profits, and may only distribute capital by following a prescribed procedure under the Companies Act 2006
Joint venture parties may choose to fund the joint venture company by way of shareholder loans to allow value to be realised by way of interest payments on the loan and to make cash extraction easier
How do joint venture parties most commonly resolve disputes in your jurisdiction?
There are no restrictions on the method of dispute resolution chosen by the parties to a joint venture
Joint venture agreements may have some matters which are resolved by expert determination (such as value on exit), some matters which are addressed via escalation (such as deadlock) and others will be referred to mediation, arbitration or the courts
Majority shareholders may wish to be able to call upon other shareholders to sell their shares under certain circumstances (for example if a minority shareholder is blocking the company’s decision-making processes by causing deadlock)
Minority shareholders may wish to be able to put their shares on the company or other shareholders (even for a nominal amount) under certain circumstances (for example to protect their reputation in the event of regulatory breach)
What does your jurisdiction offer parties setting up a joint venture there?
Tried and tested joint venture structures
Low-tax regime designed to attract investment
Access to capital markets and funding
Freedom of contract
Familiarity of international parties with English law
Are there any laws or regulations that relate specifically to foreign joint venture parties?
Yes. The National Security and Investment Act (NSI Act), (in force from January 2022) reflects a global trend for more intervention in and scrutiny of national security issues
The NSI Act represented a significant expansion of the types of transactions covered by national security reviews – moving beyond mergers and acquisitions to include a much broader range of deals including minority investments, acquisitions of voting rights and acquisitions of assets including land and IP.
To fall within the regime the target entity or asset must be from, in or have a sufficient connection with the UK. A qualifying entity must carry on activities in the UK or supply goods or services to persons in the UK, and a qualifying asset must be used in connection with activities carried on in the UK or the supply of goods or services to persons in the UK.
Failure to comply may result in heavy sanctions including turnover-based fines and criminal liability, as well as the risk of transactions subject to mandatory notification being void
The regime falls into two parts: (a) a mandatory regime; and (b) a voluntary regime. The mandatory regime requires qualifying transactions to be notified for approval before they take place. The voluntary regime allows parties to submit transactions for approval
The test for a mandatory notification is broadly in two parts: (a) there needs to be a trigger event; and (b) the transaction needs to involve a target entity active in a qualifying sector (of which there are 17 – set out in a statutory instrument – and include defence, energy, transport, advanced robotics and quantum technologies)
The trigger events for mandatory notification are:
The acquisition of more than 25 per cent, more than 50 per cent, or 75 per cent or more of the voting rights or shares in a qualifying entity.
The acquisition of voting rights enabling or preventing the passage of any class of resolution governing the affairs of the qualifying entity.
These may be relevant on the inception of a joint venture and also where interests change over the life of the joint venture, for example in default or exit scenarios. Note also that transactions are caught regardless of the nationality of the acquirer, so in addition to transactions involving foreign acquirers, relevant transactions by UK acquirers can also require approval.
Transactions can also be reviewed under the Enterprise Act 2002 (EA02) on certain “public interest” or “special public interest” grounds. Such reviews are relatively rare, but could apply to foreign acquirers (e.g. considerations include the need for accurate presentation of the news and free expression of opinion in newspapers, maintaining the stability of the UK financial system, and maintaining in the UK the capability to combat and mitigate the effects of public health emergencies).
The EA02 also includes a new prohibition on foreign state powers gaining control or influence over UK newspaper enterprises, recently added by the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (DMCC Act). The DMCC Act also introduces a new digital regulatory regime for large firms designated as having “Strategic Market Status” in respect of one or more digital activities (so-called “SMS firms”), which includes new mandatory merger reporting obligations including for certain joint ventures.
Contacts
Chris Randall
Partner
[email protected]
+44 20 7444 3642
Chris Grieves
Partner
[email protected]
+44 20 7444 3842
Victoria Scopes
Counsel
[email protected]
+44 20 7444 2494